These analyses examine how the sizes of the overall effects reported above vary based on the density
of nearby charter schools, the quality of the charter school (based on test - score performance and charter operator), and a range of student characteristics.
Our analysis of competitive effects therefore investigates whether the effect of charter schools on traditional public schools varies with the number
of nearby charter schools as well as with the distance to the nearest charter.
The influence
of a nearby charter school on traditional public schools in the area depends, in part, on the credibility of students» threats to switch to the charter.
Not exact matches
In Hempstead, while most
of the students at The Academy
Charter School are from the local district, the school draws from nearby systems as
School are from the local district, the
school draws from nearby systems as
school draws from
nearby systems as well.
Before the
charter opened, all Moraine students were bused to
schools in the
nearby suburbs
of Kettering and West Carrollton.
Those
schools include public
charter schools, magnet
schools, and other types
of options both within districts and in
nearby districts.
Not far from the heart
of Houston, unlikely alliance between a
school district and
nearby charter schools is bringing the best
of both worlds to area students.
He says, «The superintendents were far more defensive about and married to the status quo than anybody else we were dealing with...» Just as it would be an inherent conflict to put McDonald's in charge
of determining whether or not others should be allowed to open a new restaurant
nearby, Engler reasoned that
charter school authorizers should be outside the control
of the traditional K — 12 system.
«There are very few good options in
school nutrition, and most
schools serve their kids lousy food that is unappealing,» says Bob Nardo, managing director of operations for KIPP TEAM Charter Schools in Newark, N.J. «This is a problem everywhere, but particularly in low - income areas that are considered food deserts, where you can't get adequate, nutritious food
schools serve their kids lousy food that is unappealing,» says Bob Nardo, managing director
of operations for KIPP TEAM
Charter Schools in Newark, N.J. «This is a problem everywhere, but particularly in low - income areas that are considered food deserts, where you can't get adequate, nutritious food
Schools in Newark, N.J. «This is a problem everywhere, but particularly in low - income areas that are considered food deserts, where you can't get adequate, nutritious food
nearby.
In the Spring 2018 issue cover story, we present evidence on the spillover effects
of charter schools on
nearby district -
school students.
Instead
of asking whether all students in
charter schools are more likely to attend segregated
schools than are all students in traditional public
schools, we should be comparing the racial composition
of charter schools to that
of nearby traditional public
schools.
One possible alternative explanation for the improvements observed in traditional public
schools when a
charter school opened
nearby is the migration
of lower - performing students from the traditional public
school to the
charter school.
As a result, more - affluent parents in the transitioning neighborhoods — squeezed out
of schools west
of the park and unable to afford private
schools — are taking a shot at either the elementary
school down the street or a diverse
charter school nearby.
Sarah Cordes
of Temple University shows that elementary
schools in New York City see a notable uptick in student achievement, attendance, and grade completion when a
charter school opens
nearby — and that these gains are largest when the
schools are «co-located» in the same facility.
Adequate, fair funding: University
of Arkansas analysts report that the typical
charter gets 28 percent less funding per pupil than
nearby district
schools, in large part because few
charters share in the locally generated portion
of K — 12 funding.
The AFT claims that
charter schools are more racially homogeneous than district
schools, citing research that makes much
of very small differences (normally less than 10 percent) between
charter and
nearby district
school student bodies.
The results add one more data point to the diverse assortment
of studies about
charter performance: an example
of the
charter sector outperforming, on the whole,
nearby traditional
schools.
Critics at the
nearby Roaring Fork
School District, who had long opposed the charter school's existence, had complained publicly that Ross Montessori didn't serve its share of Latino stu
School District, who had long opposed the
charter school's existence, had complained publicly that Ross Montessori didn't serve its share of Latino stu
school's existence, had complained publicly that Ross Montessori didn't serve its share
of Latino students.
Working with staff at the Don Edwards San Francisco Bay National Wildlife Refuge, fifth graders from the East Palo Alto
Charter School track predators
of the clapper rail, an endangered bird, in a
nearby salt marsh.
WNYC public radio recently conducted a comprehensive analysis
of student attrition at New York City
charter schools and found that attrition rates are generally lower at
charters than at
nearby district
schools.
According to a 2015 study
of charters in urban regions across the country, conducted by the Center for Research on Education Outcomes at Stanford University, African - American students at
charters out - performed comparable students at
nearby public
schools in math by roughly a half years» worth
of learning.
Some proponents have predicted that the presence
of charter schools would have a positive effect on
nearby traditional public
schools by exerting positive competitive pressure; some opponents have worried that
charter schools would harm students in
nearby traditional public
schools by draining resources.
Second, the absence
of effects on achievement in
nearby traditional public
schools suggests that the loss
of students to
charter schools is not having negative achievement effects on traditional public
schools, but it also suggests that
charter schools may not produce the hoped - for positive competitive effects in traditional public
schools.
The researchers examined student achievement in traditional public
schools that had
charter schools nearby, and they found that the presence
of the
charter schools did not appear to help or harm student achievement in the traditional public
schools.
Even when
charter schools use simple applications, the fact that parents must submit them months before the start
of school means that «these students are in some ways more advantaged, come from more motivated families» than kids in
nearby district
schools, education analyst Michael Petrilli said.
The opening
of a
charter school leads to small reductions in enrollment at
nearby district
schools, but does not change the percentage
of students from underrepresented minority groups, special education students, or LEP students.
Although there is no significant difference on any
of the individual indicators, the sum
of responses indicates that teachers» overall perceptions at a district
school improve after a
charter school opens
nearby.
I compare the outcomes
of students at district
schools after a
charter school opens
nearby to the outcomes
of students in the same
schools before a
charter opened.
To shed light on the question
of spillover effects, I use data from New York City to estimate the effects
of charter schools on students in two types
of nearby district
schools: those in the same neighborhood, and those that are co-located (in the same building).
Together, this indicates that the positive spillovers
of charter schools on
nearby students at district
schools did not come at the detriment
of students across the city.
Limiting comparisons to students who attended the same district
schools accounts for all features
of schools that do not change over time, such as their spatial attributes (that is, whether
nearby buildings are suitable for housing a
charter school).
A 2014 study found the typical
charter getting just 72 percent
of what's spent in
nearby district
schools.
When funding follows students, the impact
of competition is greater in areas where
school - age population growth is slow or declining, as any loss
of students to
charter schools or
nearby districts is immediately seen on the bottom line.
I also find that
charter school entry has only a small impact on the probability
of students exiting
nearby district
schools.
The problem, she said in a separate analysis, is that Ms. Raymond compared the achievement
of individual
charter students with that
of groups
of students from
nearby public
schools, without making the statistical adjustments necessary to account for the natural downward biases that result from that sort
of calculation.
[vii] With the
charter school having opened nearby instead of taking over the school, the McKinley Elementary School parent trigger appears to have f
school having opened
nearby instead
of taking over the
school, the McKinley Elementary School parent trigger appears to have f
school, the McKinley Elementary
School parent trigger appears to have f
School parent trigger appears to have failed.
Student performance in
charter schools was significantly lower than regular
nearby schools in just five states with about 30 percent
of national
charter enrollment, mostly minority children from poor families.
About a third
of the eligible students in the district's boundaries attend the
charter; the others are at neighboring districts or other
nearby charter schools.
As evidence mounts that most
charters are outperforming
nearby regular public
schools, the governor and state Legislature need to step up their support
of charters.
Besides giving new authority to the chancellor, the mayor is also proposing to allow some
charter schools — those located in «high need» areas
of the city — to become neighborhood
schools, which students living
nearby would have a right to attend.
Students at the majority
of the
charter schools that could be turned down Tuesday by LA Unified's
school board are performing academically above their peers in
nearby schools.
Just 53 parents at Desert Trails, a
school of about 600 kids, made the final call to turn the building — and the public funds to run it — over to a nonprofit group that runs a
charter school in a
nearby town.
Using an individual panel data set to control for student fixed effects, we estimate the impact
of charter schools on students in
charter schools and in
nearby traditional public
schools.
Disclosure
of school operations, especially as relates to finances, should be mandatory for
charters, they say, because the failure
of such an institution impacts
nearby school districts and the students who are displaced when a
charter must close down.
The Spending Blind report also underscored the CREDO findings: The education offered at three fourths
of the
charters was worse than that provided at
nearby district
schools.
This contract fails to resolve many serious issues that were identified in the review
of the proposal for this
charter school, including inadequate staffing and student services, a budget shortfall, and no way to ensure enrollment reflects the demographics
of nearby neighborhoods or the district.
(Warhaftig has released his own data analysis
of high
schools, which includes magnets,
charters, and traditional
schools both in LA Unified and in other
nearby school districts.)
For example, in 2011, AFT engaged the NAACP, now on the union's payroll, to file a lawsuit to keep some children in Harlem in their failing traditional public
schools, instead
of allowing them to attend
nearby superior (non-unionized)
charter schools.
Most are outperforming
nearby district
schools, but the majority
of the denials stem from
charters» rejection
of specific language required by the district in their petitions.
Among those who enrolled in the spring — some just weeks before the
school year ended — were a 17 - year - old from Guatemala returning to classes for the first time since he was in sixth grade, a ninth - grader who left a
nearby charter school after she was caught with marijuana, and an 18 - year - old who dropped out
of Southeast Washington's Ballou High earlier in the year after moving into a group foster home in Northwest Washington.