Although the public presentation
of charter school research today is nearly as contentious as it was when the AFT report made waves in 2004, beneath the radar screen is a growing convergence on a set of findings that fit neither the rosy predictions of the early advocates nor the dire fears of the early critics:
Not exact matches
The data on
charter -
school performance is perhaps mixed, but a half century
of research proves, as Ravitch acknowledges, that «minority children in Catholic
schools are more likely to take advanced courses than their peers in public
schools, more likely to go to college, and more likely to continue on to graduate
school.»
Albany, NY — Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver shares the microphones with Alan Chartock this week to discuss the ramifications
of charter schools in New York, as well as the need for the state to be a leader in stem cell
research.
His particular interest is in the establishment
of new
schools such as academies and free
schools and part
of my
research is looking at Swedish free
schools and
Charter schools in the USA.
It has also reviewed hundreds
of thousands
of reports to aid in distinguishing the best - quality
research from weaker work, including studies on such subjects as the effectiveness
of charter schools and merit pay for teachers, which have informed the ongoing debate about these issues.
According to a recent survey by the National
Charter School Research Project, scarcity of facilities was listed first among all reported external barriers to growth of charter management organizations, mentioned in 89 percent of res
Charter School Research Project, scarcity
of facilities was listed first among all reported external barriers to growth
of charter management organizations, mentioned in 89 percent of res
charter management organizations, mentioned in 89 percent
of responses.
The decade between 1999 and 2009 saw a dramatic expansion in CMO
schools, with increases
of approximately 20 percent per year, a higher growth rate than seen by independent
charter schools, according to a recent study by Mathematica Policy
Research.
Perhaps because the
research literature on the strength
of Boston
charter schools is so compelling,
charter proponents have focused more on touting academic benefits than debating financial costs.
On - going trends involving public
school segregation have been a primary focus
of the CRP's
research, and the expanding policy emphasis on
school choice prompted analysis
of the much smaller — but politically potent —
charter sector.
While the evidence for the effectiveness
of charter schools nationwide is mixed,
research has found that the
charter schools in these cities are on average more effective than district
schools in raising student test scores.
Among the featured speakers were David Driscoll, commissioner
of education for the Massachusetts Department
of Education; Peter Frumkin, professor
of public affairs at University
of Texas at Austin; Laurie Gardner and Eric Premack, codirectors
of California
Charter Schools Development Center; Michael Goldstein, founder and director
of research and information for MATCH
Charter Public High
School; and HGSE Senior Lecturer James Honan.
Decades
of social science
research describing the harms
of racially isolated
schools and the benefits
of diverse
schools has informed the development
of federal policy — and even many states»
charter school legislation.
Only anecdotal evidence has been offered in support
of the claim that
charter schools systematically remove students with disabilities, and little rigorous
research has considered the underlying causes
of the difference between the percentage
of charter -
school students and district -
school students enrolled in special education, the so - called «special education gap.»
Macke Raymond, director
of Stanford University's Center for
Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO), and an expert on monopolies in the public and private sectors, made this clear at a 2006 forum organized by the National Alliance for Public
Charter Schools.
Because the oversubscribed
charter schools in our sample admit students via random lotteries, comparing the outcomes
of lottery winners (most
of whom enrolled in a
charter school) and lottery losers (most
of whom did not) is akin to a randomized - control trial
of the kind often used in medical
research.
Research that painstakingly tries to separate out the actual effects
of schools clearly has value, but it is important to bear in mind that, in the absence
of random assignment
of students to
schools (such as occurs via
charter school lotteries), families that choose for their children to be educated in their home (through virtual
schools) are likely to be very different from other families.
For instance, a Google Scholar search
of «magnet
schools»
research published since the year 2000 returns less than half the hits
of a search for «
charter schools.»
Marty West talks with Sarah Cordes about her new
research on this topic: «
Charters and the Common Good: The spillover effects
of charter schools in New York City.»
The Atlanta - based organization urges education leaders to foster
research about the performance
of charter school students; fully support and adequately finance statewide K - 12...
Scarcity
of facilities was listed as the greatest external barrier to growth
of charter management organizations in a National Charter School Research Project
charter management organizations in a National
Charter School Research Project
Charter School Research Project survey.
One strand
of his
research, which has sought to replicate effective
charter -
school practices in public
school contexts, has shown that when a
school increases instructional time, has excellent teachers and administrators, and instills data - driven instruction, small - group tutoring, and a culture
of high expectations, it can eliminate gaps in math performance.
Watch for a lot
of new work from CRPE's new crop
of brilliant analysts on the state education agencies
of the future, district -
charter collaboration, the costs
of blended - learning models,
charter schools and special education, and,
of course, more
research and tools for portfolio management.
The Long - Run Influence
of Charter Schools (phase I) project hopes to create a charter school lottery data clearinghouse, to make it possible for other researchers to store data, propose projects and to gain secure access to the data for their own research pr
Charter Schools (phase I) project hopes to create a
charter school lottery data clearinghouse, to make it possible for other researchers to store data, propose projects and to gain secure access to the data for their own research pr
charter school lottery data clearinghouse, to make it possible for other researchers to store data, propose projects and to gain secure access to the data for their own
research projects.
The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation announced a new investment
of $ 1.7 billion for K - 12 education over the next five years, with the bulk
of the funding aimed at existing traditional public
schools that show progress in improving educational outcomes, the development
of new curricula,
charter schools focused on students with special needs, and «
research and development» for scalable models that could inform best practices.
Regardless
of the sponsoring organization or the
research design, these studies all reach the same conclusion: Commonwealth
charter schools in Boston are exceptionally high performing.
In this forum, Matthew Ladner, senior advisor for policy and
research at the Foundation for Excellence in Education, argues that ESAs offer a grand advance over
charter schooling and deserve the support
of reformers.
New
research finds that students attending a district
school in New York City within a half - mile radius
of a
charter school score better in math and reading and enjoy an increase in their likelihood
of advancing to the next grade.
Mathematica's own defense
of its
research design was that it could do the study more cheaply if it relied upon readily available data, even though Caroline Hoxby, facing similar data collection problems, nonetheless found a way
of tracking students from first grade on («How New York City's
Charter Schools Affect Achievement»).
Another
research team, led by Josh Angrist and Parag Pathak, directors
of the
School Effectiveness and Inequality Initiative at MIT, compared «long - term outcomes» of Boston charter - school students to outcomes for BPS students who had entered charter - school admission lotteries (see Figu
School Effectiveness and Inequality Initiative at MIT, compared «long - term outcomes»
of Boston
charter -
school students to outcomes for BPS students who had entered charter - school admission lotteries (see Figu
school students to outcomes for BPS students who had entered
charter -
school admission lotteries (see Figu
school admission lotteries (see Figure 2).
Goldstein investigated ways to conduct useful, classroom - relevant
research with an experiment
of his own in the MATCH
charter school he founded.
«As we approached the study
of education through the lenses
of our
research on innovation,» they wrote, «our instinct was to frame
chartered schools as disruptive innovations, but upon reflection that was not correct.»
In fact, one recent piece
of research — a 2015 report from the Center for Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO) at Stanford University — suggests that students in online charter schools aren't doing as well as thei
research — a 2015 report from the Center for
Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO) at Stanford University — suggests that students in online charter schools aren't doing as well as thei
Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO) at Stanford University — suggests that students in online
charter schools aren't doing as well as their peers.
Most
research on
charter schools, and the most intense public debate over their desirability, has focused on the impact
of these new
schools on the students who attend them.
Our review
of the
research revealed few examples
of charter schools» having an impact on districts that could be attributed to market forces.
While some
of the material on
charter schools and vouchers will be familiar, it's convenient to have these multifaceted offerings, which include everything from experimental
research to first - person accounts, between two covers.
Evers is a past member
of National Educational
Research Policy and Priorities Board, a past commissioner on the California State Academic Standards Commission, past trustee on the Santa Clara County Board
of Education, and a past president
of the board
of directors
of the East Palo Alto
Charter School.
The founder
of Match
Charter School, Michael Goldstein, wrote «Studying Teacher Moves: A practitioner's take on what is blocking the
research teachers need,» for Education Next.
Kevin Booker and his colleagues («The Unknown World
of Charter High
Schools,» research) find that such schools in Florida and Chicago do better than their traditional counterparts at helping students reach graduation day and ensuring that graduates go on to c
Schools,»
research) find that such
schools in Florida and Chicago do better than their traditional counterparts at helping students reach graduation day and ensuring that graduates go on to c
schools in Florida and Chicago do better than their traditional counterparts at helping students reach graduation day and ensuring that graduates go on to college.
Indeed, it seems that many
of the major foundations involved in education are backing
charter schools in one way or another, either by supporting individual sites or by financing
research or advocacy designed to promote policies friendly to
charters.
Consequently,
charters proudly enroll higher percentages
of black and Hispanic children than other public
schools, and a growing body
of research underscores their success.
As part
of the Center for Education Policy
Research at Harvard University, SDP has been working with districts,
charter school networks, state education agencies, and nonprofits since 2008 to transform the way they collect and use data to support their program, management, and policy goals.
A 2015 study by Stanford University's Center for
Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO) found Newark
charter schools outperformed traditional district
schools: 77 percent
of Newark's
charters were more effective at raising test scores in reading, and 69 percent were more effective at raising scores in math.
The study — part
of a larger report put out by the National
Charter School Research Project at the Seattle - based Center on Reinventing Public Education — found, for instance, that charter school parents are
Charter School Research Project at the Seattle - based Center on Reinventing Public Education — found, for instance, that charter school parents are j
School Research Project at the Seattle - based Center on Reinventing Public Education — found, for instance, that
charter school parents are
charter school parents are j
school parents are just...
Twice a month, it's Technology Thursday for teachers at New Orleans's Martin Behrman
Charter Academy
of Creative Arts & Sciences, where Assistant Principal Cherie Goins, also the
school's technology coordinator, presents a three - hour training session that brings staff up to speed on technology for teaching, record keeping,
research, and more.
A 2015 report from the Center for
Research on Education Outcomes at Stanford University found that students enrolled in online
charter schools aren't performing as well as their peers, and many observers have argued that online - only
charters should be put out
of business.
Spencer Foundation — Practitioner
Research Communication and Mentoring Grant (2001 - 2002) Principal Investigator A Project to Design and Assess a Sustainable and Replicable Model of Teacher Research at City on a Hill Charter Public High School in Boston, Massachusetts, was a two - year research project that analyzed the effect of a whole - school initiative to instruct teachers in research methods and implement a teacher research component for faculty and intern teachers at the
Research Communication and Mentoring Grant (2001 - 2002) Principal Investigator A Project to Design and Assess a Sustainable and Replicable Model
of Teacher
Research at City on a Hill Charter Public High School in Boston, Massachusetts, was a two - year research project that analyzed the effect of a whole - school initiative to instruct teachers in research methods and implement a teacher research component for faculty and intern teachers at the
Research at City on a Hill
Charter Public High
School in Boston, Massachusetts, was a two - year research project that analyzed the effect of a whole - school initiative to instruct teachers in research methods and implement a teacher research component for faculty and intern teachers at the s
School in Boston, Massachusetts, was a two - year
research project that analyzed the effect of a whole - school initiative to instruct teachers in research methods and implement a teacher research component for faculty and intern teachers at the
research project that analyzed the effect
of a whole -
school initiative to instruct teachers in research methods and implement a teacher research component for faculty and intern teachers at the s
school initiative to instruct teachers in
research methods and implement a teacher research component for faculty and intern teachers at the
research methods and implement a teacher
research component for faculty and intern teachers at the
research component for faculty and intern teachers at the
schoolschool.
In an analysis
of the program, political scientist William Howell wrote that RttT encouraged applicants to develop «common core state standards,» design a teacher evaluation plan based in part on the performance
of their students, ensure «successful conditions for high - performing
charter schools,» and numerous other reforms (see «Results
of President Obama's Race to the Top,»
research, Fall 2015).
The four - day leadership development program drew on the expertise and
research of Harvard faculty and leading practitioners in framing the challenges faced by
charter schools and their
school communities while also addressing the larger state - level policy environment.
Released today by the Center for
Research on Education Outcomes, at Stanford University, the study comes as a growing number
of school districts and
charter schools around the country are experimenting with such reward programs in the hope
of improving...
The Politico article cites anti-creationism crusader Zach Kopplin's
research on the teaching
of creationism in
schools funded by vouchers — without citing his investigation into public
charter schools doing the same.