Although there exist
observational estimates of the SAMOC, the decadal and multi-decadal variability of the SAMOC and its influence on climate and weather can not be assessed due to its short temporal record.
Brient & Schneider's results in fact change little if a more reasonable method of weighting models that does not penalise differences in the uncertainty between the model and
observational estimates of the TLC reflection — SST relationship is used.
«Dessler's study is just showing that
the observational estimates of ECS are plausibly estimates from the bottom of the spread and that the difference between observational and ensemble based estimates is plausibly the effects of internal variability on the observational estimates.»
Unfortunately, ten years ago
observational estimates of aerosol forcing were poor, so Gregory used a GCM - derived estimate.
I showed that using the best
observational estimates of forcing given in the SOD, and the most recent observational OHU estimates, a heat balance approach estimates ECS to be 1.6 — 1.7 °C — well below the «likely» range of 2 — 4.5 °C that the SOD claims (in Section 10.8.2.5) is supported by the observational evidence, and little more than half the best estimate of circa 3 °C it gives.
The conclusion — taking the best
observational estimates of the change in decadal - average global temperature between 1871 - 80 and 2002 - 11, and of the corresponding changes in forcing and ocean heat uptake — is this: A doubling of CO2 will lead to a warming of 1.6 ° -1.7 °C (2.9 ° -3.1 °F).
Various mechanisms have been proposed for this hiatus in global warming3, 4,5,6, but their relative importance has not been quantified, hampering
observational estimates of climate sensitivity.
Given the short period of the records are
the observational estimates of the Hurst exponents stable enough to be used as a test for the models?
B) Im interested because the temperature record is important to
observational estimates of climate sensitivity.
Observational estimates of climate sensitivity from changes in the rate of ocean heat uptake and comparison to CMIP5 models.
As a result, the study would provide little evidence that historical period
observational estimates of ECS have been biased low in relation to effective climate sensitivity.
- that new estimates of aerosol cooling are low - that new estimates of Ocean heat uptake are low - that therefore
observational estimates of climate sensitivity may prove low - that observational estimates are now good enough that they should be preferred over models - that warming below 2C is net beneficial
TCR is not that uncertain and a growing body of research focused on
observational estimates of TCR shows is isn't likely larger than 1.2 - 1.4 C, indicating transient climate feedbacks are small.
«We may never completely reconcile the divergent
observational estimates of temperature changes in the tropical troposphere.
For example,
observational estimates of the effects of attending a charter middle school in the lottery study are 0.17 σ for ELA and 0.32 σ for math.
It's noteworthy, however, that
the observational estimates of pilot high school treatment effects are larger for schools used in the lottery study than for other pilot schools.
It is difficult to digitise the Figure 8.18 values for years affected by volcanic eruptions, so I have also adjusted the widely - used RCP4.5 forcings dataset to reflect the Section 7.5.3
observational estimate of current aerosol forcing, using Figure 8.18 and Table 8.7 data to update the projected RCP4.5 forcings for 2007 — 2011 where appropriate.
, which are in fact the excess of AFari + aci over RFari, need adjusting (scaling down by (0.73 − 0.4) / (0.9 − 0.4), all years) to obtain a forcing dataset based on a purely
observational estimate of aerosol AF rather than the IPCC's composite estimate.
Not exact matches
Of note, our point estimate for premature death exceeds the annual number of U.S. deaths from cervical cancer (3,909), asthma (3,361), or influenza (3,055).45 If a randomized control trial were to demonstrate similar effects to those reported in the observational literature, the «number needed to treat» with optimal breastfeeding to prevent a case of maternal hypertension would be 35, to prevent a maternal MI would be 135, and to prevent a case of breast cancer would be 38
Of note, our point
estimate for premature death exceeds the annual number
of U.S. deaths from cervical cancer (3,909), asthma (3,361), or influenza (3,055).45 If a randomized control trial were to demonstrate similar effects to those reported in the observational literature, the «number needed to treat» with optimal breastfeeding to prevent a case of maternal hypertension would be 35, to prevent a maternal MI would be 135, and to prevent a case of breast cancer would be 38
of U.S. deaths from cervical cancer (3,909), asthma (3,361), or influenza (3,055).45 If a randomized control trial were to demonstrate similar effects to those reported in the
observational literature, the «number needed to treat» with optimal breastfeeding to prevent a case
of maternal hypertension would be 35, to prevent a maternal MI would be 135, and to prevent a case of breast cancer would be 38
of maternal hypertension would be 35, to prevent a maternal MI would be 135, and to prevent a case
of breast cancer would be 38
of breast cancer would be 385.
The performance
of different propensity - score methods for
estimating differences in proportions (risk differences or absolute risk reductions) in
observational studies.
Using the Great Barrier Reef as their study case, they
estimated the evolution
of the region over the last 14,000 years and showed that (1) high sediment loads from catchments erosion prevented coral growth during the early phase
of sea level rise and favoured deep offshore sediment deposition; (2) how the fine balance between climate, sea level, and margin physiography enabled coral reefs to thrive under limited shelf sedimentation rates at 6,000 years before present; and, (3) how over the last 3,000 years, the decrease
of accommodation space led to the lateral extension
of coral reefs consistent with available
observational data.
The project, called
Estimating the Circulation and Climate
of the Ocean (ECCO), uses
observational data — including ocean surface topography, surface wind stress, temperature, salinity profiles and velocity data — collected between June 2005 and December 2007.
James O'Malley, PhD and former post-doc, Jaeun Choi, PhD recently had their paper «
Estimating the causal effect
of treatment in
observational studies with survival time end points and unmeasured confounding» published in The Journal
of the Royal Statistics Society; Applied Statistics.
Previous
observational studies
estimate that 60 to 90 percent
of bariatric surgery patients who were obese and had type 2 diabetes were later able to maintain normal blood glucose levels without medication.
The team compared the scattering coefficient obtained by their approach with the scattering coefficient measured on board the aircraft and found good agreement between the
estimated and measured scattering coefficients for a wide range
of observational conditions.
We
estimate that ~ 35 %
of KOIs are false positives due to contamination, when performing a first - order correction for
observational bias.
[11] Asteroseismic analyses that incorporate the tight
observational constraints on the stellar parameters for α Cen A and / or B have yielded age
estimates of 7000484999999999999 ♠ 4.85 ± 0.5 Gyr, [7] 7000500000000000000 ♠ 5.0 ± 0.5 Gyr, [27] 5.2 — 7.1 Gyr, [28] 6.4 Gyr, [29] and 7000652000000000000 ♠ 6.52 ± 0.3 Gyr.
«Although the different
estimates of OHCA (ocean heat content anomaly) produce seemingly different
estimates of interannual ocean heating rate variability, these differences are all within the range
of observational uncertainty.
«About four percent
of solar - type stars are in quadruple systems, which is up from previous
estimates because
observational techniques are steadily improving,» said co-author Andrei Tokovinin
of the Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory in Chile.
The total
of -0.7 W / m ^ 2 is the same as the best
observational (satellite) total aerosol adjusted forcing
estimate given in the leaked Second Order Draft
of AR5 WG1, which includes cloud lifetime (2nd indirect) and other effects.
The visualization covers the period June 2005 to December 2007 and is based on a synthesis
of a numerical model with
observational data, created by a NASA project called
Estimating the Circulation and Climate
of the Ocean, or ECCO for short.
The
observational and lottery - based analyses
of pilot middle schools both produce negative
estimates in the sample that includes lagged scores.
In an effort to gauge the external validity
of our lottery
estimates, we computed
observational estimates that rely solely on statistical controls, with separate effects for schools in and out
of the lottery sample.
This investigation produces
estimates remarkably similar to the lottery - based
estimates of charter effects when carried out in the sample
of charter schools that have lotteries, lending credence to the
observational analysis.
Lottery and
observational estimates are similar when
estimated using the same set
of charter schools.
«It is only when these important data sources [e.g., VAM
estimates and
observational data] are considered together that we begin to see the full picture
of an individual's performance and can determine how much our teachers and principals are contributing to our students» learning.»
However, what we have seen since 2009, when states began to adopt what were then (and in many ways still are) viewed as America's «new and improved» or «strengthened» teacher evaluation systems, is that for 70 %
of America's teachers, these teacher evaluation systems are still based only on the
observational indicators being used prior, because for only 30 %
of America's teachers are value - added
estimates calculable.
Evaluations in years one and two (1) assessed preschool quality using two
observational measures, (2) measured children's gains in receptive vocabulary, literacy, math and executive functions, and (3) compared gains
of SPP attendees to those
of a non-equivalent comparison group to
estimate SPP impacts on children's learning and development.
She designed simulations (2) and (3) to illustrate the plausibility
of the situation suggested next (as written into Audrey's post prior) about potential bias in both value - added and
observational estimates:
She used R (i.e., a free software environment for statistical computing and graphics) to simulate correlation scatterplots (see Figures below) to illustrate three unique situations: (1) a simulation where there are two indicators (e.g., teacher value - added and
observational estimates plotted on the x and y axes) that have a correlation
of r = 0.28 (the highest correlation coefficient at issue in the aforementioned post); (2) a simulation exploring the impact
of negative bias and a moderate correlation on a group
of teachers; and (3) another simulation with two indicators that have a non-linear relationship possibly induced or caused by bias.
But since there are reasonable
estimates of the real world GMT, it is a fair enough question to ask why the models have more spread than the
observational uncertainty.
One reason why these
estimates keep getting revised is that there is a continual updating
of the
observational analyses that are used — as new data are included, as non-climatic factors get corrected for, and models include more processes.
In short, irrespective
of what
observational dataset was used — it's likely that an
estimate of forced response made in 2014 would be biased cold, which on its own would translate to an overestimate
of the available budget
of about 40GtC.
Even if one were to stipulate all
of the ostensible «errors» Lewis claims, the only way he is actually able to justify his claim
of disagreement with observations» ICS is by throwing out the
observational ICS
estimate used in the paper in favor
of once he likes and obviously likes simply because
of their low values.
Internal variability as
estimated from observations can't explain sea - ice loss Superposition
of a linear trend and internal variability explains sea - ice loss
Observational sea - ice record shows no signs
of self - acceleration
We ultimately face a question
of what we trust more: our
estimate of our cumulative emissions to date combined with our full knowledge
of how much warming that might imply, or an
estimate of how warm the system was in 2014 which is subject to error due to
observational uncertainty and natural variability.
Whether you are gullible enough to accept the figures as accurate depends on how much credibility you put in the multitude
of observational measurements taken by different methods over many decades by diverse groups
of researchers that form a strong consilience
of mutually supporting evidence for the validity
of the
estimates and the possible errors.
use
of ocean heat uptake — which amounts to only ~ 86 %
of total heat uptake — as a measure
of total heat uptake despite the
observational studies Marvel et al. critique using
estimates that included non-ocean heat uptake;
Since we can not do controlled experiments, climate science is an
OBSERVATIONAL science we can't put the climate in a beaker, we can only look at past temperatures and past forcings to CONSTRAIN our
estimate of sensitivity.
Using models that don't do what you need to say sensitivity is even higher than models
estimate, so that warmunists can ignore all the
observational effective sensitivity
estimates, smacks
of illogical desperation.