The high - stakes system has led to a «
narrowing of the curriculum with a focus on English and maths at the expense of other subjects like science, humanities and the arts», Carmichael adds.
Not exact matches
Interestingly, the committee's conclusion
with respect to exit exams does not pick up on the full report's emphasis on the importance
of the design features
of incentive systems, which include warnings that tests aimed at ensuring minimum competency may lower expectations, and concerns about both the potential
narrowing of the
curriculum and the tendency for score inflation on a known test.
During stakeholder consultations, educators raised concerns the assessments would be an extra burden to teachers already struggling
with a hefty workload, lead to a possible
narrowing of the
curriculum, and cause stress for students and parents.
In the meantime, millions
of students will face a
narrower curriculum, larger classes, crumbling buildings and the erosion
of extra-curricular activities as schools cope
with over # 3 billion in real terms cuts.
This
narrowing of the
curriculum can have an effect on teachers» stress levels because it clashes
with their beliefs, according to Brian Apter, chair
of the division
of educational and child psychologists at the British Psychological Society.
Race to the Bottom Michael McGill Focusing on the push over the past few decades to «save» the nation's schools by applying rigorous business strategies, Michael McGill, M.A.T.» 67, C.A.S.» 70, Ed.D.» 72, a former superintendent, argues that corporate reform has actually weakened public schools,
with narrower curriculums and a slashing
of «nonessentials» like art and languages.
The Chinese national educational system has won high praise as an efficient system
with national standards, a
narrow curriculum, a high - stakes test (the college entrance exam), and a clearly defined set
of gateways to mark students» transitions from one stage to another.
Accountability pressures on teachers, allied
with concerns about inspection and the
narrowing curriculum options
with EBacc are fostering competitive classroom environments where teachers are feeling forced to teach to test and not to the benefit
of learners or their community.
Parents have every right and reason to be concerned
with the deleterious effects
of testing, particularly
curriculum narrowing and excessive time given over to test prep.
Our goal
with this measure is to ensure that schools do not excessively
narrow the
curriculum at the cost
of non-tested subjects and opportunities for enrichment.
The news comes as critics have argued that the
curriculum is a reflection
of the government's «obsession
with a
narrow set
of subjects in a rigid framework» and is likely to damage the chances
of young people who do not follow an academic route into work.
But we all know that this progress came
with some serious unintended consequences: Teaching to the test,
narrowing of the
curriculum, and benign neglect for children at the middle and top
of the performance spectrum.
Instead
of letting each teacher in each school come up
with his or her own
curriculum and approach, resulting in an incoherent and in some cases ineffective system
of instruction, Payzant gradually
narrowed the range
of options for schools and teachers to materials and teaching strategies that he and his teams
of coaches thought worked best for Boston students.
There are warnings from teachers that an excessive emphasis on testing
narrows the
curriculum and reduces creativity,
with the pressure
of school league tables taking precedence over the needs
of individual pupils.
The real threat to national security is squeezing the democracy out
of our schools
with such «reform school» approaches replacing efforts at real school reform, and
with standardized testing
narrowing the
curriculum so that our schools are simply no longer able to produce informed citizens.
So how might all
of us, as citizens
with a stake in our schools, resist the
narrowing of curriculum and students» lives?
Duncan stayed cool under fire, generally agreeing
with Stewart's description
of NCLB's failings, including its role in
narrowing the
curriculum and overemphasizing standardized tests that don't fully capture whether students are prepared for the real world.
Liam Collins head
of Uplands Community College in Wadhurst, East Sussex, said budget pressures amounted to «a cut
of 10 teachers, fewer clubs, no pastoral support, a
narrowed curriculum, no counselling for students struggling
with mental health issues, crumbling buildings, no IT upgrades, no new textbooks and no school planners.
If testing remains, as it has been under No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top, the primary measure
of a quality education, then once again it is the students, their families, communities and ultimately the nation that will be saddled
with the fallout
of a
narrow and alienating
curriculum.
Dr. Steiner, who became education commissioner a year ago, said that the exams had tested a
narrow part
of the
curriculum, particularly in math, and that questions were often repeated year to year,
with a few details changed, so that a student who had taken a practice test — as many teachers have their students do — were likely to do well.
«Those will stay in place
with the
curriculum narrowed for so many pupils as schools work to ensure they reach an ever - rising bar, which means they are not deemed below the floor and labelled as failing,» she said, adding that the time had come to «stop moaning about the test» and «put the nail in the coffin
of testing».
Government accountability measures such as the EBacc have been criticised for
narrowing the
curriculum in schools,
with many seen to be prioritising more academic subjects at the expenses
of creative areas.
However the new primary
curriculum, inspectors found, could risk as
narrowing of the
curriculum —
with teachers highlighting concerns about science, foreign languages and design and technology.
Gordon Lafer, in an in - depth report this year for the Economic Policy Institute (EPI), notes that Rocketship's educational model rests on four strategies: «the replacement
of teachers
with computers for a significant portion
of the day; a reliance on young and inexperienced teachers for the rest
of the day;
narrowing the
curriculum to math and reading
with little attention to other subjects; and even within these subjects, a relentless focus on preparing students for standardized tests.»
However, most
of these tests are multiple choice, standardized measures
of achievement, which have had a number
of unintended consequences, including:
narrowing of the academic
curriculum and experiences
of students (especially in schools serving our most school - dependent children); a focus on recognizing right answers to lower - level questions rather than on developing higher - order thinking, reasoning, and performance skills; and growing dissatisfaction among parents and educators
with the school experience.
With the move towards 90 per cent
of students studying the EBacc by 2025, the result will be an imposition
of uniformity and the
narrowing of the
curriculum.
Inspectors from the watchdog identified a «
narrow Islamic - focused
curriculum» and use
of «misogynistic, homophobic and anti-Semitic material» at three unregistered schools in Birmingham in early November, along
with «serious fire hazards», «unhygienic and filthy conditions» and staff without suitable checks or clearance to work
with children.
My hope is all educators and concerned citizens — and policymakers
with counter-productive,
curriculum -
narrowing mandates — will see that broad, shared knowledge is essential to equality
of opportunity.
For example, we strongly support doing away
with the adequate yearly progress measurement, and agree that requiring states to adopt unreliable test - based principal and teacher evaluation will only lead to an overemphasis on standardized tests and the further
narrowing of the
curriculum.
She was a supporter
of No Child Left Behind, the chief education initiative
of President George W. Bush, until she researched its effects on schools and students and concluded that it led to a
narrowing of curriculum, an obsession
with test prep and demoralized teachers.
Meanwhile, U.S. Secretary
of Education Arne Duncan posed a central question in his speech at the National Council for Social Studies Annual Conference: «How can we promote both a well - rounded education
with rich offerings across all subjects — civics, geography, economics and history, the arts, foreign languages, physical education, the sciences, et cetera — and simultaneously create a system
of real and meaningful accountability that doesn't lead to
narrowing of the
curriculum?»
The No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) has dramatically harmed our local schools
with its over-emphasis on high - stakes testing,
narrowing of the
curriculum, and punitive unfunded mandates that have been especially harmful to schools
with high - needs student populations.
Ruth Wattenberg, the Ward 3 representative on DC's State Board
of Education (SBOE), says «too much testing» and the
narrowing of the
curriculum it has caused were the two issues that had the most resonance
with parents during her campaign.
Similarly to ASA, ASCD is concerned
with the negative effects
of current accountability practices, including «over testing, a
narrowing of the
curriculum, and a de-emphasis
of untested subjects and concepts — the arts, civics, and social and emotional skills, among many others.»
For students in targeted districts, the harm would come from providing their teachers
with preparation that is based on a reductive, behaviorist view
of teaching and learning, and that emphasizes the kind
of techniques shown to
narrow the
curriculum and adversely affect students» socio - emotional development.
Over a decade
of research shows that an over emphasis on high - stakes standardized tests
narrows curriculum, creates social and emotional stress for students and families, drives committed teachers out
of the profession, and turns schools into test - prep factories
with principals forced to comply as overseers — especially in low - scoring schools.
a)
With a focus on the end
of year testing, there inevitably will be a
narrowing of the
curriculum as teachers focus more on test preparation and skill and drill teaching [6].
Echoing arguments made last month in the pages
of the Hill by Schott Foundation President John Jackson, Judith Browne Dianis
of the Advancement Project and wishy - washy education professor Pedro Noguera, Journey for Justice declares
with no evidence that testing and accountability has somehow harmed poor and minority kids as well as supposedly «
narrowed curriculum» (an argument that has been proven false by research from the likes
of the U.S. Department
of Education and Quadrant Arts Education Research's Robert Morrison).
I don't know what teachers she is observing, but the teachers I see in the schools today are the best and brightest I've ever seen — and are doing heroic work in spite
of the most difficult conditions we've ever faced as a profession: meager resources; dwindling budgetary support; a
narrowing of the
curriculum leading to cuts to music, art and PE; withering attacks from Rhee, Kopp, Gates and Duncan and friends; an obsession
with standardized testing; and much more.