And so could potentially thousands
of design patent holders, driving even the healthiest company into bankruptcy in such a scenario.
His ultimate dream is to hold a
bunch of design patents which keeps him motivated to thrive for self - improvement.
It looks (also based on the jury's approach to damages) like the jury decided the trade dress part like it was just an
enhancement of design patents.
The Forbes piece and other coverage of the shapewear dispute link it to another recent high - profile case that illustrates the potential for design patent enforcement in the fashion industry: the lawsuit brought last fall by yoga - wear company Lululemon Athletica against Calvin Klein over alleged
infringement of design patents for Lululemon's «Astro Pant.»
Continue reading «Apple Wins a
Series of Design Patents in Europe Covering AirPower, iPhone X Glass Covers, Leather Folio & more»»
For the last 5 years our main site Patently Apple has covered Apple's new design patents week - in an week - out and never once was there a misplaced patent from another company within the list
of design patents for any particular week.
The ruling in this case, while limited to the question of damages, is critically important to the future
of design patents in general, said Alexander Poltorak, CEO of General Patent.
Samsung was awarded a great
number of design patents covering everything from a series of washing machines to dishwashers to toner cartridges.
As a result, the Court vacated a $ 399 Million damage award against Samsung Electronics Co. in a lawsuit alleging infringement
of design patents covering features of Apple, Inc.'s iPhone smartphones and sent the case back to the Federal Circuit Court of Appeal for further analysis.
The scope
of design patent damages law has been criticized as too broad, according to Christopher Rourk, a partner at Jackson Walker.
Matt Levy, the CCIA's former patent counsel (in which capacity he was really a thought leader with respect to «article of manufacture» as the key determination to be made in connection with an otherwise - unapportioned
disgorgement of design patent infringer's profits) and now a consultant;
If the Supreme Court had allowed the Federal Circuit's statutory interpretation with respect to a disgorgement
of a design patent infringer's unapportioned profits to stand, the consequences would have been really bad.
In this retrial, a win for Apple would mean that
hundreds of design patent owners could put forward very large lawsuits for all sorts of product components that are expensive to produce.
In a 8 - 0 ruling, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that damages for infringement
of design patents under 35 U.S.C. § 289 can be limited to the defendant's «total profits» from the article of manufacture that contains the patented design, which may only be one component of a commercial product, rather than...
While the number
of design patents issued annually across all industries has increased only incrementally over the past decade — cumulatively, about 26 % — tech design patents have shot through the roof.
Clients may decide that their portfolios should include a mix
of design patents of different scope to maximize their ability to collect damages from infringing competitors.
But as Nokia's name returns to the stage, there's been some attention to a renewed partnership with optics manufacturer Zeiss and a transfer
of design patents from Microsoft that cover, among many other things, the user interface featured on the beloved Lumia Camera app for Windows Phone.
Apple also notes that Oklahoma Associate Professor of Law Sarah Burstein, who had supported Samsung before the Federal Circuit with respect to design patent damages, decided not to sign her colleagues» Supreme Court brief because she fundamentally disagrees on the
question of design patent claim construction (as she made clear in this PatentlyO guest post Apple also points the Supreme Court to).
Apple surely are having a hard look of the device to make sure the popular 10 inch Android tablet stays
clear of its design patents while we do the same here too with help of NewGadgets.de who have got hold of the Samsung tablet to find out just what makes the the versions different.
The key question of the
value of design patents rallied Samsung supporters in the tech sector, and Apple backers in the creative and design communities.
Even Samsung's own expert witnesses gave testimony that allowed the court to infer that they had understood the scope
of those design patents quite well (for example, if someone says a patent is obvious, he must understand the patent in the first place).
It also suggests that the question of causation can not simply be kept
out of the design patent damages analysis the way the Federal Circuit and Judge Koh did.
Supreme Court Addresses Design Patent Damages for First Time in 120 Years: New
Era of Design Patent Damages Dawn
But in practical terms, I guess it wouldn't make (or have made) sense for Samsung to ask the top U.S. court to take a look at this matter while Samsung is trying to get the Supreme Court interested in a
couple of design patent issues.
Similarly, the list of top districts for design patent cases feature the Central District of California as the leader (as it is in trademark cases) rather than the familiar Eastern District of Texas (which appears in 9th place and has had less than 3 %
of design patent cases since 2012).
Its iPhone design defined smartphone style, and its vigorous
defense of its design patents has led to such judgments as a $ 1 billion verdict against Samsung for patent violation in 2012.
The pen or stylus is the
focus of the design patent though they're clearly envisioning it working with a newly styled smartphone with slight finger grooving down the side to give users a better grip of the display while writing, taking orders or drawing.
Chip Lutton, former Chief Patent Counsel at Apple Computer (2001 - 2011), in his enlightening talk at Berkeley Law on September 25, 2012, also agreed that the
importance of designs patents is on the rise after the Apple v. Samsung decision.
The United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) approved a
selection of design patents pertaining to three mysterious products on Tues...
Additionally, they point out Samsung has a «fundamental
misunderstanding of design patents,» and that the «totality of the circumstances» that the Korean company proposes as a test for originality is lackluster.
Citing a
violation of design patents, the Beijing Intellectual Property Office has ordered Apple to halt sales of its latest iPhone models on the territory of the city, Bloomberg reports.
Bob has additionally prepared and filed
hundreds of design patents that protect the ornamental appearance of a product, independent of the product's functional aspects.
In a 8 - 0 ruling, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that damages for infringement
of design patents under 35 U.S.C. § 289 can be limited to the defendant's «total profits» from the article of manufacture that contains the patented design, which may only be one component of a commercial product, rather than the entire product.