Writing in the journal Nature Geoscience, astrobiologists Alberto Fairén of Cornell University and Dirk Schulze - Makuch of Washington State University say the NASA Office
of Planetary Protection's «detailed and expensive» efforts to keep Earth microorganisms off Mars are making missions to search for life on the red planet «unviable.»
The researchers claim «the protocols and policies
of planetary protection are unnecessarily restricting Mars exploration and need to be revised.»
The Office
of Planetary Protection is like an interplanetary Environmental Protection Agency, with a mission «to minimize the biological contamination that may result from exploring the solar system.»
It is remotely possible that, in the name
of planetary protection, we are making the effects of cross-contamination worse.
Cassini's fate is tied to the issue
of planetary protection, which refers to the measures scientists and engineers take to minimize that chances that life - forms from Earth make it to other worlds.
Dr. Andy Spry, Senior Scientist, SETI Institute, & Consultant, Office
of Planetary Protection, NASA
So the international Committee on Space Research (called COSPAR) has debated and refined the details
of a planetary protection policy that meets the treaty's requirement ever since.
To meet it, the panel discussed the creation
of a Planetary Protection Coordination Office (PPCO) within NASA, with an annual budget of $ 250 million - $ 300 million.
The presence of water raises the possibility that Ceres might harbor life, so NASA's Office
of Planetary Protection insisted that Dawn stay at least 420 miles away to minimize the risk of contaminating a pristine world with earthly microbes.
Traditionally, the assumed beneficiary
of planetary protection has been the planet Earth.
Welcome to the paradox
of planetary protection.
«Because
of planetary protection and our desire to go back to Enceladus, go back to Titan, go back to the Saturn system, we must protect those bodies for future exploration,» Jim Green, director of NASA's planetary science division, said at a news conference on September 13.
The Viking landers of the 1970s were the only missions to Mars ever to be completely cleaned to the highest standards
of planetary protection.
They opened the already - sterilized bit box, a violation
of planetary protection protocols that caused the office to downgrade Curiosity's sterility.
Not exact matches
The incident has become a lessons - learned example
of miscommunication in assuring that
planetary protection procedures are strictly adhered to
Moreover, the
planetary protection office has not yet agreed on the efficacy
of the techniques JPL will use to sterilize the tubes in which the rover will cache rock cores.
While the
planetary protection office is currently an office
of one, Conley expects the field to expand.
Conley is joking, but Rummel confirms that when he first got the position, he thought he was going to be working on life support systems until the person who'd hired him left a week later, leaving him in charge
of astrobiology and
planetary protection.
But that doesn't change the fact that Cassie Conley, NASA's
planetary protection officer, is in charge
of protecting Earth from alien invasions.
«We're still trying to figure out how to implement
planetary protection,» says space law professor Joanne Gabrynowicz at the University
of Mississippi.
Part
of her job as
planetary protection officer is to keep Earth safe from alien life.
Today, at a meeting in Washington, D.C.,
of NASA's
planetary science advisory committee, the agency's new
planetary protection officer raised the possibility
of opening up a few
of the planet's most promising regions to more aggressive exploration.
Officially, he is the senior staff scientist
of the biotechnology and
planetary protection group.
Fortunately, the risk
of contaminating the Red Planet is extremely slim, says Catharine Conley, NASA's
planetary protection officer, who is charged with ensuring agency projects do not contaminate other solar system bodies.
(«
Planetary protection» is the term scientists commonly use for precautions to minimize the chance
of biological contamination between worlds.
Shapiro stresses that it is unclear whether Congress will give further funds to
planetary protection, noting that if it doesn't, there is a risk
of the money being taken away from space science.
To a
planetary protection officer entrusted with keeping deadly life - forms out
of Earth's biosphere, doing nothing is the one option that is completely unacceptable.
So argue two Mars scientists behind a controversial new push to relax
planetary protection rules — a set
of sterilisation procedures that Mars - bound spacecraft must undergo to avoid contaminating the planet with terrestrial microbes.
Microbial ecology
of a crewed rover traverse in the arctic: Low microbial dispersal and implications for
planetary protection on human Mars missions.
«It was clear to everybody that we need more refined technical requirements, not just guidelines,» says Gerhard Kminek,
planetary protection officer for the European Space Agency and chair
of COSPAR's
planetary protection panel, which sets the standards.
On a positive note however, the researchers add that this suggests that any microorganisms that may be transported to Mars from Earth by mistake are unlikely to be able to survive on the Martian surface, something that is
of current concern for
planetary protection.
«No government in the world today has explicitly assigned the responsibility for
planetary protection to any
of its agencies,» ASE member Rusty Schweickart, who flew on the Apollo 9 mission in 1969, said Friday during a panel discussion at the American Museum
of Natural History in New York City.
«When we landed the Huygens probe on Titan, we had no idea what we'd find on the surface, so it was really the discoveries
of Huygens and Cassini that led to these new [
planetary protection] requirements,» says Spilker.
Planetary protection works both ways: The probability
of infecting another world with microbes from Earth can not ever be zero.
«This should greatly reduce
planetary protection concerns as well as any concerns about infection
of astronauts,» McKay explained.
«And this has large impact on different fields including, but not limited to, the theory
of Panspermia and
planetary protection issues.»
Vehicle: 2001 Dodge Durango Owner: Steve Maxfield, Kanosh, Utah Engine: 5.7 L Hemi V - 8 Transmission: Stock five - speed automatic (four gears plus overdrive
planetary) Transfer case: Stock Powerwagon Front axle: Powerwagon AAM 9.25 with 4.56:1 gears and electric lockers Rear axle: Powerwagon AAM 10.5 with 4.56:1 gears and electric lockers Front suspension: Stock Powerwagon five - link welded onto Durango frame, including coil buckets and control arm mounts, 12 - inch - stroke King 2.0 air shocks Rear suspension: Stock Durango leaf spring with spring - over swap, 12 - inch - stroke King 2.0 air shocks Steering: Hydraulic - assist steering ram fed from ported Dodge steering box Tires / wheels: 42 - inch Pit Bull Rockers on 16 1/2 - inch H1 HUMVEE beadlocks
Protection: Full belly skidplates made out
of 3 / 16 - inch steel, full 2 - inch, 0.120 - wall DOM exoskeleton, custom bumpers, and tire carrier integrated into exoskeleton Other: Warn winch, bumper - mounted LED lightbar, roof - mounted LED lightbar, rock cameras connected to onboard monitor
Of course I will try my hardest to share my strong beliefs about
planetary protection, but I also realize that they need to come to that realization on their own.
He served as professor
of environmental sciences at the University
of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA (1971 — 94); distinguished research professor at the Institute for Space Science and Technology, Gainesville, FL (1989 — 94); chief scientist, U.S. Department
of Transportation (1987 — 89); vice chairman
of the National Advisory Committee for Oceans and Atmosphere (NACOA)(1981 — 86); deputy assistant administrator for policy, U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency (1970 — 71); deputy assistant secretary for water quality and research, U.S. Department
of the Interior (1967 — 70); founding dean
of the School
of Environmental and
Planetary Sciences, University
of Miami (1964 — 67); first director
of the National Weather Satellite Service (1962 — 64); and director
of the Center for Atmospheric and Space Physics, University
of Maryland (1953 — 62).