This is in agreement with the recent results of [CITE], but it is in contrast to the earlier analysis of [CITE], and suggests that the source
of the irradiance variations is the same for cycles 22 and 23, namely the evolution of the magnetic flux at the solar surface.
Data records of sufficient duration are expected to reveal the extent
of irradiance variations over time that reflect a combination of cause and effect of climate change.
Not exact matches
11 Duration, in years,
of a typical solar cycle, natural
variations in the number
of sunspots and flares that affect solar
irradiance levels on Earth.
Solar
irradiance modulation
of Equator - to - Pole (Arctic) temperature gradients: Empirical evidence for climate
variation on multi-decadal timescales
The «equilibrium» sensitivity
of the global surface temperature to solar
irradiance variations, which is calculated simply by dividing the absolute temperature on the earth's surface (288K) by the solar constant (1365Wm - 2), is based on the assumption that the climate response is linear in the whole temperature band starting at the zero point.
Dr. Benestad states: «From regression analysis cited by the authors (Douglass and Clader 2002, White et al. 1997), it seems possible that the sensitivity
of global surface temperature to
variations of total solar
irradiance might be about 0.1 K / Wm -2.
On the other hand, Esper's data appear to be in close agreement with
variations in cosmogenic isotopes whose production rates are indicators
of variation in solar
irradiance, and thus, global temperatures on Earth.
Typhoon variability was likely modulated further by the state
of the East Asia summer monsoon (EASM) pattern, associated with
variation in the magnitude
of solar
irradiance.
As examples
of work in this category, I would mention Judith Lean's tireless efforts on relating luminosity to sunspot number, the work
of Bard and colleagues on developing isotopic solar proxies like 10Be, Shindell's work on response to solar ultraviolet variability, and the work
of Foukal et al on factors governing solar
irradiance variations.
Important manifestations
of such external forcing from space to the atmosphere are the
variations in different solar parameters such as the solar
irradiance (including solar UV) and solar particle fluxes, which can induce changes in the atmosphere both at local and global scales, and can influence over a large range
of altitudes.
Let's set the stage by noting that, as a significant competitor to anthropogenic greenhouse forcing
of recent climate change, the direct radiative forcing by solar
irradiance variations is dead on arrival.
Changes in insolation are also thought to have arisen from small
variations in solar
irradiance, although both timing and magnitude
of past solar radiation fluctuations are highly uncertain (see Chapters 2 and 6; Lean et al., 2002; Gray et al., 2005; Foukal et al., 2006).
Solar
irradiance variations are sometimes assumed to be the most likely natural driver
of climate change.
We only have direct observations
of total solar
irradiance (TSI) since the beginning
of the satellite era and substantial evidence for
variations in the level
of solar activity (from cosmogenic isotopes or sunspot records) in the past.
Because
of the
variations of sunspots and faculae on the sun's surface, the total solar
irradiance (TSI), also called the solar constant, varies on a roughly 11 - year cycle by about 0.07 %, which has been measured by orbiting satellites since 1978 [Lean, 1987, 1991; Wilson et al., 1981].
...» We describe the
variations with time
of the solar
irradiance and
of the flux
of ejected magnetised plasma.
While the later is useful, as it is all that we have earlier than 1978 or so, direct measurements
of irradiance show that the
variation is at best 1 part in 1300 over the last forty or so years
In the May issue
of Astronomy & Astrophysics, Shapiro et al. present a new long - term reconstruction
of the solar
irradiance that implies much greater
variation over the last 7000 years than any previous ly reconstruction.
See e.g. this review paper (Schmidt et al, 2004), where the response
of a climate model to estimated past changes in natural forcing due to solar
irradiance variations and explosive volcanic eruptions, is shown to match the spatial pattern
of reconstructed temperature changes during the «Little Ice Age» (which includes enhanced cooling in certain regions such as Europe).
They claim that the evidence for Milankovitch forcing
of the ice ages implies that the planet is hypersensitive to solar
irradiance variations.
The Top
Of Atmosphere solar
irradiance varies from about 1365.4 watts per meter squared to about 1366.4 watts / M ^ 2, but that
variation (less than 1 %) doesn't modulate the global temperature significantly — see http://www.woodfortrees.org/plot/pmod/from:1978/mean:10/offset:-1366/plot/wti/from:1978/mean:10
Or, even more broadly, we know there's approx. 0,1 %
variation of solar
irradiance between two cycles minima (Willson 2003), how do we exclude with reasonable confidence the hypothesis that there is a 1 %
variation between 21.000 y BP and 1750 AD?
The IPCC 2001 report states «Several recent reconstructions estimate that
variations in solar
irradiance give rise to a forcing at the Earth's surface
of about 0.6 to 0.7 Wm - 2 since the Maunder Minimum and about half this over the 20th century... All reconstructions indicate that the direct effect
of variations in solar forcing over the 20th century was about 20 to 25 %
of the change in forcing due to increases in the well - mixed greenhouse gases.»
Title: «Shortwave forcing
of the Earth's climate: Modern and historical
variations in the Sun's
irradiance and Earth's reflectance» Author, P.R. Goode, E. Pallé Journal: Journal
of ATMOSPHERIC and SOLAR - TERRESTRIAL PHYSICS DoP: Sept 2007 DOI: 10.1016 / j.jastp.2007.06.011
The Holy Grail
of climatology has always been to ascertain whether, and if so how, the sun might affect the Earth's energy budget to cause the climate swings observed throughout history despite the apparent inadequacy
of the tiny
variations in Total Solar
Irradiance (TSI) that occur from one series
of solar cycles to another.
Oceanic oscillations are sufficient to cancel out or enhance the effects
of natural
variations in solar
irradiance or other forms
of solar input to the heat budget
of the Earth for variable periods
of time.
Whatever wide - ranging coherence one finds at multi-decadal frequencies is more likely the result
of global - scale
variations in cloud - regulated thermalization
of solar
irradiance and the lagged advection
of heat from the tropics by winds and ocean currents.
Douglas Hoyt and Kenneth Schatten, «A Discussion
of Plausible Solar
Irradiance Variations, 1700 - 1992,» Journal
of Geophysical Research, v. 98, no.
A third example would be the research on how incoming solar
irradiance influences China's thermometer temperature records, showing that over periods
of many decades the
variations in total solar
irradiance in the upper atmosphere are matched by
variations at the surface.
(See Soon & Legates 2013: Solar
irradiance modulation
of Equator - to - Pole (Arctic) temperature gradients: Empirical evidence for climate
variation on multi-decadal timescales.)
Parsimony is not a grounds for ignoring the now mountain
of evidence that solar activity does somehow drive climate much more powerfully than can be explained by the tiny
variation in solar
irradiance, and the implications
of a solar explanation for 20th century warming are much different than for an internal -
variation explanation.
«Since
irradiance variations are apparently minimal, changes in the Earth's climate that seem to be associated with changes in the level
of solar activity — the Maunder Minimum and the Little Ice age for example — would then seem to be due to terrestrial responses to more subtle changes in the Sun's spectrum
of radiative output.
Soon, W. and D.R. Legates, 2013: Solar
irradiance modulation
of equator - to - pole (Arctic) temperature gradients: empirical evidence for climate
variation on multi-decadal timescales, Journal
of Atmospheric and Solar - Terrestrial Physics 93: 45 — 56.
Soon, W., 2005: Variable solar
irradiance as a plausible agent for multidecadal
variations in the Arctic - wide surface air temperature record
of the past 130 years, Geophysical Research Letters32: doi.10.1029 / 2005GL023429.
Shortwave forcing
of the Earth's climate: modern and historical
variations in the Sun's
irradiance and the Earth's reflectance, P.R. Goode, E. Palle, J. Atm.
We also show that a non-thermal solar component is necessarily present, indicating that the total solar contribution to the 20th century global warming,
of ∆ Tsolar = 0.27 ± 0.07 ◦ C, is much larger than can be expected from
variation in the total solar
irradiance alone.
In the summary
of Chapter 7, one can read that the effects
of variation in solar radiation are negligible You seem to miss the whole point.: «The Chapter 7 authors are admitting strong evidence («many empirical relationships») for enhanced solar forcing (forcing beyond total solar
irradiance, or TSI), even if they don't know what the mechanism is.»
There could also be other unknown mechanisms driven by solar changes that exaggerate the effect
of small
variations in total solar
irradiance.
First, this is possible because helioseismic data provide the most precise measure ever
of the solar cycle, which ultimately yields more profound physical limits on past
irradiance variations.
Figure 1 (a) represents the corrected visible light from Neptune from 1950 to 2006; (b) shows the temperature anomalies
of the Earth; (c) shows the total solar
irradiance as a percent
variation by year; (d) shows the ultraviolet emission from the Sun (Source: Hammel and Lockwood (2007)-RRB-.
Second, their temperature reconstructions were not based exclusively on TSI changes as the sole source
of temperature
variation, but included associated changes in spectral
irradiance that would be expected to amplify TSI effects, changes in UV being one example.
Shortwave forcing
of the earth's climate: Modern and historical
variations in the sun's
irradiance and the earth's reflectance.
In order to reliably interpret surface temperature
variations we need a good idea
of all the causal factors, including El Niño, solar
irradiance, volcanic eruptions, observational biases, changes in ocean circulation and possible long term oscillations.
Regarding solar, most sceptics are focused on the solar
variation between the 11 - year cycles and not on the
irradiance variation between minima and maxima
of the single cycles.
«All 18 periods
of significant climate changes found during the last 7,500 years were entirely caused by corresponding quasi-bicentennial
variations of [total solar
irradiance] together with the subsequent feedback effects, which always control and totally determine cyclic mechanism
of climatic changes from global warming to Little Ice Age.»
Solar forcing is the only known natural forcing acting to warm the climate over this period but it has increased much less than greenhouse gas forcing, and the observed pattern
of long term tropospheric warming and stratospheric cooling is not consistent with the expected response to solar
irradiance variations.
Although we focus on a hypothesized CR - cloud connection, we note that it is difficult to separate changes in the CR flux from accompanying
variations in solar
irradiance and the solar wind, for which numerous causal links to climate have also been proposed, including: the influence
of UV spectral
irradiance on stratospheric heating and dynamic stratosphere - troposphere links (Haigh 1996); UV
irradiance and radiative damage to phytoplankton influencing the release
of volatile precursor compounds which form sulphate aerosols over ocean environments (Kniveton et al. 2003); an amplification
of total solar
irradiance (TSI)
variations by the addition
of energy in cloud - free regions enhancing tropospheric circulation features (Meehl et al. 2008; Roy & Haigh 2010); numerous solar - related influences (including solar wind inputs) to the properties
of the global electric circuit (GEC) and associated microphysical cloud changes (Tinsley 2008).
http://www.agci.org/docs/lean.pdf «Global (and regional) surface temperature fluctuations in the past 120 years reflect, as in the space era, a combination
of solar, volcanic, ENSO, and anthropogenic influences, with relative contributions shown in Figure 6.22 The adopted solar brightness changes in this scenario are based on a solar surface flux transport model; although long - term changes are «50 % larger than the 11 - year
irradiance cycle, they are significantly smaller than the original estimates based on
variations in Sun - like stars and geomagnetic activity.
Just how effective this driver is has remained relatively uncertain, however, partly due to missing knowledge on the exact
variation of the Sun's
irradiance over time in different parts
of the solar spectrum.
We find that most
of the solar cycle
variation in the total solar
irradiance can be accounted for by the absolute magnetic field strength on the solar disk, if fields associated with dark and bright regions are considered separately.