If society is expected to buy into the notion that judges are
neutral arbiters of the law, they can't engage in this kind of behaviour, he adds.
The recent decisions of federal district judges Nicholas Garaufis and Shira Scheindlin in cases involving the New York City Fire and Police Departments highlights the importance of the Senate's role in recommending federal judges to the President and in confirming judges who are
neutral arbiters of disputes.
Not exact matches
So, it appears there's something
of a disconnect at Sundance, between the idea
of a perfectly
neutral, non-partisan
arbiter of artistic merit, the festival that focuses on the stories while politically, as Redford put it elsewhere in the press conference, «the pendulum swings,» and the reality
of a filmmaking body that is deeply, sometimes radically, political.
The bet would also need a
neutral arbiter — we propose, for example, the director
of the Hadley Centre, home
of the data used by Keenlyside et al., or a committee
of neutral colleagues.
I'm glad that you bring up the Office
of Special Masters
of the U.S. Court
of Federal Claims, as it is frequently referred to as some sort
of neutral arbiter substantiating anti-vaccination claims.
The construction
of law as the
neutral, objective,
arbiter of social conflicts is, in fact, a gendered construction.
There are further comments in the case about the judge's role as «
neutral, passive
arbiter» (para. 67) and the basically adversarial nature
of the sentencing phase
of a criminal proceeding (ibid.).
At the heart
of this appeal are two potentially competing tensions: (1) the adversarial system, which relies on the parties to frame the issues on appeal, and reserves the role
of neutral arbiter for the courts; and (2) the need for an appellate court to intervene in order to prevent an injustice.
When settlement differences are arbitrated, a
neutral arbiter hears the arguments
of both sides and then makes a final decision.
Rather than keeping a
neutral ledger that lacks discrimination, he's becoming the
arbiter of smart contracts and a benevolent dictator for Ethereum.