No wonder the thought
of prisoner voting makes David Cameron physically ill.
Even with the radioactive issue
of prisoner votes excised from the draft, pending a Government appeal, Mr Clarke is expecting trouble.
The issue
of prisoner votes returned to the courtroom this week, with an unsurprising judgment on many fronts.
Not exact matches
By the time W finished his second term, I had graduated from college, come to terms with the fact that the criminalization
of abortion is highly unlikely no matter the party in power, expanded my definition
of «pro-life» to include Iraqi children and
prisoners of war, and experienced first - hand some
of the major problems with America's healthcare system, which along with poverty and education issues, contributes to the troubling abortion rate in the U.S. I remained pro-life idealistically, but for the first time,
voted for a pro-choice president, hoping that the reforms I wanted to see in the healthcare, the economy, immigration, education, and for the socioeconomically disadvantaged would function pragmatically to reduce abortions.
Shrouded in fears
of violence, the
vote pitted President Uhuru Kenyatta, a wealthy 55 - year - old businessman and the son
of Kenya's founding president, against Raila Odinga, 72, a former political
prisoner and son
of Kenya's first vice-president.
My own opininon regarding allowing
prisoners with sentences
of less than four years the right to
vote is that it is actually a fudge.
Britain will have to continue its fight with the European court
of human rights for a decade if it is to protect the ban on
prisoner voting, David Davis has warned parliament.
It has ruled that denying
prisoners their right to
vote is an infringement
of their human rights.
However, besides addressing some
of the recent controversies in the UK human rights landscape such as deporting suspected terrorists and
prisoner voting, the Conservative Manifesto does not provide much detail on what specifically a British Bill
of Rights will contain and how it will differ from the HRA.
The idea
of murderers and rapists being able to
vote uses extreme examples to make the point, no mention
of the
prisoner who didn't pay their TV license.
How will they ensure that
prisoners who are guilty
of serious offences but serving short sentences are not given the
vote?
In Westminster Hall yesterday, ahead
of the binding Commons
vote, Philip Hollobone instigated a debate on
voting rights for
prisoners.
Mark Harper admits «exasperation» over
prisoner voting rights as he faces the wrath
of angry Tory MPs
Ministers had thought a ruling by the European Court
of Human Rights would force them to give
prisoners the
vote only in Westminster or European parliamentary elections.
Will the Minister provide details
of the precise mechanics that
prisoner voting will entail?
«When the previous Government consulted on this matter, the right hon. and learned Member for Beaconsfield (Mr Grieve), who was then the shadow Secretary
of State for Justice and is now the Attorney - General, described the prospect
of giving
prisoners the
vote as «ludicrous».
The most famous debates
of this kind were on
prisoner voting and,
of course, the EU referendum motion (in which 81 Tory MPs rebelled).
Tory MPs Brian Binley and Claire Perry sound off at the Council
of Europe about
votes for
prisoners
«Mark Harper admits «exasperation» over
prisoner voting rights as he faces the wrath
of angry Tory MPs Main Health Minister makes reducing abortion rate «an absolute priority» as Nadine Dorries raises concerns over lack
of pre-abortion counselling»
Last week, MPs
voted on a motion put forward by David Davis and Jack Straw, opposing the right
of prisoners to take part in elections.
I wonder why our politicians think that a
prisoner is capable
of holding elected office but not
voting for one.
The government should rather look to our European neighbours, all
of whom permit the majority
of prisoners to
vote.
However, I am a pragmatic politician and, as such, have some sympathy for the view that allowing
prisoners to
vote would help rehabilitate at least some
of them.
It had frustrated eurosceptics over issues like
prisoner voting and the deportation
of Abu Qatada, and is now insisting no - one in jail should face the prospect
of not being let out
of prison before they die.
For instance, we could allow
voting rights for
prisoners in open prisons, namely those convicted
of relatively minor crimes, and offenders who are transferred from a secure environment.
«Ex-Labour MP Jim Devine convicted
of fiddling his expenses Main A full breakdown
of how all MPs
voted on
votes for
prisoners»
The House
of Commons has spent all afternoon debating the issue
of whether
prisoners should have the right to
vote, as has been instructed by the European Court
of Human Rights.
«That this House notes the ruling
of the European Court
of Human Rights in Hirst v the United Kingdom in which it held that there had been no substantive debate by members
of the legislature on the continued justification for maintaining a general restriction on the right
of prisoners to
vote; acknowledges the treaty obligations
of the UK; is
of the opinion that legislative decisions
of this nature should be a matter for democratically - elected lawmakers; and supports the current situation in which no
prisoner is able to
vote except those imprisoned for contempt, default or on remand.»
With Parliament asserting itself on
votes for
prisoners, there must now either be reform
of the European Convention on Human Rights, the European Court's interpretation thereof, or
of Britain's relationship to the Convention.
Of the MPs who backed
votes for
prisoners, there was only one Conservative - Sir Peter Bottomley, MP for Worthing West.
The BBBC - which allows backbenchers proper time to debate issues that matter to them (and the public) like Europe, petrol prices, or
prisoners»
votes - has been one
of the best things the Coalition has done to make Parliament look like the honourable and relevant institution it should be.
«The Hirst judgment says that article 3
of protocol 1
of the European convention on human rights obliges this House to give some
prisoners the
vote; as we have heard, it also gives rise to financial compensation to some
prisoners who have been denied that right.
«In considering the Government's policy on this thorny issue, will the Secretary
of State, if he has to abide by the ruling
of the European Court
of Human Rights, restrict the right to
vote to those
prisoners at the lowest level
of seriousness — for example, those dealt with by the magistrates courts for summary offences only?»
If Murdo Fraser's new party had been formed at dvolution to appeal to the Christian Democrat voters who used to form a Conservative majority
of the popular
vote, or if Tommy Sheridan hadn't given up politics to spend more time with
prisoners then the SNP wouldn't have had such a pushover.
During Justice Questions yesterday, the issue
of votes for
prisoners was raised on the back
of the recent judgment from the European Court
of Human Rights.
David Cameron should heed their advice and that
of his own minister and allow sentenced
prisoners to
vote.
Following the ruling by the apex court, then President John E. A. Mills announced during the inauguration
of the Ankaful Maximum Security Prison in the Central Region on November 8, 2011, that the EC will be well - resourced to register
prisoners for them to
vote in the 2012 elections.
Through its own audit procedures, the Ministry
of Justice has been systematically seeking
prisoners» level
of interest in
voting and is known to have received positive responses.
Practically, there would be few difficulties in expanding the arrangements already in place enabling remand
prisoners to
vote to the rest
of the sentenced prison population.
This has resulted in tens
of thousands
of sentenced
prisoners being unlawful denied their right to
vote in local, national and European elections.
The Electoral Commission has set out a mechanism by which
prisoners could be enfranchised though a system
of postal or proxy
voting.
The government has today published proposals that could see certain categories
of prisoners allowed to
vote while in jail.
The past president
of the Prison Governors» Association said: «The blanket ban on sentenced
prisoners»
voting is out
of step in a modern prison service and runs counter to resettlement work which aims to ensure that
prisoners lead a responsible, law - abiding life on release.»
Earlier this week Frances Crook
of the Howard League for Penal Reform argued in a comment piece for politics.co.uk that
prisoners deserve the right to exercise their citizenship by
voting.
Gove will use his speech to warn that the European court
of justice will decide whether
prisoners can
vote, intervene on how intelligence services monitor suspected terrorists, and control asylum and refugee policy.
The tactic
of using the business committee to force a Commons division was successful in overturning moves to give the
vote to
prisoners.
They have faced criticism over David Cameron's negotiations over the EU budget, over confirming they will almost triple the cap on tuition fees to # 9,000 and over the announcement that they will have to implement the European Court
of Human Rights (ECHR) ruling that
prisoners should be able to
vote.
Clarke's defiant stance on
prisoner voting and more community sentences is at odds not just with Conservative core voters but many Labour core voters — in other words, a lot
of voters, as the Sun and Daily Mail have noticed.
Grieve's exit has cleared the way for the Conservative party to clash more directly with the European court
of human rights as he had cautioned over defying the Strasbourg authority on issues like
prisoner voting.
Former attorney general says ruling on
prisoner voting by European court
of human rights offers way out from split