And although the state's voucher program has more stringent academic expectations than many others — private schools must give the same state tests as public schools, are graded on the same A-to-F scale and can be prohibited from accepting
new voucher students if they perform poorly — there are loopholes.
Horizon consolidated its three schools into one, which was then allowed to continue accepting
new voucher students this fall — though Tammy Henline, a Horizon co-founder and its superintendent, said the consolidation had nothing to do with avoiding accountability: «Having everyone in the same building makes things a little simpler.»
Seven schools did so badly, state Superintendent John White barred them from accepting
new voucher students — though the state agreed to keep paying tuition for the more than 200 voucher students already enrolled, if they chose to stay.
As soon as the law was passed, four religious schools applied for a waiver and all four were approved to take on
new voucher students despite their failing grades.
The proposal also would require testing for taxpayer - subsidized students at private voucher schools while barring the lowest - performing schools from enrolling
new voucher students.
Money to pay for
new voucher students would come out of the budget of public schools that are losing students, and be prorated statewide based on applications instead of a set amount as it is now.
Later in May, Ms. Nelson was notified that Upperroom was barred from accepting
new voucher students because of the school's poor exam results.
Fordham even implicitly shows how its testing approach will eventually impact non-voucher private school students: «[i] f a private school's voucher students perform in the two lowest categories of a state's accountability system for two consecutive years, then that school should be declared ineligible to receive
new voucher students until it moves to a higher tier of performance (emphasis added).»
New voucher students fell statistically significantly behind their public school peers in math after switching.
Meanwhile, the Catholic Archdiocese of Washington, whose private school system is expected to provide the bulk of the seats for
new voucher students and which was involved in passing and developing the program, is seeking additional money, noting that their tuition rates on average cover only about 50 percent of the system's costs to educate each child.
The state of Louisiana recently banned four schools from receiving
new voucher students because the scores of prior voucher recipients had been so low.
Not exact matches
More than 700,000
students in more than 1,200
New York City schools — including large high schools in all five boroughs — would face higher class sizes, have fewer teachers and lose after - school academic and enrichment programs if President - elect Trump makes good on a campaign promise to pull billions of federal dollars away from public schools to pay for private
vouchers, a UFT analysis has found.
When comparable samples and measuring sticks are used, the improvement in test scores for black
students from attending a small class based on the Tennessee STAR experiment is about 50 percent larger than the gain from switching to a private school based on the
voucher experiments in
New York City, Washington, D.C., and Dayton, Ohio.
A more likely scenario could be an effort to reform the tax code to offer tax credits for donations to organizations that provide scholarships to low - income
students — an approach that could serve much the same purpose as school
vouchers but would not require the creation of a
new direct - spending program.
Conversely, «if a white
student uses a LSP
voucher to attend a school that is more white than its surrounding community, the transfer would be reducing integration at the
new school.»
CAMBRIDGE, MA — A
new study estimates that between 7.5 and 14 percent of
students in Milwaukee's
voucher program have disabilities, a much higher rate than the one provided by the Wisconsin State Department of Public Instruction (DPI), which has stated, «about 1.6 percent of choice
students have a disability.»
This would include funding for a pilot private - school
voucher program,
new money for charter schools, and additional money for Title I that would be directed to follow
students to the public school of their choice.
As befitting an article published in the nation's leading statistics journal, it introduces
new statistical techniques to deal with problems that often emerge in randomized field trials: 1) missing data (for instance, not all
students who initially joined the study participated in the follow - up testing sessions), and 2) noncompliance (some
students, for example, refused the
vouchers that were offered to them).
But though fabricated out of thin air, the court nevertheless used its
new exclusivity doctrine to stop the legislature from running its publicly - funded K - 12
voucher program for a general
student population.
On the third page of the study, the authors write: «Negative
voucher effects are not explained by the quality of public fallback options for LSP applicants: achievement levels at public schools attended by
students lotteried out of the program are below the Louisiana average and comparable to scores in low - performing districts like
New Orleans.»
We followed
students who participated in a
voucher experiment in
New York City in the 1990s, and found that African - American
students who won a
voucher were more likely to go to college than those who were not offered the opportunity.
In 2009 - 10, the second year of the
voucher program, 1,324
New Orleans
students attended 31 private schools using
vouchers with a maximum value of over $ 7,000.
By contrast, Krueger and Zhu concluded, «The provision of
vouchers in
New York City probably had no more than a trivial effect on the average test performance of participating black
students.»
The
new research is significant in that it affords an unusual opportunity to obtain high quality information on the participation rate in school
voucher programs by
students with disabilities.
In The Education Gap:
Vouchers and Urban Schools (Brookings, 2002), we and our colleagues reported that attending a private school had no discernible impact, positive or negative, on the test scores of non-African-American
students participating in school
voucher programs in Washington, D.C.,
New York City, and Dayton, Ohio.
A study in the Summer 2013 issue of Education Next looked at the impact of receiving a
voucher on the college enrollment rates of
students in
New York City.
Participating private schools with unacceptable ratings are barred from accepting
new students receiving
vouchers for the following year.
The Devil Is in the Details of the Latest Supposedly Negative Study of DC's Voucher Program (The Washington Examiner) Marty West's perspective on
new findings on
vouchers and
student performance in DC schools.
Officials in a San Antonio district said last week they have lost nearly 600
students this fall to a
new, privately financed
voucher program.
Vouchers have come to include the use of private funding as partial tuition support for low - income
students to attend private schools (as in Washington, D.C., San Antonio, and
New York); the use of public funds to allow a small number of low - income
students to attend private schools (as in Milwaukee and Cleveland); or, as in the case of Florida, the provision of public funds for
students to attend a private school or another public school if their current public school has a poor aca - demic record.
That legislation, which also passed the House 95 - 21 and which Gov. Jeb Bush, a Republican, was expected to sign, would impose a
new set of accountability requirements, including mandating standardized tests for thousands of
voucher students attending private schools with public money.
Specifically, for
students who had attended public schools deemed to be failing before the
students took part in the
voucher program — a high - priority target for the D.C. Opportunity Scholarship Program — the
new federal study shows no statistically significant impacts on their test scores.
Because the
voucher studies compare
students who won a
voucher to those who did not — and those not receiving a
voucher very likely ended up in the
new and improved public / charter system.
Louisiana appears on track to enact a private - school -
voucher plan for
New Orleans that borrows from choice programs elsewhere in several respects, from its focus on a single city and its means - testing of families to its targeting of
students enrolled in low - performing public schools.
It is reasonable to conclude that African - American
students» initial gains in the
New York City school
voucher program were preserved but did not increase between year one and year two.
As the controversy raged in the late 1990s, a group of philanthropists created the
New York School Choice Scholarships Foundation (SCSF), which offered three - year
vouchers worth up to $ 1,400 annually to as many as 1,000 low - income families with children who were either entering 1st grade or were public school
students about to enter grades two through five.
In dioceses like
New Orleans and Cincinnati, where publicly funded
voucher and tax credit programs provide disadvantaged
students public money to attend private and parochial schools, a half dozen or more schools have closed since 2014.
Ed Week, Ed Sector, and others are picking up on a hyperventilating story from the free weekly Miami
New Times about misconduct in Florida's McKay Scholarship
voucher program for disabled
students.
Only a small fraction of low - income public - school
students in
New York, Dayton, and D.C. were offered
vouchers, and these
students made up a small share of the cities» private - school populations.
These higher rates of educational attainment due to the Milwaukee
voucher program represent improvements of 15 — 20 percent over the rates obtained by the comparison group of public - school
students — nearly as large as those for the African American
students in the
New York City study.
Paul Peterson sits down with the WSJ to discuss a
new study on how
vouchers help African American
students.
In our
new study, we track the voting behavior of
students who participated in the
voucher experiment.
For instance, a 2015 study of a privately funded
voucher program in
New York City found that being offered a
voucher to attend a private school increased college enrollment rates among black and Hispanic
students by 4.4 percentage points, a 10 percent gain relative to the control group, and also increased bachelor's degree completion rates among black and Hispanic
students by 2.4 percentage points, a 27 percent gain.
In the spring of 1997 over 20,000
New York City elementary school children applied for a half - tuition
voucher offered by the School Choice Scholarships Foundation, and a lottery was held to pare the number of lottery winners to around thirteen hundred
students, the number that SCSF resources could support.
On Top of the News Private School
Vouchers to Go to about 300 D.C. Students Washington Post August 5, 2012 Behind the Headline How Vouchers Came to D.C. Education Next Fall 2004 Nearly three hundred new students have been awarded vouchers in D.C. as part of a controversial federally - funded
Vouchers to Go to about 300 D.C.
Students Washington Post August 5, 2012 Behind the Headline How Vouchers Came to D.C. Education Next Fall 2004 Nearly three hundred new students have been awarded vouchers in D.C. as part of a controversial federally - funded
Students Washington Post August 5, 2012 Behind the Headline How
Vouchers Came to D.C. Education Next Fall 2004 Nearly three hundred new students have been awarded vouchers in D.C. as part of a controversial federally - funded
Vouchers Came to D.C. Education Next Fall 2004 Nearly three hundred
new students have been awarded vouchers in D.C. as part of a controversial federally - funded
students have been awarded
vouchers in D.C. as part of a controversial federally - funded
vouchers in D.C. as part of a controversial federally - funded program.
While Pecchia concedes that Youngstown has had to close schools because of slumping enrollment, the
new assignments mean large numbers of
students who would have been eligible for
vouchers next year won't be for at least two years.
Though still in negative territory,
voucher students» test scores were on the upswing in year two, with
new data on the horizon.
In the weeks after the storm, the superintendent of schools for the Archdiocese of
New Orleans appeared before the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education (BESE) urging board members to consider using
vouchers as a way for the state and Catholic schools to collaborate in serving the
students who remained in the city.
Such a decline is likely larger for
voucher students who move to a private school immediately after a choice program is created, because the schools also have to adjust — to an influx of
new, disadvantaged
students.
Findings:
New York, NY — Using alternative methods, this study confirms the 2003 finding that, after one year,
voucher students had math scores 5 percentile points higher than the control group.