Many lawmakers have been asking for a delay in the implementation, and to put off the consequences
of the high stakes tests for school children for another couple of years.
Besides the
issue of high stakes test and data, there is a major movement that needs to occur before teachers will come to the table and negotiate new forms and criteria for evaluation.
As legislators, demand the evidence, particularly the literature that illustrates the damaging
effects of high stakes test scores in teacher evaluations.
Parents have voiced that while they are not against testing, they are against the implications the
amount of high stakes testing has on their student's future and well - being.
One 2012 study found that instructional quality declined with the
rise of high stakes testing, especially in the weeks before the exam.
In today's
climate of high stakes testing, business leaders and politicians continue to demand better results with data driven assessments and test scores.
Last year she and other teachers at her school declared themselves «teachers of conscience» a form of conscientious objection in relation to the overwhelming negative
impact of high stakes testing.
«Last year the State Superintendent was able to remove five state assessments in science and social studies in an effort to cut down on the number
of high stakes tests students take.
«We want to see a reduction in the
number of high stakes tests students are required to take,» NCAE's Ellis told N.C. Policy Watch, adding that reducing testing was another of the teachers» association's top priorities for this year's legislative session.
Hostile work conditions with colleagues, high pressure
demands of high stakes testing, diminished autonomy, and inadaquate planning time are cited as key reasons why this generation of teaher's psychosocial health is on the decline and they are leaving the profession.
The six criteria are: 1)
rejection of high stakes testing, 2) the professionalization of teaching, 3) rejection of public school privatization 4) financial support 5) how well taxpayers resources are spent and 6) children's chances for success.
He said, «In the present
environment of high stakes testing, budgetary challenges, increased demands on educators and competition for students attention, everyone in the school benefits when humor is part of the pedagogy.
Maybe to a
plethora of high stakes tests and other assessments that already exist across our planet we can consider including questions that ask students: «How might you plan to spend the next 24 to 36 hours of your life?
«All of us think our children should be challenged by difficult tasks in school and that the performance of teachers in the classroom should be judged by the highest standards, but there is no scientific validity whatsoever to the use
of high stakes tests as the primary instrument for evaluating children and teachers.
Reclaiming Camelot: Capturing the Reflections of Exemplary, Veteran Middle School Teachers in an
Age of High Stakes Testing and Accountability Through Narrative Inquiry, Nancy Fichtman Dana, Darby Claire Delane, and Paul George
Given the
primacy of high stakes tests in many locations, how do we ensure that curriculum and instruction remain tools for shaping lives in positive ways?
«It is shocking that our national union leader is proposing a national high stakes exam for educators, while at the same time leading a national campaign supposedly against the
overuse of high stakes testing for students,» said Julie Cavanagh, NYC teacher and UFT presidential candidate with MORE caucus.
The critical conversation that needs to be had is not about the
administration of high stakes testing, but rather about which data and information can be gleaned from assessment in order to improve student achievement and learning.
WHEREAS, the new evaluation system based on NYS Education Law 3012c disproportionately weights the use
of high stakes test scores over qualitative assessments as «Measures of Student Learning (MOSL)» in determining teacher performance, leading to a proliferation of Common Core - aligned tests with devastating consequences for teaching and learning conditions in our schools, and
However, the UFT is calling for a moratorium on using the
results of high stakes tests for teacher evaluations until alterations to the local portion of the Measures of Student Learning portion of the system can be worked out in contract negotiations.