It was this latter date when the CET instrumental records began, and we can usefully bookend this era with two pieces
of observational climate information.
There are also a substantial number
of observational climate sensitivity estimates below 1 C, e.g. Lindzen & Choi (2009) at 0.5 C..
There are also a substantial number
of observational climate sensitivity estimates below 1 C. e.g. Lindzen & Choi (2009) at 0.5 C. See my comment on apparent bimodal distribution of climate sensitivity estimates.
Not exact matches
Using the Great Barrier Reef as their study case, they estimated the evolution
of the region over the last 14,000 years and showed that (1) high sediment loads from catchments erosion prevented coral growth during the early phase
of sea level rise and favoured deep offshore sediment deposition; (2) how the fine balance between
climate, sea level, and margin physiography enabled coral reefs to thrive under limited shelf sedimentation rates at 6,000 years before present; and, (3) how over the last 3,000 years, the decrease
of accommodation space led to the lateral extension
of coral reefs consistent with available
observational data.
«Much
of our historical data about species» population - level responses to
climate change comes from
observational studies, which can suggest but not confirm causation,» said Anne Marie Panetta, lead author
of the study and a post-doctoral researcher in CU Boulder's Department
of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology (EBIO).
Observed
Climate Changes The many new or improved
observational data sets that became available in time for the 2007 IPCC report allowed a more comprehensive assessment
of changes than was possible in earlier reports.
We've narrowed the uncertainty in surface warming projections by generating thousands
of climate simulations that each closely match
observational records for nine key
climate metrics, including warming and ocean heat content.»
Co-author
of the study Professor Ian Hall, from the School
of Earth and Ocean Sciences, said: «Our results highlight the challenge
of basing our understanding
of the
climate system on generally short
observational records.
Co-author Nerilie Abram, from the Australian National University, said: «In order to better understand
climate change in Antarctica, we need continued
climate measurements in the Antarctic and Southern Ocean, and extension
of these short
observational records with past
climate reconstructions and
climate modelling.»
The project, called Estimating the Circulation and
Climate of the Ocean (ECCO), uses
observational data — including ocean surface topography, surface wind stress, temperature, salinity profiles and velocity data — collected between June 2005 and December 2007.
Leal said the revised conceptual framework, along with a greater emphasis on collecting
observational data in the field, will both help to better predict and mitigate the effects
of climate change on these vulnerable animals.
Climate modeling and
observational data suggest the world is already on track to reach dangerous levels
of warming by the end
of the century, according to the two papers.
To find out, atmospheric experts at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory compared six reanalyses products against
observational data from the U.S. Department
of Energy's Atmospheric Radiation Measurement (ARM)
Climate Research Facility in Oklahoma.
Introducing NEON: The National Ecological Observatory Network was created to understand and forecast the impacts
of climate change, land use change, and invasive species on continental - scale ecology by providing an
observational infrastructure to support research, education, and environmental management in these areas.
Methods: Researchers Drs. Samson M. Hagos and L. Ruby Leung, atmospheric scientists at PNNL, surveyed tropical divergence in three global
climate models, three global reanalyses (models corrected with
observational data), and four sets
of field campaign soundings.
Their goal was to improve
climate modeling
of the MJO and authenticate results using
observational data.
A decade
of observational data was collected at the ARM
Climate Research Facility Southern Great Plains site in Oklahoma.
Results
of both regional
climate model simulations and
observational analyses suggest that much
of the observed rainfall increase — as well as the decrease in temperature and increase in humidity — is attributable to agricultural intensification in the central United States, with natural variability and GHG emissions playing secondary roles.
To meet this societal need, the world
climate research community is challenged by underlying science questions and the quality and coverage
of the
observational data that are used to monitor and understand extremes.
As part
of the World Weather Attribution (WWA) team CPDN scientists have looked at
observational data and model simulations, including weather@home to identify whether and to what extend human - induced
climate change influenced the likelihood and magnitude
of this extreme event.
Here we briefly summarize more generally some
of the pitfalls and issues involved in developing
observational constraints on
climate feedbacks.
«He's got this combination
of excellent
observational skills from taking photographs (and) understanding
of the day - to - day severe weather... but also the understanding
of the larger - scale
climate variations,» says David Karoly, his academic advisor at Melbourne.
The ongoing heat wave dominating a large swath
of Europe is being exacerbated by
climate change, according to a new analysis by a team
of international scientists using both
observational data and
climate models.
The IPCC AR4 (9.6:
Observational Constraints on
Climate Sensitivity) lists 13 studies (Table 9.3) that constrain climate sensitivity using various types of data, including two using LG
Climate Sensitivity) lists 13 studies (Table 9.3) that constrain
climate sensitivity using various types of data, including two using LG
climate sensitivity using various types
of data, including two using LGM data.
However, satellite observations are notably cooler in the lower troposphere than predicted by
climate models, and the research team in their paper acknowledge this, remarking: «One area
of concern is that on average... simulations underestimate the observed lower stratospheric cooling and overestimate tropospheric warming... These differences must be due to some combination
of errors in model forcings, model response errors, residual
observational inhomogeneities, and an unusual manifestation
of natural internal variability in the observations.»
The ARM Aerosol Measurement Science Group (AMSG) coordinates ARM
Climate Research Facility observations of aerosols and atmospheric trace gases with user needs to ensure advanced, well - characterized observational measurements and data products — at the spatial and temporal scales necessary — for improving climate science and model for
Climate Research Facility observations
of aerosols and atmospheric trace gases with user needs to ensure advanced, well - characterized
observational measurements and data products — at the spatial and temporal scales necessary — for improving
climate science and model for
climate science and model forecasts.
Our evaluation
of a fossil fuel emissions limit is not based on
climate models but rather on
observational evidence
of global
climate change as a function
of global temperature and on the fact that
climate stabilization requires long - term planetary energy balance.
The visualization covers the period June 2005 to December 2007 and is based on a synthesis
of a numerical model with
observational data, created by a NASA project called Estimating the Circulation and
Climate of the Ocean, or ECCO for short.
Schools can assess school
climate in a variety
of ways — for example, using focus groups;
observational methods; interviews; town hall discussions; study circles; participatory action research; and student, staff, and family surveys.
As part
of the study, independent («blind») observers assessed the quality
of classroom
climate in all third grade classrooms in the 18 schools using a research - based
observational instrument called the Classroom Assessment Scoring System (CLASS).
We also now have persuasive
observational evidence
of dramatic changes already taking place in the
climate system, changes that are not in any sense small.
We have neither long enough nor good enough
observational data to have a perfect knowledge
of the extremes
of heat waves given a steady
climate, and so no claim along these lines can ever be for 100 % causation, but the change is large enough to be classically «highly significant».
Observational and model studies
of temperature change,
climate feedbacks and changes in the Earth's energy budget together provide confidence in the magnitude
of global warming in response to past and future forcing.
This is similar to how the denier claims
of no global warming, or
of no anthropogenic influence upon warming, or
of low
climate sensitivity, depend on all
observational data being wrong in the same direction.
The reception to my comments was especially cold... not one supporter, though a couple
of scientists did say I had a «lot
of guts» to stand up and say what I said before 140 L.A.s. I was (and still am) calling for the AR5 to be a more open scientific assessment in which those
of us who are well - credentialed and have evidence for low
climate sensitivity (
observational and theoretical) be given room to explain this.
Thanks Gavin, I get the point (in your response to my comment # 14) that your intention here is to discuss changes in the ocean / atmosphere system that could cause a cooling
of European
climate, and that both
observational and model evidence point to a weakening
of THC as the most likely candidate.
The lessons learned from studying this problem can and should be applied towards the improvement
of existing
climate monitoring systems, so that future model evaluation studies are less sensitive to
observational ambiguity.»
Mike's work, like that
of previous award winners, is diverse, and includes pioneering and highly cited work in time series analysis (an elegant use
of Thomson's multitaper spectral analysis approach to detect spatiotemporal oscillations in the
climate record and methods for smoothing temporal data), decadal climate variability (the term «Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation» or «AMO» was coined by Mike in an interview with Science's Richard Kerr about a paper he had published with Tom Delworth of GFDL showing evidence in both climate model simulations and observational data for a 50 - 70 year oscillation in the climate system; significantly Mike also published work with Kerry Emanuel in 2006 showing that the AMO concept has been overstated as regards its role in 20th century tropical Atlantic SST changes, a finding recently reaffirmed by a study published in Nature), in showing how changes in radiative forcing from volcanoes can affect ENSO, in examining the role of solar variations in explaining the pattern of the Medieval Climate Anomaly and Little Ice Age, the relationship between the climate changes of past centuries and phenomena such as Atlantic tropical cyclones and global sea level, and even a bit of work in atmospheric chemistry (an analysis of beryllium - 7 measure
climate record and methods for smoothing temporal data), decadal
climate variability (the term «Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation» or «AMO» was coined by Mike in an interview with Science's Richard Kerr about a paper he had published with Tom Delworth of GFDL showing evidence in both climate model simulations and observational data for a 50 - 70 year oscillation in the climate system; significantly Mike also published work with Kerry Emanuel in 2006 showing that the AMO concept has been overstated as regards its role in 20th century tropical Atlantic SST changes, a finding recently reaffirmed by a study published in Nature), in showing how changes in radiative forcing from volcanoes can affect ENSO, in examining the role of solar variations in explaining the pattern of the Medieval Climate Anomaly and Little Ice Age, the relationship between the climate changes of past centuries and phenomena such as Atlantic tropical cyclones and global sea level, and even a bit of work in atmospheric chemistry (an analysis of beryllium - 7 measure
climate variability (the term «Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation» or «AMO» was coined by Mike in an interview with Science's Richard Kerr about a paper he had published with Tom Delworth
of GFDL showing evidence in both
climate model simulations and observational data for a 50 - 70 year oscillation in the climate system; significantly Mike also published work with Kerry Emanuel in 2006 showing that the AMO concept has been overstated as regards its role in 20th century tropical Atlantic SST changes, a finding recently reaffirmed by a study published in Nature), in showing how changes in radiative forcing from volcanoes can affect ENSO, in examining the role of solar variations in explaining the pattern of the Medieval Climate Anomaly and Little Ice Age, the relationship between the climate changes of past centuries and phenomena such as Atlantic tropical cyclones and global sea level, and even a bit of work in atmospheric chemistry (an analysis of beryllium - 7 measure
climate model simulations and
observational data for a 50 - 70 year oscillation in the
climate system; significantly Mike also published work with Kerry Emanuel in 2006 showing that the AMO concept has been overstated as regards its role in 20th century tropical Atlantic SST changes, a finding recently reaffirmed by a study published in Nature), in showing how changes in radiative forcing from volcanoes can affect ENSO, in examining the role of solar variations in explaining the pattern of the Medieval Climate Anomaly and Little Ice Age, the relationship between the climate changes of past centuries and phenomena such as Atlantic tropical cyclones and global sea level, and even a bit of work in atmospheric chemistry (an analysis of beryllium - 7 measure
climate system; significantly Mike also published work with Kerry Emanuel in 2006 showing that the AMO concept has been overstated as regards its role in 20th century tropical Atlantic SST changes, a finding recently reaffirmed by a study published in Nature), in showing how changes in radiative forcing from volcanoes can affect ENSO, in examining the role
of solar variations in explaining the pattern
of the Medieval
Climate Anomaly and Little Ice Age, the relationship between the climate changes of past centuries and phenomena such as Atlantic tropical cyclones and global sea level, and even a bit of work in atmospheric chemistry (an analysis of beryllium - 7 measure
Climate Anomaly and Little Ice Age, the relationship between the
climate changes of past centuries and phenomena such as Atlantic tropical cyclones and global sea level, and even a bit of work in atmospheric chemistry (an analysis of beryllium - 7 measure
climate changes
of past centuries and phenomena such as Atlantic tropical cyclones and global sea level, and even a bit
of work in atmospheric chemistry (an analysis
of beryllium - 7 measurements).
I have been looking at the histogram
of the models spread compared to
observational means at the bottom
of the
Climate Model Projections Compared to Observations page as the definitive way to look at the question
of how the models are performing.
As our
observational capacity improves, we should expect to have fewer and fewer instances
of unexplainable
climate changes.
Unavoidably, some
of these losses have been key scientific positions, including in
climate and weather prediction, but also in our
observational and computational facilities.
There are limited
observational data to start with, insufficient testing
of climate model simulations
of extremes, and (so far) limited assessment
of model projections.
Here we analyze a series
of climate model experiments along with
observational data to show that the recent warming trend in Atlantic sea surface temperature and the corresponding trans - basin displacements
of the main atmospheric pressure centers were key drivers
of the observed Walker circulation intensification, eastern Pacific cooling, North American rainfall trends and western Pacific sea - level rise.
Part
of the story here is that it is this very sort
of very careful work done by John Kennedy and Phil Jones and other colleagues working on these datasets that has allowed us to start challenging the models and our understanding in such a detailed way — in some ways it is quite remarkable that the
observational data is now good enough to identify this level
of detail in how the
climate varies and changes.
A series
of sensitivity tests show that our detection results are robust to
observational data coverage change, interpolation methods, influence
of natural
climate variability on observations, and different model sampling (see Supplementary Information).
The disagreement arises from different assessments
of the value and importance
of particular classes
of evidence as well as disagreement about the appropriate logical framework for linking and assessing the evidence — my reasoning is weighted heavily in favor
of observational evidence and understanding
of natural internal variability
of the
climate system, whereas the IPCC's reasoning is weighted heavily in favor
of climate model simulations and external forcing
of climate change.
From its home within DOE's Office
of Biological and Environmental Research, ARM organized around a task that was both big and new: To establish, over time, a series
of instrumented platforms that would provide an
observational basis for studying the Earth's
climate.
Indirect Solar Forcing
of Climate by Galactic Cosmic Rays: An
Observational Estimate
As noted in that post, RealClimate defines the Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation («AMO») as, «A multidecadal (50 - 80 year timescale) pattern
of North Atlantic ocean - atmosphere variability whose existence has been argued for based on statistical analyses
of observational and proxy
climate data, and coupled Atmosphere - Ocean General Circulation Model («AOGCM») simulations.
My goal is to find some interesting
observational tests suggesting constrains
of climate sensitivity or cloud feedback.