For a long time, Delaware has been unique in having as an aspect of its system
of judicial discipline, a process in which a sole judicial officer, the Chief Justice, is expected to review incoming complaints and dismiss those that do not state a proper claim.
Given the important purpose
of the judicial discipline process, the critical role of integrity in ensuring public confidence in the judiciary, and the need to ensure fairness to Justice Girouard, the Ministers agree that the best course of action is to jointly request, pursuant to s. 63 (1) of the Judges Act, that an inquiry be held into the findings of the majority of the Inquiry Committee that prompted it to recommend his removal.»
Not exact matches
But the concerns cited above show why it is important that
judicial decisions be
disciplined, based on sources
of law other than the judge's own view
of political morality.
In The Historian and the Believer, 57 Van A. Harvey uses the metaphor
of judicial proceedings to illuminate the different relationships between evidence, warrants, and conclusions involved in the «field - encompassing»
discipline practiced by the modern scientific historian.
The concern
of judicial conservatives was sparked by those liberal judges untethered from the
discipline of the text, who would soar off to invent new «rights.»
True, there are stated procedures to
discipline an erring judge; and in fairness, the National
Judicial Council (NJC) has latterly gone on the offensive to
discipline some
of such judges.
The
Judicial Council has set up a five - member committee to
discipline those implicated after outcome
of the investigations.
Any legal challenge to these regulations faces an uphill battle, yet
judicial efforts may be needed to prevent ED and DOJ from using the civil rights laws to federalize all issues
of discipline in the nation's schools.
In ordering the disbarment, the Supreme
Judicial Court rejected Finneran's contention that he should be given lighter
discipline because his false testimony was unrelated to his practice
of law.
The way in which the Trial Chamber reacted to Alternate Judge Sow's decision to make a public statement on the Taylor Trial; the exclusion
of his statement from the official transcript
of the hearing; and the recent information suggesting irregularities in the process which the SCSL judges invoked to
discipline their
judicial colleague for alleged misconduct all underscore the need for greater transparency on this issue than we have so far received from the SCSL.
The Registrant petitioned for
judicial review
of the Council's ruling, but the review was dismissed and the
discipline matter remanded.
All the lawyers
disciplined so far by the Law Society
of Upper Canada under its
judicial complaints protocol are women.
The recitation
of the facts and the reasons are an appalling example
of the gross abuse
of judicial power and the judge who gave them should have been
disciplined.
That could be evidence
of a good judiciary, but also possible that the
judicial discipline and removal process has not been as effective as it might be.
That affair was one
of the developments that led to the current
judicial discipline process at the federal level in the 1970s.
A New Brunswick Court
of Queen's Bench judge who took months, sometimes years, to render decisions will not be
disciplined following a review by the Canadian
Judicial Council.
If anyone can point to me where last month's ruling
of the «sharply divided national federal
judicial discipline committee» is available online so that I can link to it, or if anyone can send an electronic copy
of that ruling to me so that I can post it online, I will be most appreciative.
Texas: bill removes power
of State Commission on
Judicial Conduct to
discipline judges who refuse to follow federal court rulings; claims state judges have free speech right to refuse to obey federal court rulings
The office oversees attorney admissions, attorney registration, mandatory continuing legal and
judicial education, attorney diversion and
discipline, regulation
of the unauthorized practice
of law, and inventory counsel.
In this class
of cases, we think the rule
of action which should govern the civil courts, founded in a broad and sound view
of the relations
of church and state under our system
of laws, and supported by a preponderating weight
of judicial authority, is that whenever the questions
of discipline or
of faith or ecclesiastical rule, custom, or law have been decided by the highest
of these church judicatories to which the matter has been carried, the legal tribunals must accept such decisions as final and as binding on them in their application to the case before them.
The Court has adopted a Code
of Judicial Conduct, and upon the recommendation
of the
Judicial Qualifications Commission, it may
discipline or remove any Justice or judge who is found to have violated code standards.
The court held that the canon, minus the unconstitutional «appear to commit» language, permitted any speech by a
judicial candidate, short
of a pledge, promise, or commitment to adjudicate a particular result, and thus candidates could respond to questionnaires without fear
of discipline.
Further, if the
discipline committee (and the entire Board) have been exposed to a «mediation agreement» relating to the respondent, such that the members
of the
Discipline Committee might be precluded from hearing the matter, due to a reasonable apprehension
of bias, a
judicial review will still be premature if any possibility remains an unbiased
discipline panel being convened.
Another major initiative was reforming the Courts
of Justice Act, to improve the
judicial complaints and discipline process and to broaden the possible sanctions available to the Judicial
judicial complaints and
discipline process and to broaden the possible sanctions available to the
Judicial Judicial Council.
To the benefit
of all Canadians, we need your financial support to force modern standards
of accountability, transparency and performance upon the Canadian
Judicial Council — the organization mandated to investigate and
discipline Canada's federal judges.
Frequently appears as prosecution counsel and defence counsel for colleges
of regulated professionals before
discipline committees and on appeal or
judicial review in the courts;
We went through a process which concluded that we should have a professional and independent adjudicative body, and that the sole purpose
of that body should be to play a
judicial role with respect to lawyer
discipline.
The majority held that decisions about professional
discipline are akin to prosecutorial discretion, such that errors «must likely approach an abuse
of process to invite
judicial intervention» (at para 47).
[1] Cooperation with investigations and proceedings
of judicial and lawyer
discipline agencies, as required in paragraph (A), instills confidence in judges» commitment to the integrity
of the
judicial system and the protection
of the public and may be considered by the
judicial and lawyer
discipline agencies as a mitigating factor.
The Lawyer: Employment judge first to fall foul
of new misconduct rules An employment judge has become the first to be publicly censured under new rules that will see all judges and magistrates who are
disciplined for misconduct have their cases publicised by the Office for
Judicial Complaints (OJC).
Whether
discipline should be imposed should be determined through a reasonable and reasoned application
of the Rules, and should depend upon factors such as the seriousness
of the transgression, the facts and circumstances that existed at the time
of the transgression, the extent
of any pattern
of improper activity, whether there have been previous violations, and the effect
of the improper activity upon the
judicial system or others.
There are two instances
of judicial humour in the matter: word play («port
of call») which occurs before the magistrate delivers the decision to dismiss the charges; and a reference to military
discipline, which occurs at the very end
of the matter.
We recommend that the Supreme Court appoint a study commission to review these and other recommendations for reform
of our attorney and
judicial discipline rules and procedures.
We respectfully suggest that the
discipline process is a civil proceeding and thus falls within the protective walls
of the
Judicial Immunity Doctrine.
A denial
of judicial immunity to Judge Bamberger will put every judge in Kentucky under the threat
of KBA
discipline sanctions if they acted on representations made by the attorneys or parties who appeared before them.
Loss
of the standard
of correctness gives rise to the potential loss
of the «
judicial self -
discipline» advocated by Justice Iacobucci [xiii]-- eliminating the separate category
of correctness may actually weaken judges» mental focus on deference under reasonableness.
There is an important jurisdictional question raised by the attempt
of the KBA to
discipline a judge for acts taken by the judge in his jurisdiction without the referral by the
Judicial Conduct Commission.
Whether disciplinary action is appropriate, and the degree
of discipline, should be determined through a reasonable application
of the text and should depend on such factors as the seriousness
of the improper activity, the intent
of the judge, whether there is a pattern
of improper activity, and the effect
of the improper activity on others or on the
judicial system.
The Code
of Judicial Conduct provides that, although such opinions are not per se binding on the
Judicial Conduct Board, the Court
of Judicial Discipline, or the Supreme Court
of Pennsylvania, action taken in reliance thereon shall be considered in determining whether
discipline should be recommended or imposed.
A sharply divided national federal
judicial discipline committee ruled 3 to 2 in late April that it had no power to sanction Real, 81, because the chief judge
of the U.S. 9th Circuit Court
of Appeals failed to properly investigate the complaint.
Bamberger asserted that «Section 121 (
of the Kentucky Constitution) fixes original jurisdiction for
judicial discipline exclusively in the (Judicial Conduct) Commission..
judicial discipline exclusively in the (
Judicial Conduct) Commission..
Judicial Conduct) Commission...»
A major academic objective
of the degree program is to help create and define a new academic
discipline,
judicial studies.
Rules
of Judicial Disciplinary Procedure: These rules set forth the mechanisms of the Judicial Hearing Board and govern the procedure for discipline of judicial o
Judicial Disciplinary Procedure: These rules set forth the mechanisms
of the
Judicial Hearing Board and govern the procedure for discipline of judicial o
Judicial Hearing Board and govern the procedure for
discipline of judicial o
judicial officers.
Chinese President Xi Jinping has made clear that the courts must submit to the
discipline of the central party and
judicial officials who are directed by the state and the party.
Rambo's article notes that «surprisingly, most
of the state and federal courts deciding
judicial discipline cases based on extrajudicial speech have not addressed the constitutionality
of the code provisions involved.»
Although we have authority to deflect cases to the Court
of Appeals, which relieves much
of the load, the more difficult and complex cases, plus all cases involving constitutional questions, death penalty, first impressions, newly developing law and a whole litany
of special subjects (election contests, utility rates, annexations, bar and
judicial discipline matters, etc.) are assigned to our Court.
Education & Experience: Associate's degree in business or related
discipline; and 2 years
of related work experience (e.g. comprehensive customer service or case administration in a law or
judicial corporate environment); or an equivalent combination
of education and work experience.
Regarding the 30 - day suspension, the Supreme Court
of Mississippi stated «
judicial review
of disciplinary proceedings
of a voluntary association should be limited to determining only whether the member
disciplined received procedural due process as required by the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution, and whether the association has conducted its inquiry in accordance with its own rules
of procedure.»
His role there is both legislative and
judicial, with responsibility for adopting changes to Civil Service Law as well as adjudicating employee appeals
of wrongful
discipline.