[Robert Howarth, professor of ecology and environmental biology at Cornell University] is basing his conclusion on a preliminary analysis that includes not only the amount of carbon dioxide that comes out of a tailpipe when you burn diesel and natural gas, but also the impact
of natural gas leaks.
For the new study, Brandt and his colleagues analyzed approximately 15,000 measurements from 18 prior studies
of natural gas leaks from across the U.S. using a statistical technique called extreme value theory, which is useful for analyzing infrequent but highly consequential events.
Learn about the climate risks
of natural gas leaks from drilling sites, processing plants, storage facilities, and pipelines.
Two prominent analysts of human - driven global warming have offered fresh criticisms of the way Anthony Ingraffea, a Cornell University engineering professor, has been portraying the contribution
of natural gas leaks to climate change.
(In a related development, Lawrence Cathles, an earth and atmospheric sciences professor at Cornell University, sent me a fresh rebuttal to the Op - Ed article on the contribution
of natural gas leaks to global warming by his colleague, Anthony Ingraffea (earlier critiques are here).
For the new study, Brandt and his colleagues analyzed approximately 15,000 measurements from 18 prior studies
of natural gas leaks from across the U.S. using a statistical technique called extreme value theory, which is useful for analyzing infrequent but highly consequential events.
In both of those cities our team has mapped thousands
of natural gas leaks block by block.
Residents barely had time to recognize the smell
of a natural gas leak and to run with their loved ones.
Not exact matches
New
natural gas pipelines do not face the same kind
of opposition as oil pipelines because the product is a
gas and, in case
of a
leak, it escapes into the atmosphere rather than fouling waterways and soil.
Estimates vary widely on just how much methane is
leaked from the vast network
of oil and
gas wells, pipelines and processing plants, but the problem has cast doubt on how much better
natural gas is than coal for the environment.
They should instead re-examine their practices that might have led to traces
of, for example, diesel turning up in the Wyoming groundwater and come up with standards that would make
leaks along the well bore impossible before less appropriate and more costly rules are thrust upon them at a time when
natural gas prices are hitting 10 - year lows.
Capable
of powering 15,000 homes, the system was conceived as part
of a backup against projected energy shortages following a huge methane
leak at a
natural gas facility near Los Angeles.
Proponents argue it would boost New York's
natural gas supply to help keep energy costs down while creating jobs and generating tax revenue, while opponents, who rallied this month ahead
of the decision, say it would increase fossil - fuel use, harm sensitive ecosystems and put the state at inordinate risk
of dangerous methane
leaks.
While official results
of the investigation have not yet been released, preliminary tests conducted by the National Transportation Safety Board have indicated that the blast was caused by a
natural gas leak from a 127 - year - old pipe.
Additional evidence for this idea
of super-emitters has been reported in other studies, said Steven Hamburg, chief scientist at the group Environmental Defense Fund, which is spearheading a set
of studies on
leaks from the
natural gas supply chain.
The researchers took direct emissions measurements
of 230 randomly selected, representative
leaks from underground pipelines as well as at 229 metering and regulating stations where
natural gas is measured and regulated from higher pressure pipelines to lower pressure distribution pipelines.
Methane, the main component
of natural gas, is released from
leaking pipelines, coal mines, oil wells, cattle, rice paddies and landfills.
The research team also located 75
natural sources
of sulfur dioxide — non-erupting volcanoes slowly
leaking the toxic
gas throughout the year.
A «fat tail»
of a few leaky wells This is often referred to as the «fat tail» or «super-emitter» problem, that just a small subset
of wells or pieces
of equipment is responsible for the majority
of the
leaks from the
natural gas system (ClimateWire, Feb. 14).
She'd already had the local board
of health to her home to test her tap water and check for
natural gas leaks.
A new study provides one
of the first quantitative estimates
of the methane
leak rate from the blowout
of a
natural gas well in California in 2015, suggesting that emissions from this event temporarily doubled those from all other sources in the entire Los Angeles Basin, including landfills, dairies, and other
leaks.
Their report emphasizes the utility
of rapid - response airborne chemical sampling in providing
leak rate data, and it reveals how single vulnerabilities in the
natural gas infrastructure can impact local and federal climate policies.
New research to re-examine distribution system
leak rates has been funded by the Environmental Defense Fund as part
of a larger project to quantify lost methane from the
natural gas system.
In the January issue
of Environmental Science & Technology the researchers described their efforts mapping nearly 5,900
natural gas leaks of varying severity across 1,500 road miles
of Washington, D.C. To learn more about the state
of the
gas pipelines running through several major U.S. cities — in particular those serving New York City — Scientific American interviewed Robert Jackson, professor
of environmental sciences at Stanford and Duke universities and the study's lead author.
If that number is significant, it could negate the climate benefit
of natural gas — measured against coal — unless the
leaks are plugged.
Leaks and explosions involving
natural gas transmission and distribution pipelines in the U.S. cause an average
of 17 fatalities, 68 injuries and $ 133 million in property damage annually, according to a study released earlier this year.
However, the colorless, odorless
gas can be difficult to track and derives from a wide range
of sources, from decomposing biological material to
leaks in
natural gas pipelines.
Environmental controls designed to prevent
leaks of methane from newly drilled
natural gas wells are effective, a study has found — but emissions from existing wells in production are much higher than previously believed.
Significant
leaks of heat - trapping methane from
natural gas production sites would erase any climate advantage the fuel offers.
Conflicting numbers The study was funded by a partnership
of nine
natural gas producers and the Environmental Defense Fund, a non-profit environmental group based in Washington DC, as part
of a broad effort to trace methane
leaks all the way from the wellhead to the user.
About a third
of the factors used to estimate pipeline
leaks and other
natural gas emissions in the most recent inventory, for 2015, are based on a 1996 study by the EPA and an industry group then known as the Gas Research Institu
gas emissions in the most recent inventory, for 2015, are based on a 1996 study by the EPA and an industry group then known as the
Gas Research Institu
Gas Research Institute.
Mapping methane plumes on the streets
of Boston and San Francisco paints a picture
of «clean» streets with few
natural gas leaks, and more common «dirty» streets where methane concentrations can be more than 15 times global background levels.
U.S. EPA has begun the process
of requiring
natural gas companies to use «green completions,» a set
of technologies and methods that allow for an efficient and
leak - free transfer
of natural gas from extraction wells to transport pipelines to the refineries or processors.
The trick to lowering
natural gas's global warming quotient is to tighten up
leaks in upstream operations, from extraction to use, say the authors
of a World Resources Institute report released today.
Though focused on end uses
of natural gas, the paper also shows how results are affected by highly uncertain
leak rates from
natural gas production and delivery.
Natural gas plants that
leak a substantial amount
of methane during their supply process can produce more warming than comparable coal plants.
After testing a sample
of abandoned oil and
natural gas wells in northwestern Pennsylvania, the researchers found that many
of the old wells
leaked substantial quantities
of methane.
It is the main component
of natural gas, but by 2014 there were mounting suspicions that a lot
of it was
leaking or being vented into the air over the production fields, rather than being shipped off to market.
«Low - cost imaging system detects
natural gas leaks in real time: Infrared device enables reliable monitoring under a range
of environmental conditions.»
EDF has been active in trying to quantify the amount
of methane
leaking from
natural gas operations.
It was evidence that the Bakken was
leaking raw
natural gas, including huge amounts
of methane, which is 86 times more potent as a global warmer than carbon dioxide during the first nine years
of its life.
As
natural gas booms nationwide, the amount
of methane
leaking from the
natural gas system — from wellhead to homes — has become a hot - button issue.
That means the U.S. is likely
leaking 2.25 percent, not 1.5 percent,
of all the
natural gas used, according to the new study, which helps explain why concentrations measured in the atmosphere keep rising above expected rates.
And there are other challenges associated with fracking for
natural gas besides climate change, from what to do with the wastewater produced to drinking water contamination and even improperly drilled wells that
leak or explode and get out
of control (a blowout).
The key to sustainable use
of natural gas is identifying and halting «super emitters» — valves or hatches that are stuck open, corroded holes in pipes or other major
leaks — according to this study.
Just as oil and
natural gas fields have been found to be emitting more methane than official government estimates suggest, a new study shows that more methane than previously thought may be
leaking from the other end
of that system — cities, where people actually use
natural gas for heating and cooking.
«We're finding that when it comes to
natural gas leaks, a 50/5 rule applies: That is, the largest 5 percent
of leaks are typically responsible for more than 50 percent
of the total volume
of leakage,» said study co-author Adam Brandt, an assistant professor
of energy resources engineering at Stanford's School
of Earth, Energy & Environmental Sciences.
Advocates for cuts also see a chance to curb
leaks of methane from
natural gas production and distribution pipelines.
These kinds
of leaks from production and transportation
of natural gas resources have been well documented.
Impetus to address methane
leaks directly should come from an ongoing study involving the
gas industry and the Environmental Defense Fund, which aims to put hard numbers on the amount
of methane lost across the
natural gas supply chain.