Not exact matches
Most
of these severe crises are linked to massive
volcanic activity,
global climate changes and sea level lowstands.
The best
global view
of the heavily cratered surface
of Mercury — a mosaic
of more than 140 images snapped by Mariner 10 in March 1974 — reveals expansive plains that may have been created by
volcanic activity.
By combining this data with Ridgwell's
global climate model, the team deduced the amount
of carbon added to the ocean and atmosphere and concluded that
volcanic activity during the opening
of the North Atlantic was the dominant force behind the PETM.
Interestingly, some scientists argue that without the cooling effect
of major
volcanic eruptions such as El Chichn and Mount Pinatubo,
global warming effects caused by human
activities would have been far more substantial.
As discussed elsewhere on this site, modeling studies indicate that the modest cooling
of hemispheric or
global mean temperatures during the 15th - 19th centuries (relative to the warmer temperatures
of the 11th - 14th centuries) appears to have been associated with a combination
of lowered solar irradiance and a particularly intense period
of explosive
volcanic activity.
Researchers have found that glacial erosion and melting ice caps both played a key role in driving the observed
global increase in
volcanic activity at the end
of the last ice age.
Human induced trend has two components, namely (a) greenhouse effect [this includes
global and local / regional component] and (b) non-greenhouse effect [local / regional component]-- according to IPCC (a) is more than half
of global average temperature anomaly wherein it also includes component
of volcanic activities, etc that comes under greenhouse effect; and (b) contribution is less than half — ecological changes component but this is biased positive side by urban - heat - island effect component as the met network are concentrated in urban areas and rural - cold - island effect is biased negative side as the met stations are sparsely distributed though rural area is more than double to urban area.
It's pertinent to your point that the
global temperature drifted downwards a tad between 1880ish and 1910ish, a result most likely
of the large
volcanic activity in that period.
I particularly enjoyed the slides that, when combined (1) provided an overview
of hotter and cooler CO2 molecules as it relates to how they are seen from outer space and from profile — because this will make it easier for me to explain this process to others; (2) walked through the
volcanic and solar
activity vs assigning importance to CO2 changes — because this another way to help make it clearer, too, but in another way; (3) discussed CO2 induced warming and ocean rise vs different choices we might make — because this helps point out why every day's delay matters; and (4) showed Figure 1 from William Nordhaus» «Strategies for Control
of Carbon Dioxide» and then super-imposed upon that the
global mean temperature in colors showing pre-paper and post-paper periods — because this helps to show just how far back it was possible to make reasoned projections without the aid
of a more nuanced and modern understanding.
Thus, Victor the Troll, to contradict all that you wrote @ 221, «the dissipation
of aerosols from any given eruption IS caused by a lack
of volcanic activity,» and
global temperatures CAN «rise above (the) level» «they would have been had the volcanoes not occurred» because the impact
of previous volcanism would have also dissipated in the interval.
Reminds me
of the UK met Office annual predictions, which forecast annual
global temperatures based on atlantic multidecadal oscillation, ENSO, solar, recent
volcanic activity and, crucially, radiative forcing due to GHG.
We do have reasonably good estimates
of global temperature in the period prior to and after 1910 (or if you prefer 1912, when Novarupta erupted), and we do have reasonably good estimates
of volcanic activity during that period and beyond, as illustrated in the paper Kevin cited, by Robock.
You provide no evidence
of some substantial increase in
volcanic and / or earthquake
activity in the
global warming period since 1900, or the more recent
global warming period
of since 1970.
A statistical model (based on the work
of Judith Lean at the Naval Research Laboratory) that accounts for solar variability, El Niño,
volcanic activity, and greenhouse warming indicates that the underlying trend
of global warming has accelerated over the past 15 years.
Like Foster and Rahmstorf, Lean and Rind (2008) performed a multiple linear regression on the temperature data, and found that although
volcanic activity can account for about 10 %
of the observed
global warming from 1979 to 2005, between 1889 and 2006
volcanic activity had a small net cooling effect on
global temperatures.
A paper published in Environmental Research Letters by Rahmstorf, Foster, and Cazenave (2012) applied the methodology
of Foster and Rahmstorf (2011), using the statistical technique
of multiple regression to filter out the influences
of the El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) and solar and
volcanic activity from the
global surface temperature data to evaluate the underlying long - term primarily human - caused trend.
I'm not predicting huge
volcanic eruptions, just cooling, affected mostly by already weak and declining solar
activity and continuation
of the oscillatory behaviour
of the
global temperature indices.
Also
volcanic activity is being blamed for the lack
of global temperature rise yet it is not accepted as part
of the reason for the cold a century ago.
If periods
of horrific
volcanic activity and horrendous meteor strikes barely budged
global temperature from its cyclic course
of transitions between Ice Ages and Warm Periods, man's puny efforts are surely lost in the noise.
Other leading theories to causes
of mass extinctions include:
global climate change, changes in sea level, chemical poisoning
of the atmosphere and / or oceans, variation in solar radiation, and extreme
volcanic activity.
Now imagine the kind
of extra
volcanic activity that could result from 1, 6, or 250 feet
of global sea level rise under the raging rate
of human - caused warming and you begin to understand the concern.
The world's climate is way too complex... with way too many significant
global and regional variables (e.g., solar,
volcanic and geologic
activity, variations in the strength and path
of the jet stream and major ocean currents, the seasons created by the tilt
of the earth, and the concentration
of water vapor in the atmosphere, which by the way is many times more effective at holding heat near the surface
of the earth than is carbon dioxide, a non-toxic, trace gas that all plant life must have to survive, and that produce the oxygen that WE need to survive) to consider for any so - called climate model to generate a reliable and reproducible predictive model.
10 Most past changes in world climates were caused by natural factors
Volcanic activity Motion
of the continents Recently scientists have observed climate changes that are the result
of HUMAN
ACTIVITIES GLOBAL WARMING
This is currently the leading cause
of global climate change even though there is always natural factors as well such as
volcanic processes and solar
activity, but not at the rate
of climate change we have seen the last century.
I have heard it said that periods
of severe
volcanic activity in the geological past increased
global temperatures by emitting substantial volumes
of greenhouse gases.
A paper published in Environmental Research Letters by Rahmstorf, Foster, and Cazenave (2012) applied the methodology
of Foster and Rahmstorf (2011), using the statistical technique
of multiple regression to filter out the influences
of the El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) and solar and
volcanic activity from the
global surface temperature data to evaluate the underlying long - term human - caused trend.
Figure 1: Contributions
of solar
activity (dark blue),
volcanic activity (red), ENSO (green), and anthropogenic effects (purple) to
global surface warming (HadCRUT observations shown in light blue), according to Lean and Rind (2008).
The climate has changed many times in the geologic past due to natural causes — including
volcanic activity, changes in the sun's intensity, fluctuations in Earth's orbit, and other factors — but none
of these can account for the current rise in
global temperatures.
RFC12 takes a very clever approach to address this issue, applying the methodology
of Foster and Rahmstorf (2011), using the statistical technique
of multiple regression to filter out the influences
of ENSO and solar and
volcanic activity from the
global surface temperature data (Figure 1).
So solar,
volcanic activity, ENSO / AMO etc. are independent
of TCR and any measurement
of TCR would presumably have accounted for their (presumed estimated) effect upon
global temperatures.
Figure 1:
Global surface and lower atmosphere temperature data from 5 data sets (with a 12 - month running average) before and after applying the statistical methodology
of Foster and Rahmstorf (2011) to remove the influences
of ENSO and solar and
volcanic activity.
According to climatologist Cliff Harris, we «are seeing an increase in
volcanic activity worldwide» and this could easily lead to a period
of significant
global cooling if it continues...
Precession / obliquity — Precession very favorable while obliquity is lessening and becoming more favorable as compared to the Holocene Optimum period
of time and this is why I think the
global temperatures in general have been on a decline overall since the Holocene optimum however with fits and starts due to solar
activity changes /
volcanic activity and enso superimposed upon this general trend.
The images show that the axial valley at 4,000 m water depth is blanketed by an extensive set
of pyroclastic deposits, raising important questions regarding the accumulation and discharge
of magmatic volatiles on such ridges and demonstrating that large - scale pyroclastic
activity is possible along even the deepest portions
of the
global mid-ocean ridge
volcanic system.
http://www.agci.org/docs/lean.pdf «
Global (and regional) surface temperature fluctuations in the past 120 years reflect, as in the space era, a combination
of solar,
volcanic, ENSO, and anthropogenic influences, with relative contributions shown in Figure 6.22 The adopted solar brightness changes in this scenario are based on a solar surface flux transport model; although long - term changes are «50 % larger than the 11 - year irradiance cycle, they are significantly smaller than the original estimates based on variations in Sun - like stars and geomagnetic
activity.
Its main message — largely missing from news reports and blogs alike — is that carbon emissions interact with a wide range
of other factors, from
volcanic activity to El Niño weather patterns, in determining the trajectory
of global temperatures.
The unrelated, noncyclical events that reduce hurricane
activity, including
volcanic eruptions, have masked a progressive rise in sea temperatures because
of global warming, he said.
Foster and Rahmstorf (2011) used multiple linear regression to filter out the effects
of the El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO), and solar and
volcanic activity (Figure 2), and found that the underlying
global surface and lower atmosphere warming trends have remained very steady in recent years (Figure 3).
In the study (Kathleen Compton, Richard A. Bennett, and Sigrun Hreinsdottir, «Climate driven vertical acceleration
of Icelandic crust measured by CGPS geodesy,» Geophysical Research Letters 42 (3): 743 — 750, 2015) the authors don't try to blame «
global warming» for increased
volcanic activity.
One major
volcanic eruption would affect
global climate more than any variance in solar
activity, and much more than any supposed «man - made climate change» with drastic amounts
of particulate matter being expelled into the atmosphere that utterly dwarf the impact
of all
of us.
1816 is widely referred to as «The Year Without a Summer» because
volcanic activity the year before triggered such a significant decrease in
global temperatures that many areas
of the world had frost and snow throughout their spring and summer seasons.