Not exact matches
The
number of
homebirths still hovers
at around 1 %.
There may be a few more bad outcomes in the
homebirth groups depending on how you look
at the data, but when you consider the
number of births we are looking
at, the absolute
number is so very few that the argument is a little ridiculous.»
Leaving aside for the moment that this is the same group who crowed over a 20 % increase in
homebirths from from 0.56 % to 0.67 % of US births, does dismissing the absolute
number of death as low fully convey what is
at stake in the decision to attempt
homebirth?
MANA refuses to release the
number of those 24,000 babies who died
at the hands of
homebirth midwives.
Babies die all the time
at homebirth, and the biggest risk factors lead to the greatest
number of deaths.
However, you are lashing out
at a community of women who are working hard to give their babies the best start possible and completely ignoring the huge
number of women and babies that die in hospitals that far exceeds that of
homebirths... Trying to clean the speck out of my eye while you've got a flippin tree in your own eye.
I agree that the database almost certainly under - counts the
number of deaths
at CPM attended
homebirth.
Or look
at this way: an increase in the rate of
homebirth from 0.5 % to 1 % would constitute a doubling of the
number of patients for HB midwives (a 100 % increase), and a drop of 1 patient for every 190 for OBs (a 0.5 % decrease).
It doesn't take a rocket scientist to speculate that an extraordinarily high
number of babies die
at the hands of
homebirth midwives.
The actuaries looked
at the
numbers from
homebirths and said, nuh uh, no way, that will cost us a lot of money.
We can also be sure that the authors understood that their data showed that
homebirth has a horrifically high death rate, because they try to hide the
number of deaths for the past 5 years, released the data only under pressure, and then proceeded to draw a conclusion entirely
at odds with what their own data showed.
In my experiences with
homebirth midwives that practice in Illinois (there is still a large Mennonite population, and a
number of women who still wish to birth
at home), the recommend having a
homebirth friendly Pediatrician in place because, «there are orders to call CPS if a homebirthed baby or mom transfers to a hospital».