Experts still predict that testing
of gene drive in the field is still years away.
One potential method of controlling the spread of an RNA - guided suppression drive is to combine it with another
form of gene drive that is threshold - dependent.
Still, many people are uncomfortable with the
idea of gene drives that have the potential to eradicate entire species.
At present, the
regulation of gene drive research does not fit within the purview of any of the U.S. agencies involved in the Coordinated Framework for the Regulation of Biotechnology, which includes the Food and Drug Administration, U.S. Department of Agriculture, and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
To navigate the uncertainty posed by this fast - moving field of study and make informed decisions about the development and potential application of gene - drive modified organisms, the committee that conducted the study and wrote the report recommended a collaborative, multidisciplinary, and cautionary approach to research on and
governance of gene drive technologies.
Potential
implications of gene drives fall beyond the purview of the lists of bacteriological and viral agents that now define security regimes.
The new technical work builds upon research by Austin Burt of Imperial College London, who, more than a decade ago, first proposed using a
type of gene drive based on cutting DNA to alter populations.
In researching and assessing potential new strategies, Campbell and his colleagues have made an argument for the use
of gene drives on islands.
«Every powerful technology is a national security issue,» says Kevin Esvelt, an evolutionary engineer at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in Cambridge, who won DARPA funding to limit the
spread of gene drives.
A UK - based team hopes to begin field
tests of gene drives in Anopheles gambiae mosquitoes, the main carrier of malaria in Africa, as soon as 2024.
The whole
point of a gene drive is to disperse in the wild, but government regulations are designed to keep genetic engineering out of wild organisms, says Zach Adelman, a molecular biologist at Virginia Tech in Blacksburg.
We don't know enough,» Esvelt says, adding, «I'm probably the foremost scientific
critic of gene drives even though I'm a leader in the field.»
But now scientists finally have a tool that allows them to harness the power
of gene drives more precisely and efficiently than ever: CRISPR — Cas9, the affordable and easy - to - use gene - editing tool that allows scientists to modify an organism's genome with extreme precision.
In this research project, investigators applied state - of - the - art genetic sequencing to learn the unique
set of genes driven specifically by NOD2 proteins.
Its report, Gene Drives on the Horizon: Advancing Science, Navigating Uncertainty and Aligning Research with Public Values, stresses that although gene drive offers great promise for agriculture, conservation, and public health, neither the science nor the current regulatory system is adequate to address the risks and
requirements of gene drive — altered organisms.
«Despite all the potential
benefits of gene drives, they remain understudied,» said Omar Akbari, an assistant professor of entomology at UC Riverside.
In selecting sites for potential field testing and environmental releases, the committee recommended that preference be given to locations in countries with existing scientific capacity and governance frameworks to conduct and oversee the safe
investigation of gene drives and the development of gene - drive modified organisms.
Despite the wide - ranging applicability and
importance of gene drives, there has been only modest development in their progress in past decades.
The remaining gaps in our understanding of the
biology of gene drives and the potential effects of gene - drive modified organisms on the environment are fundamental considerations in the development and release of gene - drive modified organisms, the report says.
The emerging
science of gene drives has the potential to address environmental and public health challenges, but gene - drive modified organisms are not ready to be released into the environment and require more research in laboratories and highly controlled field trials, says a new report from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine.
Robert Friedman of the J. Craig Venter Institute in San Diego, California, another AHTEG member who was singled out, similarly bristles at being criticized for encouraging experts to contribute to the online forum, especially given that
opponents of gene drives sometimes make «pretty fishy» statements there.
Like other
proponents of gene drive research, Kuiken contends that they could help control disease, remove invasive species, and create pest - resistant crops.
Jim Thomas of the Ottawa - based ETC Group said the U.S. military's substantial
funding of gene drive research «raises alarming question about this entire field,» and he called the technology «powerful and dangerous,» warning that it «could have disastrous impacts on peace, food security, and the environment.»
The public relations firm — which the critics note was given $ 1.6 million by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation to «increase awareness, understanding, and acceptance of possible gene drive applications for public good purposes» — also coordinates responses to postings on the online forum that are
critical of gene drives.
It is anticipated that within the next few years, several
versions of gene drive will be developed that build in even more safeguards to eliminate non-target impact.
When coupled with the use
of a gene drive naturally occurring in mice, this technique could ensure that all non-native mice on an infested island can be reached to affect an all - male - population unable to reproduce.
A self - sustaining method would require the use
of a gene drive designed to persist in the environment and spread within the target population, but with some risk of spreading into a non-targeted area where that same species may be desired.
Massachusetts Institute of Technology A model system to evaluate the dynamics and
safety of gene drive applications
Such reversibility, they say, could minimize the
chance of gene drives released into the wild turning into an ecological disaster.
«But if a lone wolf or terrorist group is working on this, the regulation
[of gene drives that government officials are contemplating] wouldn't make any difference.»
In an attempt to identify possible
ramifications of gene drives, the National Academy of Sciences has assembled experts to assess current regulations and recommend whether additional oversight is needed.
The Academy panel is expected to deliver a report next spring on, among other questions, biological techniques to reduce the risk of unintended
consequences of gene drives.
The speaker, Heath Packard from Island Conservation, explored the
concept of gene drives and how this method of introducing certain genetic traits to a specific population could be used to reduce invasive species» fertility — and, thus, their population.
Tina Hesman Saey discussed the power of a new gene - editing technique to boost the
development of gene drives in «Gene drives unleashed» (SN: 12/12/15, p. 16).
But some of the most powerful
forms of gene drives are hard to control or reverse, and without the proper biosecurity mechanisms they could theoretically spread beyond the target population to impact an entire species.
«It's a perfect place to start putting together the
governance of gene drives,» says Jim Thomas, a research programme manager at the ETC Group, an environmental organization in Ottawa, Canada, that supports a moratorium
In the paper, the authors focus on several
types of gene drives, including homing - based drives, sex - linked meiotic drives, medea and underdominance gene drives.