In such a case, a court may not substitute its own construction
of a statutory provision for a reasonable interpretation made by the administrator of an agency.
Justice Kagan wrote for all nine Justices, focusing primarily on the text and context
of the statutory provisions at issue but also addressing the legislative history when refuting Novo's arguments.
Opinion analysis: When a statutory exclusionary rule «makes sense» SCOTUSblog, May 15, 2018 The Supreme Court's brisk opinion in Dahda v. United States awarded the government yet another exclusionary rule victory, this time in the
context of a statutory provision rooted in the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act of 1968.
The first directly elected mayor was introduced in Greater London in 2000 as part
of the statutory provisions of the Greater London Authority Act 1999.
The Czech Government's description of Akcenta's situation is evidence enough of the fact that the
application of statutory provisions may call for complex assessments which are not within the area of responsibility of those private undertakings or associations of undertakings.
(iv) In addressing the questions the court should focus very closely on the
language of the statutory provision in question in the context of the statute and in the light of any statutory definition.
In determining the appropriate standard of review, Justices LeBel and Cromwell relied on the tribunal's expertise, the factual nature of the question, and the
purpose of the statutory provisions at issue.
The Supreme Court's brisk opinion in Dahda v. United States awarded the government yet another exclusionary rule victory, this time in the context
of a statutory provision rooted in the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act of 1968.
Many types of income, including retirement and government benefits, are effectively exempt from creditors
because of statutory provisions that prohibit alienating or assigning benefit payments to anyone other than the beneficiary.
So, in Section 11 of the Employment Act, it states: «Any requirement to wear a safety helmet which... would, by
virtue of any statutory provision or rule of law, be imposed on a Sikh who is on a construction site shall not apply to him at any time when he is wearing a turban».
Most recently I've seen legal reasoning blunders on limitations law issues, because of misconstruction of precedent, failure to look at the law of other jurisdictions, or lack of awareness of the basis for limitations principles or
origins of statutory provisions.
Nonetheless, as I suggested in my previous posts on the subject, where criteria are used to inform the exercise of discretion it is generally better that they be made public, a point which applies with equal force to executive
non-enforcement of statutory provisions.
The «pith and substance»
of any statutory provision requiring the data to be destroyed is «property and civil rights in the province» and beyond the authority of the federal government.
The legal principle of equality of arms forms part of the right to a fair trial and this lies at the
heart of the statutory provisions that have been introduced to ensure that one party is not unfairly disadvantaged due to lack of funding.
The second aspect requires that the
validity of the statutory provision be considered on the grounds of gross dis - proportionality as evidenced in reasonable hypothetical cases.
Rather, I suggested that there may exist a
category of statutory provisions — including provisions permitting the executive branch to override judicial decisions — that are «so constitutionally egregious as to test the courts» commitment to the absolute supremacy of Parliament».
For
opacity of statutory provision the consequences of s 44 must take a Kafka award; and in what follows I feel I am only guessing at the law (unless I've missed something very simple).
When a challenge to an agency
construction of a statutory provision, fairly conceptualized, really centers on the wisdom of the agency's policy, rather than whether it is a reasonable choice within a gap left open by Congress, the challenge must fail.
Furthermore, there is no authority for implying a right to be heard in the
face of a statutory provision (such as s. 5 (1) of the MCIA), which specifically denies such a right
Finally, in 2012, having exhausted all his avenues internally, he took his question to the Federal Court, seeking declarations on the correct interpretation
of statutory provisions used to assess whether proposed legislation complies with the Charter or Bill of Rights.
After a
review of the statutory provisions the Court found that the Copyright Act entitles Re: Sound to collect fees only on the basis of all sound recordings in Re: Sound's repertoire and not all those eligible for equitable compensation, noting, among other reasons, that Re: Sound does not have a monopoly to act as the collective society and propose tariffs under Section 19.
The suggested construction made nonsense, also, of the language
of the statutory provisions under which, upon nationalisation in 1948, the liabilities of the private gas undertakers were transferred to the state owned area boards and, upon privatisation in 1986, the liabilities of the state owned area boards were transferred to British Gas plc..
Where the
intent of a statutory provision that speaks expressly to the question of preemption is at issue, «we do not invoke any presumption against pre-emption but instead focus on the plain wording of the clause, which necessarily contains the best evidence of Congress» pre-emptive intent.»
The Divisional Court reviewed the relevant sections of the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 that pertain to a landlord's right to enter the rental premises and found that
none of the statutory provisions permitted entry for the purpose of taking photographs to market the property for sale or lease.
NAR opposes any
erosion of the statutory provision of the the Internal Revenue Code Section 3508, which provides clear directives about how a real estate broker may classify his / her sales agents as independent contractors.