The evolution of Diane Ravitch's thinking is instructive; she seems to be honest enough to change her mind once evidence is in on the lack
of effectiveness of charter schools in general, and clear - eyed enough to recognize the disadvantages.
Not exact matches
This Monday night on BronxTalk two education experts will debate the
effectiveness of charter schools.
Fresh off the Legislature's second on - time budget in a row, Sen. Saland talks about the need to balance capital and administrative spending, explains the state budget's hold harmless rules and gives his opinion on the
effectiveness of charter schools in New York and around the country.
However, questions have been raised about the
effectiveness of learning outcomes in online
charter schools, as well as how they compete for limited educational resources.
It has also reviewed hundreds
of thousands
of reports to aid in distinguishing the best - quality research from weaker work, including studies on such subjects as the
effectiveness of charter schools and merit pay for teachers, which have informed the ongoing debate about these issues.
Stay tuned to the grant winners: Academy 21 at Franklin Central Supervisory Union in Vermont, which is focused on a high - need, predominantly rural community; Cornerstone
Charter Schools in Michigan, which seeks to prepare Detroit students for college and health - focused careers; Da Vinci Schools in California, which will integrate blended learning, early college, and real - world experiences with its existing project - based learning approach; Education Achievement Authority in Michigan, which, as part of the statewide turnaround authority is trying to create a student - centric system for students in Detroit; Match Education in Massachusetts, which already operates high - performing schools in Boston and will now focus on using technology to increase the effectiveness of its one - on - one tutoring; Schools for the Future in Michigan, which will serve students significantly below grade level; Summit Public Schools in California, which aims to build off its experiments in blended - learning models to launch a competency - based school; and Venture Academies in Minnesota, which is a new charter organization that will focus on accelerated college credit attainment and cultivation of entrepreneurial lead
Charter Schools in Michigan, which seeks to prepare Detroit students for college and health - focused careers; Da Vinci Schools in California, which will integrate blended learning, early college, and real - world experiences with its existing project - based learning approach; Education Achievement Authority in Michigan, which, as part of the statewide turnaround authority is trying to create a student - centric system for students in Detroit; Match Education in Massachusetts, which already operates high - performing schools in Boston and will now focus on using technology to increase the effectiveness of its one - on - one tutoring; Schools for the Future in Michigan, which will serve students significantly below grade level; Summit Public Schools in California, which aims to build off its experiments in blended - learning models to launch a competency - based school; and Venture Academies in Minnesota, which is a new charter organization that will focus on accelerated college credit attainment and cultivation of entrepreneurial lead
Schools in Michigan, which seeks to prepare Detroit students for college and health - focused careers; Da Vinci
Schools in California, which will integrate blended learning, early college, and real - world experiences with its existing project - based learning approach; Education Achievement Authority in Michigan, which, as part of the statewide turnaround authority is trying to create a student - centric system for students in Detroit; Match Education in Massachusetts, which already operates high - performing schools in Boston and will now focus on using technology to increase the effectiveness of its one - on - one tutoring; Schools for the Future in Michigan, which will serve students significantly below grade level; Summit Public Schools in California, which aims to build off its experiments in blended - learning models to launch a competency - based school; and Venture Academies in Minnesota, which is a new charter organization that will focus on accelerated college credit attainment and cultivation of entrepreneurial lead
Schools in California, which will integrate blended learning, early college, and real - world experiences with its existing project - based learning approach; Education Achievement Authority in Michigan, which, as part
of the statewide turnaround authority is trying to create a student - centric system for students in Detroit; Match Education in Massachusetts, which already operates high - performing
schools in Boston and will now focus on using technology to increase the effectiveness of its one - on - one tutoring; Schools for the Future in Michigan, which will serve students significantly below grade level; Summit Public Schools in California, which aims to build off its experiments in blended - learning models to launch a competency - based school; and Venture Academies in Minnesota, which is a new charter organization that will focus on accelerated college credit attainment and cultivation of entrepreneurial lead
schools in Boston and will now focus on using technology to increase the
effectiveness of its one - on - one tutoring;
Schools for the Future in Michigan, which will serve students significantly below grade level; Summit Public Schools in California, which aims to build off its experiments in blended - learning models to launch a competency - based school; and Venture Academies in Minnesota, which is a new charter organization that will focus on accelerated college credit attainment and cultivation of entrepreneurial lead
Schools for the Future in Michigan, which will serve students significantly below grade level; Summit Public
Schools in California, which aims to build off its experiments in blended - learning models to launch a competency - based school; and Venture Academies in Minnesota, which is a new charter organization that will focus on accelerated college credit attainment and cultivation of entrepreneurial lead
Schools in California, which aims to build off its experiments in blended - learning models to launch a competency - based
school; and Venture Academies in Minnesota, which is a new
charter organization that will focus on accelerated college credit attainment and cultivation of entrepreneurial lead
charter organization that will focus on accelerated college credit attainment and cultivation
of entrepreneurial leadership.
We have also found that teachers,
schools, and
charter management organizations within BCRC vary in their
effectiveness in supporting the development
of non-cognitive skills.
While the evidence for the
effectiveness of charter schools nationwide is mixed, research has found that the
charter schools in these cities are on average more effective than district
schools in raising student test scores.
Despite a record
of supporting
charter schools, presidential candidate Hillary Clinton questioned their
effectiveness in her campaign by saying that they «don't take the hardest - to - teach kids or, if they do, they don't keep them.»
Boston's oversubscribed
charter schools are of particular interest, as multiple studies have exploited the lottery admissions process to document the schools» effectiveness in raising student test scores (see «Boston and the Charter School Cap,» features, Winter
charter schools are
of particular interest, as multiple studies have exploited the lottery admissions process to document the
schools»
effectiveness in raising student test scores (see «Boston and the
Charter School Cap,» features, Winter
Charter School Cap,» features, Winter 2014).
Some organizations direct their activities only to district and / or
charter school issues, such as improving teacher quality and
effectiveness, developing new public
charter schools, or closing and transforming failing district
schools to create new high - quality
schools of choice.
In the piece, we discuss New Jersey's Assembly Bill 3105, which would block approval
of virtual
charters for one year while a study
of the general
effectiveness of full - time online
schooling is conducted.
Manno focuses on three
of these nonprofit organizations that have had helped to lift
charter school caps, implement «parent trigger» policies, and reform teacher
effectiveness provisions.
To many in the media, both studies sound like they are estimating the
effectiveness of charter schools or maybe even the impact
of school choice — so shouldn't the answer be the same?
Another research team, led by Josh Angrist and Parag Pathak, directors
of the
School Effectiveness and Inequality Initiative at MIT, compared «long - term outcomes» of Boston charter - school students to outcomes for BPS students who had entered charter - school admission lotteries (see Figu
School Effectiveness and Inequality Initiative at MIT, compared «long - term outcomes»
of Boston
charter -
school students to outcomes for BPS students who had entered charter - school admission lotteries (see Figu
school students to outcomes for BPS students who had entered
charter -
school admission lotteries (see Figu
school admission lotteries (see Figure 2).
Voucher supporters,
charter advocates, standards nuts, teacher -
effectiveness fanatics — we all fundamentally believe that fantastic
schools staffed by dedicated educators can help poor kids climb out
of poverty and compete with their affluent peers.
But the proposal to pay kids to learn is falling by the wayside, and the two RFTs
of charter school effectiveness helped sustain political support for the innovation.
•
Charter schools are no panacea, and legitimate concerns exist about the
effectiveness of for - profit education.
Given the statute's scope, today's debate could include countless issues, such as possible changes to Title II rules on educator
effectiveness, the expansion
of the
charter school grant program, the introduction
of a private
school choice initiative, reconsideration
of competitive grant programs (RTTT, TIF, i3), and much more.
In the end, our analysis
of charter school effectiveness is based on the experiences
of only those students for whom we observe annual gains (whether positive or negative) in test scores at least once in a
charter school and at least once in a traditional public
school.
His published work includes key studies on the
effectiveness of charter schools, the origins and inequities
of the racial achievement gap, and the impact
of historically black colleges and universities.
With all this evidence apparently stacked against
charter schools, it seems downright responsible
of the AFT to call for a moratorium on further
charter school expansion «until more convincing evidence
of their
effectiveness and viability is presented.»
As the RAND study
of charter schools and vouchers, Rhetoric Versus Reality, argued, «Judging the long - term
effectiveness of the
charter school movement based on outcomes
of infant
schools in their first two years
of operation may be unfair, or at least premature.»
Coleman's work spawned a large body
of research comparing the
effectiveness of district, private, and (later)
charter schools in preparing students for college and life.
And in Cambridge,
school officials in 2005 mailed letters to 4,000 families questioning the academic
effectiveness of a
charter school that had yet to open.
They should continue to support funding for the replication and expansion
of high - quality
charter schools, and they should make new investments in research and support for parent information, equitable funding and facilities, and innovative, low - regulation approaches to equity and
effectiveness in
schools of choice.
The
effectiveness of charter schools in raising student achievement has become an intensely debated issue.
But their work spawned a large body
of research comparing the
effectiveness of district, private, and (later)
charter schools in preparing students for college and life.
The
effectiveness of public
schools in developing engaged citizens has rarely been examined empirically,» notes a new Mathematica report on the impact on civic participation
of Democracy Prep, a network
of charter schools that educates more than 5,000 students, mostly in New York City.
At beginning
of their sample period, the average
effectiveness of charter schools was below that
of traditional public
schools.
Using rigorous non-experimental methods, a 2013 study
of charters in 16 states by the Center for Research on Education Outcomes found that average
charter school effectiveness increased overall, due in large part to closures
of poorly performing
schools.
Unlike the authors
of the Texas paper, however, the authors
of the North Carolina paper contend that the improvement in
charter school effectiveness is due to the increasingly positive selection
of students into
charter schools.
But in 2009, when the foundation announced it would award $ 335 million to a number
of school districts and
charter schools to promote teacher
effectiveness, the union response was a far cry from the anticorporate rhetoric it regularly delivers to its internal audience.
Just last week, the annual conference
of the Association for Education Finance and Policy featured new research on topics such as the importance
of charter organization type, the characteristics
of charter schools associated with
effectiveness,
charter student outcomes beyond standardized test scores.
Following an existing literature on teacher and
school value - added, this recent
charter school research controls for student demographics and baseline academic achievement in order to estimate the
effectiveness of individual
schools.
Brian Gill studies K — 12 education policy, including
charter schools, educator
effectiveness, and the implementation and impacts
of high - stakes testing and other accountability regimes.
But another important point from past studies is that there is enormous variation in the
effectiveness of charter schools.
The
effectiveness of voucher and
charter school programs has long been debated, and pro and con camps both cite studies to back up their points
of view.
Charter Schools, Achievers Early College Charter School, Camden, Coffee Break, growth, Individualized Education Program, Laura Waters, learning growth, local education agency, Mark Rynone, National Center for Special Education in Charter Schools, New Jersey, New Jersey Left Behind, New Jersey Special Education Collaborative, Newark, Newark Charter School Fund, NJ Left Behind, Paterson, Plainfield, School Choice, Special Education Medicaid Initiative, student achievement, student growth, student success, teacher effectiveness, teacher quality, The College of New Jersey, traditional public
Schools, Achievers Early College
Charter School, Camden, Coffee Break, growth, Individualized Education Program, Laura Waters, learning growth, local education agency, Mark Rynone, National Center for Special Education in
Charter Schools, New Jersey, New Jersey Left Behind, New Jersey Special Education Collaborative, Newark, Newark Charter School Fund, NJ Left Behind, Paterson, Plainfield, School Choice, Special Education Medicaid Initiative, student achievement, student growth, student success, teacher effectiveness, teacher quality, The College of New Jersey, traditional public
Schools, New Jersey, New Jersey Left Behind, New Jersey Special Education Collaborative, Newark, Newark
Charter School Fund, NJ Left Behind, Paterson, Plainfield,
School Choice, Special Education Medicaid Initiative, student achievement, student growth, student success, teacher
effectiveness, teacher quality, The College
of New Jersey, traditional public
schoolsschools
Mini-briefs in this series are: Regulating
Charter Schools; The
Effectiveness of Class Size Reduction; Does Money Matter?
The latest findings, based on six well - regarded
charter schools in Boston, released Wednesday by the Boston Foundation and MIT's
School Effectiveness and Inequality Initiative, adds to the accumulating evidence that at least a subset
of high - performing
charters are measuring up to the movement's early aspirations
of giving disadvantaged kids a shot at a better life.
In the work released Wednesday, researchers assess whether these test score gains are actually putting students on a path to better lives or simply the result
of charter schools»
effectiveness in «teaching to the test» for the MCAS.
The most striking finding was that
charter — high
school attendance may positively affect the chance that a student will graduate and go on to college — two critical outcomes that have not been examined in previous research — suggesting the need to look beyond achievement - test scores when measuring the
effectiveness of charter schools.
Many
of the
charter schools in our study aspire to boost minority achievement, so a natural benchmark for
charter effectiveness is the black - white test score gap.
The researchers conclude that the relative
effectiveness of urban lottery
charter schools can be explained by over-subscribed
schools» embrace
of the No Excuses approach to education.
He served as principal investigator for the first rigorous, nationwide examination
of the
effectiveness of nonprofit
charter -
school management organizations.
Lead author
of Rhetoric vs. Reality: What We Know and What We Need to Know About Vouchers and
Charter Schools, he has published in the Journal
of Research on Educational
Effectiveness, Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, Behavioral Science and Policy, Statistics and Public Policy, the Journal
of Labor Economics, Economics
of Education Review, Education Finance and Policy, American Journal
of Education, Teachers College Record, Peabody Journal
of Education, Education Next, the Handbook
of Research on
School Choice, and the Encyclopedia
of Education Economics and Finance.
In the 2013 - 2015 state budget, money for districts will be tight again, creating a new round
of challenges, which D'Andrea says will probably include merit pay, a teacher
effectiveness program, the expansion
of school choice, and maybe the creation
of a statewide
charter authorizer.
In the Summer 2013 issue
of Education Next, Joey Gustafson took a close look at the work
of charter school authorizers and at efforts to improve their
effectiveness.
This approach appears to produce reliable estimates
of charter effectiveness and does so in a manner that ensures high rates
of coverage for many different types
of charter schools in diverse locations across the country.