In addition, numerous U.S. academic studies have found that the Reid technique produces a shocking
number of false confessions, especially in particularly vulnerable suspects, such as children or those of moderate to low intelligence.
Must Blairites fear a midnight knock on the door from the Momentum NKVD, ready to whisk them away to some God - forsaken Islington North Lubyanka, prior to the
extraction of false confessions by torture?
«This case — and the
frequency of false confessions in criminal cases — shows that common sense reforms like the videotaping of interrogations are needed to protect the innocent and our communities.»
Innocent people falsely confess due to psychological pressure placed upon them during police interrogations and confession contamination (see Brandon L Garrett, «The
Substance of False Confessions» (2010) 62 Stan L Rev 1051, at 1053).
The electronic recording of interrogations, from the reading of Miranda rights onward, is the single best reform available to stem the
tide of false confessions.
Some exonerees are denied their compensation
because of their false confessions, despite the fact that they were coerced, psychologically manipulated, and suffered the same amount as a result of the same failures of the criminal justice system.
Also, the
taping of a false confession does not catch the suspects whole life on camera, meaning that it would not capture events prior to the interrogation that might effect their mental health or current mental state.
At the center, Professor Drizin's research interests involve the
study of false confessions, and his policy work focuses on supporting efforts around the country to require law enforcement agencies to electronically record custodial interrogations.
They close the interview with an analysis of Brendan's defense attorney Len Kachinsky's duty of loyalty breach and the
realities of false confessions that they hope people will take away from their legal work.
The
problem of false confessions is widespread in New York; according to the Innocence Project statistics quoted in the City Room blog post, false confessions or admissions were involved in 10 of the 23 wrongful conviction cases in the state since 1991.
As discussed in an article by Meaghan Bixby in Temple Now, the popularity of Making a Murderer has highlighted the
issue of false confessions.
As Laura Nirider explained so well yesterday, defense lawyers and some courts have been developing a «new, scientifically - driven awareness of the problem
of false confessions.»
In the post, Laura acknowledged the problem
of false confessions — a problem she describes as happening «with disturbing regularity.»