They fail to understand the broader dimensions
of scenario uncertainty as well as the existence of flat out ignorance on a number of topics, plus the ambiguity associated with arguments for the warming made from the perspective of natural variability.
Not exact matches
Along with Garcia, dozens
of Dreamers have started their own companies since coming to the U.S., and the
uncertainty surrounding the DACA program has them girding for losses and, in the worst - case
scenario, deportation.
Between late 2016 and early 2017, Bentham's team put together four
scenarios to try to help make sense
of how Shell might navigate the radical
uncertainty.
«Although it's possible to think about
scenarios and plan for several possible outcomes, I think it's extremely difficult for companies
of all sorts to make concrete plans right now with this amount
of uncertainty,» she said.
It added that «the effect on U.S. growth is estimated to be positive through 2020, cumulating to 1.2 percent through that year, with a range
of uncertainty around this central
scenario.»
The EPA denied the resource consent on the basis
of the
uncertainties and was not convinced the applicant's proposed conditions and adaptive management
scenarios would ensure sustainable development (See the executive summary
of the decision here).
It was smooth sailing through the end
of February, and then a series
of scenarios converged onto the investing landscape, creating large potholes
of uncertainty that took a significant toll on short - term investor sentiment.
In making such decisions under conditions
of uncertainty (Ruth Macklin calls them conditions
of ignorance), the construction
of best - possible and worst - possible
scenarios will probably depend in no small part on the basic orientation
of the individuals constructing them.
The authors note that cost - benefit analyses
of sustainable land management
scenarios «can be done even with limited data availability, «and underscore that, despite an inevitable degree
of uncertainty, «it is imperative to take action now, as every day sees the loss
of more productive land that will have to be gained back.»
Instead, most modelers accommodate the inevitable
uncertainties by averaging over many runs
of each
scenario and displaying a likely range
of outcomes, much like landfall forecasts for hurricanes.
Modeling future climate
scenarios is a notoriously tricky science, involving wide margins
of uncertainty, myriad variables and a profusion
of data.
Next the pair calculate what happens if they loosen the limits
of the
uncertainty principle in this
scenario, allowing the messages to be better decoded and letting you access information that you wouldn't have had when the
uncertainty principle was in force.
But, they argued, this
scenario violated the Heisenberg
uncertainty principle, which said that it's impossible to know both the position and momentum
of a particle at the same time [because the act
of measuring one instantly and unavoidably changes the other].
Remember the job interview
scenario: You can reduce some
of the
uncertainty by preparing for your interview.
Even the latest report
of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) sees clouds as the greatest
uncertainty factor in the climate
scenarios of the future.
Large
uncertainties were caused by the GMSLR
scenario and sediment size; however, the minimum projected rate
of beach loss was 18 % in the near future, and this rate
of loss is expected to have significant implications for coastal management.
«There is no single forensic tool that is useful in all
scenarios, as all have some degree
of uncertainty,» said Metcalf.
As can be seen your graph, our climate models make a wide range
of predictions (perhaps 0.5 - 5 degC, a 10-fold
uncertainty) about how much «committed warming» will occur in the future under any stabilization
scenario, so we don't seem to have a decent understanding
of these processes.
Structured expert judgment has been used for decades in fields where
scenarios have high degrees
of uncertainty, most notably nuclear - energy generation, Oppenheimer explained.
On time - scales
of a few decades, the current observed rate
of warming can be used to constrain the projected response to a given emissions
scenario despite
uncertainty in climate sensitivity.
The estimated size
of and
uncertainty in current observed warming rates attributable to human influence thus provides a relatively model - independent estimate
of uncertainty in multi-decade projections under most
scenarios.
As acknowledged in an Australian Bureau
of Agriculture and Resource Economics report on climate change
scenarios, also released on Monday, there are still considerable scientific
uncertainties surrounding the nature and extent
of future climate change.
As we mentioned briefly, that leads to a «sweet spot» for forecasting
of a couple
of decades into the future where the initial condition
uncertainty dies away, but the
uncertainty in the emission
scenario is not yet so large as to be dominating.
This could be used for more
uncertainty runs, having larger ensembles, exploring a wider range
of types
of scenarios.
It's not necessarily obvious to the uninitiated what a huge effect this ~ 2ºC
uncertainty in ECS estimates has on
scenarios that attempt to predict the magnitude and timing
of climate change impacts (e.g. the AR5 RCPs).
Woody's rollercoaster
of excitement and confliction resonate with human
uncertainty about growing older, leaving one place behind, or having to choose between two desirable
scenarios.
The Department will communicate scientific and technological findings by including a clear explanation
of underlying assumptions, including accurate contextualization
of uncertainties, and describing the probabilities associated with both optimistic and pessimistic projections, including best - case and worst - case
scenarios where appropriate.
Scenario II: Deferred tax assets (with expiration dates
of up to 20 years)
of $ 36 M have not been recognised in respect
of US losses, due to
uncertainty regarding their utilisation.
The Norwegian - born and Berlin - based artist follows up Dubious Desire for Cleanliness at Rod Barton and Consume Meaning and Wash Away the Stains
of uncertainty at Come over Chez Malik's, as well as a contribution to New
Scenario's C R A S H group exhibition with a new solo exhibition at the Berlin space.
All these factors and many more combine
uncertainties resulting in different
scenarios of change — each potentially likely to occur.
Our results show that the only way in our
scenarios to achieve the 1.5 °C target in the presence
of SIAF would be through negative emissions, which imply more risks and
uncertainties for the future [Rogelj et al., 2015; Hansen et al., 2016].
The estimated size
of and
uncertainty in current observed warming rates attributable to human influence thus provides a relatively model - independent estimate
of uncertainty in multi-decade projections under most
scenarios.
Of course, on a timescale of one decade the noise in the temperature signal from internal variability and measurement uncertainty is quite large, so this might be hard to determine, though tamino showed that five year means show a monotonic increase over recent decades, and one might not unreasonably expect this to cease for a decade in a grand solar minimum scenari
Of course, on a timescale
of one decade the noise in the temperature signal from internal variability and measurement uncertainty is quite large, so this might be hard to determine, though tamino showed that five year means show a monotonic increase over recent decades, and one might not unreasonably expect this to cease for a decade in a grand solar minimum scenari
of one decade the noise in the temperature signal from internal variability and measurement
uncertainty is quite large, so this might be hard to determine, though tamino showed that five year means show a monotonic increase over recent decades, and one might not unreasonably expect this to cease for a decade in a grand solar minimum
scenario.
The magnitude and timing
of this emission
scenario is unconstrained due to large
uncertainties in estimating future rates
of cryosphere degradation, hydrocarbon reservoir response, and potential methane oxidation.
He also gives the distinct impression that the majority
of the scientific community thinks this is a plausible
scenario, and without any reference to the relevant
uncertainties and timescales.
The most we can hope for, given the high
uncertainties, is a range
of plausible
scenarios or projections for any given region.
Even if the SRES
scenarios have some bias, it's more or less lost in the noise
of other
uncertainties.
It's not necessarily obvious to the uninitiated what a huge effect this ~ 2ºC
uncertainty in ECS estimates has on
scenarios that attempt to predict the magnitude and timing
of climate change impacts (e.g. the AR5 RCPs).
The trends for the period 1984 to 2010 (the 1984 date chosen because that is when these projections started),
scenario B has a trend
of 0.27 + / -0.05 ºC / dec (95 %
uncertainties, no correction for auto - correlation).
Although there is still some disagreement in the preliminary results (eg the description
of polar ice caps), a lot
of things appear to be quite robust as the climate models for instance indicate consistent patterns
of surface warming and rainfall trends: the models tend to agree on a stronger warming in the Arctic and stronger precipitation changes in the Topics (see crude examples for the SRES A1b
scenarios given in Figures 1 & 2; Note, the degrees
of freedom varies with latitude, so that the
uncertainty of these estimates are greater near the poles).
Over the short time scales considered, the model
uncertainty is larger than the
uncertainty coming from the choice
of emission
scenario; for sea level it completely dominates the
uncertainty (see e.g. the graphs in our Science paper).
When comparing with alternative models
of plant physiological processes, we find that the largest
uncertainties are associated with plant physiological responses, and then with future emissions
scenarios.
So if I understand things correctly, the IPCC «
scenarios» show a range
of global temperature values due to the
uncertainties of future forcings.
Pielke compares single
scenarios of IPCC, without mentioning the
uncertainty range.
Note that such an ice dynamic
uncertainty was only included for Greenland but not for Antarctica; instability
of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet, a
scenario considered «very unlikely» in the TAR, was explicitly not included in the upper limit
of 88 cm.
However if the
uncertainty is
of the same order as the signal in the forecast (
scenario if you will) then the meaning
of the forecast is pretty much nil.
Based on results from large ensemble simulations with the Community Earth System Model, we show that internal variability alone leads to a prediction
uncertainty of about two decades, while
scenario uncertainty between the strong (Representative Concentration Pathway (RCP) 8.5) and medium (RCP4.5) forcing
scenarios [possible paths for greenhouse gas emissions] adds at least another 5 years.
(Another fine point: This is slightly less than the central estimate
of 43 cm for the A1FI
scenario that was reported in the media, taken from earlier drafts
of the SPM, because those 43 cm was not the sum
of the individual best estimates for the different contributing factors, but rather it was the mid-point
of the
uncertainty range, which is slightly higher as some
uncertainties are skewed towards high values.)
Since 1990, observed sea level has followed the uppermost
uncertainty limit
of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) Third Assessment Report (TAR), which was constructed by assuming the highest emission
scenario combined with the highest climate sensitivity and adding an ad hoc amount
of sea - level rise for «ice sheet
uncertainty» (1).
In the rekognition
of the
uncertainties, the IPCC Good - Practice - Guidance - Paper on using climate model results offers some wise advice (first bullet point under section 3.5 on p. 10): the local climate change
scenarios should be based on (i) historical change, (ii) process change (e.g. changes in the driving circulation), (iii) global climate change projected by GCMs, and (iv) downscaled projected change.