Pennsylvania: Hearing on merit selection plan set for today, membership
of nominating commission unclear UPDATE: Vote delayed
On February 2, 2016, the Seventh Judicial
District Nominating Commission announced its selection of three nominees for appointment to the Seventh Judicial District Court to fill a vacancy created by the resignation of Hon. Jeff B. Herron, effective March 1, 2016.
The member appointed to the Fourteenth Judicial District Judicial
Nominating Commission for a term expiring December 31, 2017, is:
He was an elected member of the Kansas Supreme
Court Nominating Commission for two consecutive terms, having been elected by mail ballot of the lawyers in the Second Congressional District.
With the judicial
nominating commission as the initial and, indeed, essential component of the O'Connor Judicial Selection Plan, the Quality Judges Initiative has undertaken extensive work in this area in the last few years.
It moves Supreme Court races to a merit selection system, but places much more power over the 15 member Judicial
Nominating Commission in the legislature
The Supreme Court
Nominating Commission comprises one attorney and one non-attorney member from each of Colorado's seven judicial congressional districts, with one additional non-attorney member.
At the same time, Florida legislators have focused on giving the governor greater discretion in selecting members of the state's
nominating commissions by eliminating tenure protections.
The 2016 legislative sessions have seen a new trend — a proposed requirement that
nominating commissions submit to the appointing authority (usually the governor) the names of all applicants who meet the constitutional and statutory qualifications for serving as a judge.
There has been no attempt to change this from nonpartisan to partisan, although several bills were introduced to change the nonpartisan races to gubernatorial appointment from a judicial
nominating commission list and yes / no retention elections.
HCR 5013 (Constitutional Amendment) Changes Supreme Court
nominating commission membership: 4 members chosen by election of bar members (one per congressional district); 5 members chosen by governor (one per congressional district + 1 statewide to serve as chair); 6 members chosen by legislature (2 House Speaker; 1 House Minority Leader; 2 Senate President; 1 Senate Minority Leader).
She then went after Agriculture Commissioner Adam Putnam, the leading Republican gubernatorial candidate, for having voted for an unbuilt nuclear power plant while he was in Congress, and then go after likely Republican gubernatorial candidate House Speaker Richard Corcoran for appointing to the
PSC nominating commission.
Judges of the state Supreme Court and the three - district Court of Appeals are now appointed by the governor from slates of finalists forwarded by
special nominating commissions.
The chairperson [of the judicial
nominating commission] shall make the name of each person whose nomination is accepted available to the public whenever the commission stops accepting nominations for such appointment, but not less than 10 days prior to submitting the names of nominees to the governor.
Oklahoma Speaker puts forth judicial agenda: keep merit selection but
change nominating commission, term limits but only for Court of Civil Appeals, mandatory retirement age for all appellate judges, several «placeholder» bills
The 20 lawyers Gov. Nathan Deal named in his first week in office to serve on the Judicial
Nominating Commission draw on diverse practices and regions of the state.
We began with a detailed report on why states adopted merit selection in the first place, how the structure and operation of
nominating commissions differ across the country, and what some of the best practices appear to be in building public trust in the process.
Until July of 2013, a statutorily - authorized judicial
nominating commission advised the governor in appointing judges, and legislative approval was not required.
Oklahoma: Senate approves plan to put Judicial
Nominating Commission under Open Meetings Law, Kansas Senate approved similar proposal in 2015
Reddick is a nationally recognized expert in the areas of judicial selection and judicial performance evaluation and has conducted training programs for members of judicial
nominating commissions around the country.
Most recently, in consultation with a working group of judges, lawyer and
non-lawyer nominating commission members, and commission staffers, we developed model rules with accompanying commentary that address the ethical responsibilities and obligations of judicial nominating commissioners.
The Supreme Court
Nominating Commission consists of one attorney and one non-attorney from each of Colorado's seven congressional districts, plus one at large member who is not an attorney.
Judicial
nominating commissions review applications for judicial vacancies in their district and select nominees for appointment by the governor.
Should the bills pass, the governor would select judges from a recommended list of qualified candidates provided by a Judicial
Nominating Commission instead of forcing judges to run for election.
Oklahoma's Senate Judiciary Committee has approved five measures that would replace commission - based appointment of appellate judges with contested elections, limit the role of the judicial
nominating commission in identifying the best qualified applicants, allow the governor to replace some lawyer members of the commission, and require appellate judges to get 60 percent «yes» votes to be retained.
On Wednesday, June 16, 2016, the Colorado State Judicial Branch announced that the Twenty - First Judicial
District Nominating Commission selected three finalists for a vacancy on the District Court, occasioned by the retirement of Hon. David A. Bottger, effective August 12, 2016.
Following the defeat of a proposed constitutional amendment that would have given the governor greater authority in appointing
nominating commission members and more discretion in selecting judges, supporters of the measure vowed to «regroup and move forward with something more aggressive» for 2014.
Each of Colorado's 22 judicial districts has a judicial
nominating commission comprised of seven members — four non-attorneys and three attorneys, of whom no more than four may be from the same political party.
A judicial
nominating commission selected four lawyers Monday as finalists to fill the vacancy on the Nebraska Supreme Court created by the sudden resignation of Judge Max Kelch.
Rhode Island: bill requiring Judicial
Nominating Commission name at least one person of color for every judicial vacancy stalls in committee
Widespread use
of nominating commissions wouldn't be a cure - all for the deep - seated conflicts over selection of federal judges, says Harvey I. Saferstein, the committee member who will introduce the recommendation in the House.