But to truly assess the role
of exaptation in evolution, they will need to validate their results in living organisms.
Barve and Wagner's work adds to a growing number of examples
of exaptation at the molecular level.
«If that was the only explanation for the incidence
of exaptation, that would not be interesting,» Wagner said.
The scientists conclude that this is probably an example
of exaptation — when a structure that was meant for one function is co-opted for another.
Not exact matches
At the heart
of your Behe article are two concessions which simply don't support ID: 1) the ability
of evolution to produce functional novelty via gene duplication / mutation and
exaptation exists; and 2) that evidence
of «new information» in the form
of «new Functional Coded elemenTs, or «FCTs»» also exists.
«I think it's becoming increasingly clear that
exaptation is very important in the evolution
of biologically important processes,» said Joe Thornton, a molecular evolutionary biologist at the University
of Chicago and the University
of Oregon, who was not involved in the study.
The results
of the study, which focused on metabolism, complement anecdotal examples and take an initial step toward quantifying
exaptation's contribution, at least within this system, said researchers not involved in the work.
Instead, the complexity
of the network appeared to determine its flexibility; the more reactions in a network, the greater its potential for
exaptation.
As they described it,
exaptation is a counterpart to the more familiar concept
of adaptation.
The strength
of Barve and Wagner's theoretical approach was that they could definitely demonstrate the potential for
exaptation outside
of any historical context.
The order and arrangement
of the bones in the four limbs
of land - dwelling animals are an
exaptation for walking on land, since these limbs originally evolved for navigating water; by contrast, changes to the shape
of the bones and to the musculature are adaptations, Gould and Vrba wrote.
Birds» and bats» wings could be called
exaptations of arms; however, the structural changes that followed can not be called adaptations because «you are talking about a historical incident; it's not something you can test,» said Mark Norell, a vertebrate paleontologist at the American Museum
of Natural History, who studied with Vrba.
This suggests that
exaptation was critical for the genesis
of the first nerve cell, with eumetazoan - specific gene innovations providing the regulatory and structural requirements to connect these protoneural components into a functional neuron (Fig. 3b).