And some mutual funds, especially those that are truly active funds instead
of closet index funds, actually have a chance of beating the index and can do so over extended periods of time.
Not exact matches
If the active share
of a
fund is close to zero, then the
fund is effectively a replica
of the
index, hence the term «
closet indexer.»
In other words, the vast majority
of professional investors are just
closet index funds charging high fees.
There are still trillions
of dollars captured by hedge
funds,
closet indexing funds, high fee 401K plans and high fee investment advisors.
Closet indexing is the result
of active managers owning the market like an
index fund, but charging active management level fees.
As
of 2009 when the below chart ends, roughly half
of mutual
fund assets are
indexed or
closet indexed [ii].
Your investments are too important to leave it at the mercy
of the market (
index funds or
closet index funds)
Thirteen major U.S. mutual
fund companies have agreed to begin publishing data about how actively their
funds are managed, following an investigation by the office
of the attorney general
of New York (NYAG) into the practice
of «
closet indexing,» NYAG announced Thursday.
A
closet index fund is when the
fund manager is simply trying to follow an
index, which is a huge rip - off for you, since you could instead just buy an actual
index fund and pay an MER
of 0.5 % instead.
However, as a generalization I think it's pretty fair to say that the vast majority
of mutual
funds are
closet -
indexing leaches that do no one any good (except for the management companies who charge the high fees).
In this July 2006 research note titled Come out
of the
closet, or, show me the alpha James features a study that suggests
closet indexing accounts for nearly one third
of the US mutual
fund industry.