The case will consider whether the law against polygamy is consistent with the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and also look at what are
the necessary elements of an offence — that is, whether Section 293 requires that polygamy involve a minor or some other element of abuse or exploitation.
Second, did the trial judge err in the manner in which he assessed
the necessary elements of the offence of failing to comply with a demand to provide a suitable sample
Presumably, the offence will be interpreted by the courts in a way identical to the s 458 offence; notably dishonesty is
a necessary element of the offence.
Oppal asked the Court to answer two questions about Canada's polygamy laws: whether the law is consistent with the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms; and what
the necessary elements of the offence are.
Not exact matches
Dishonesty has never been a
necessary element of analogue
offences steeped in the history
of English criminal law.
Those cases established that if the
offence of outraging public decency was to be proved, it was
necessary to prove two
elements: first, that the act was
of such a lewd character as to outrage public decency; that
element constituted the nature
of the act which had to be proved before the
offence could be established.