Reference is made particularly to the judgment of the Constitutional Court no. 138/10 in the first two applicants» case, the findings of which were reiterated in a series
of subsequent judgments in the following years (see some examples at paragraph 45 above).
Not exact matches
If our listeners insist on attributing to us those qualities they glimpse in the first few seconds
of our talks, despite
subsequent evidence to the contrary, let us employ all means at our disposal to take advantage
of their leap to
judgment.
This includes disagreements over
judgment calls made by lenders or their agents; changes in circumstances occurring after the underwriting process has been completed; small mistakes that bear little relation to either the credit risk or the
subsequent default; and inconsistent interpretations
of the rules.
My concern at this juncture is with the biblical witness itself, as crucial springboard for — and basis for
judgment of —
subsequent developments in the church's theologizing.
The reference to the furnace
of fire and to men weeping and gnashing their teeth, which reappears in several
of the
subsequent parables
of judgment, is straight out
of Jewish eschatology.
And consonant with the immutable position
of Yahwistic prophetism, whose primary proposition is always the effective impingement
of divine life upon history, the meaning
of Solomon's reign and
of events
subsequent to it is discerned in the scheme
of sin and
judgment: like Babel, apostasy results in the rupture
of human community.
In his
subsequent maturing he revised that
judgment.40 I am suggesting that the so - called conversion experiences
of Wesley and Luther and many others are really transition experiences.
McGovern's failure to properly vet Eagleton and his
subsequent handling
of the controversy gave occasion for the Republican campaign to raise serious questions about his
judgment.
You know the media fireworks that went round in Akwa Ibom State as at the time
of the tribunal and the
subsequent judgment at the appeal court was way too confusing to most people.
This error
of judgment is seen all over, from the damming
of rivers (and
subsequent loss
of fish species) to the misguided attempts
of the BLM in trying to control horse and wolf populations while ignoring natural selection).
Our approach, then, attributes the effect
of the SFJ in
subsequent years to the party in power when the
judgment is made, even if there is a
subsequent change in partisan control.
-- For purposes
of paragraph (2)(C), in determining whether a first or
subsequent violation has occurred, a determination in a single action, by
judgment or settlement, that the covered entity has engaged in more than one discriminatory act shall be counted as a single violation.
Indeed, even while a consumer is enrolled in a debt relief program, creditors and debt collectors may continue to make collection calls pending resolution
of the consumer's debts and may proceed with lawsuits and
subsequent enforcement
of any
judgments, such as through garnishment
of wages.
The
subsequent rejection
of Duchamp's Fountain by the exhibition's organizers ignited a controversy that continues today about the definition
of art and who gets to pass
judgment.
But what will be hard will be the harsh
judgment of history on the President and Secretary
of State that allows this pipeline - and the
subsequent tipping points
of climate change - to come to pass.
During decision making, anchoring occurs when individuals use an initial piece
of information to make
subsequent judgments.
There were many different representations
of uncertainty (e.g., a range in models versus an expert
judgment) in the TAR, and the consensus RF bar chart did not generate a total RF or uncertainties for use in the
subsequent IPCC Synthesis Report (IPCC, 2001b)(Chapters 2 and 7; Section 9.2).
Labour's strategy has been to seek to get the court to give a
subsequent judgment that allows consideration
of national security issues to be balanced against the rights
of the individual.
The decision to refuse those requests was the subject
of judicial review and
subsequent appeals culminating in a
judgment from the House
of Lords.
In addition, although the Gunn Court noted that state court interpretations
of the Patent Act would not be binding on federal courts, [10] final state court
judgments determining patent issues, such as validity, infringement, or claim construction, may well be binding on a patentee in
subsequent litigation involving the same or related patents.
Applying the Restatement (Second)
of Judgments § 27, the Court noted that «subject to certain well - known exceptions, the general rule is that when an issue
of fact or law is actually litigated and determined by a valid and final
judgment, and the determination is essential to the
judgment, the determination is conclusive in a
subsequent action between the parties, whether on the same or a different claim.»
After reviewing the key paragraphs
of the Court
of Appeal's
judgment in Mitchell and a number
of subsequent authorities as well as outlining the principal criticisms which had been leveled against that case, the Court
of Appeal went on to set out the new guidance.
In view
of the fact that the
judgment in the said case was not appealed to the Court
of Justice, the GC followed this reasoning also in the case T - 186 / 11 Schönberger v Parliament, however, this time, the applicant's petition was declared admissible by the Petitions Committee, but, as Mr. Schönberger alleged, not properly handled in the
subsequent steps.
In its
judgment, the GC had concluded that the
subsequent de facto application
of the Association Agreement and the Liberalisation Agreement to the territory
of Western Sahara had to be interpreted as
subsequent practice in the sense
of Article 31 (3)(b) VCLT, justifying the interpretation
of the territorial scope
of the Agreements as including Western Sahara.
While this is very true
of course, I am a bit puzzled by the
subsequent paragraphs
of the
judgment relating to the role
of NCA's and the assistance they can give to undertakings in providing legal certainty.
Questioned by SBA about the information in the 2010/2011 edition
of JUVE, he acknowledged in a letter in May 2016 that his firm had represented Volkswagen Bank in the competition dispute until a
judgment of the Munich Court
of Appeal in 2010, with a separate lawyer representing it in
subsequent proceedings before the Federal Supreme Court in Germany.
Subsequent Reasons to the original trial
judgment addressed the issue
of whether or not the banked sick time was recoverable as a gross amount or net amount.
[9]
Subsequent to the reporting
of this
judgment, this author is not aware
of any reported attempts to enforce the award elsewhere.
It is interesting to note the last part
of the
judgment, where the Court addresses the requirements to be complied with during the
subsequent proceedings and refers to the Charter
of Fundamental Rights
of the EU.
On the basis
of the
judgment of Lord Justice Megaw in Maredelanto Cia Naviera SA v Bergbau - Handel GmbH (The Mihalis Angelos)[1971] 1 QB 164, [1970] 3 All ER 125, it argued that the only exception to this rule was where
subsequent events were, at the date
of crystallisation, inevitable or predestined.
Judge Snowdon's
subsequent judgment clarifies that, even where there is a finding
of wrongful trading, it is possible that administrators» and liquidators» costs will not be recovered.
868, 874 - 78 (N.D.N.Y. 1995)(granting summary
judgment in favour
of employer on employee defamation claim stemming from employer's investigation and
subsequent reporting
of employee's illegal conduct, and finding that the investigation was conducted in a «thorough and responsible manner» because it was initiated immediately following reports
of wrongdoing, included interviews with all relevant parties and an extensive review
of books and records, and was undertaken by a team including both inside and outside counsel).
On the
subsequent appeal, the Court
of Appeal noted that summary
judgment for divorce should not be granted where it would result in the other spouse losing benefits such as health insurance coverage prior to the determination
of the corollary relief issues.
Similarly, Cecil et al. found that defendants moving for summary
judgment were awarded summary
judgment in full 64 %
of the time, whereas plaintiffs moving for summary
judgment were awarded summary
judgment in full only 39 %
of the time.90 In a
subsequent study
of all federal district court summary
judgment activity in 2006, Cecil and Cort found that moving parties succeeded more often (57 %) than non-moving parties (43 %), as was the case for moving parties in federal court in our sample (73 % to 27 %).91 Although success rates in our sample were higher than success rates in the Cecil study and the Cecil and Cort study, a higher success rate is expected given that we excluded motions seeking partial summary
judgment from our sample.
Where criminal proceedings follow civil proceedings, ordinarily findings
of a civil court on the matters in issue in the criminal case will not be admissible in those
subsequent criminal proceedings, although in some circumstances civil
judgments may be admissible pursuant to the rules concerning evidence
of bad character.
The precautionary principle has received considerably more local attention since the principle was mentioned (albeit in a non-binding part
of the decision) in the Supreme Court
of Canada's 2001
judgment in Spraytech v. Hudson and in the
subsequent Ontario Court
of Appeal decisions in R. v. City
of Kingston and in Crop Life v. Toronto.
Notwithstanding a
judgment of non-return pursuant to Article 13
of the 1980 Hague Convention, any
subsequent judgment which requires the return
of the child issued by a court having jurisdiction under this Regulation shall be enforceable in accordance with Section 4
of Chapter III below in order to secure the return
of the child.
A refusal does not prevent a
subsequent application for recognition or enforcement
of the
judgment.
LeNoury now faced the unenviable task
of trying to overturn two
subsequent lower
judgments written by two respected workhorses: Justice James O'Reilly
of the Federal Court
of Canada and Justice David Stratas
of the Federal Court
of Appeal.
The
judgment deals with this argument by citing the decisions in Zaiwalla & Co v Walia [2002] IRLR 697, [2002] All ER (D) 103 (Aug) and Governing Body
of St Andrew's Primary School v Blundell [2010] UKEAT / 330/09, [2010] All ER (D) 68 (Oct), in each
of which aggravated damages reflected the abusive way in which the employer had defended the
subsequent legal proceedings; from this it was extrapolated that there can be consideration
of post-termination conduct generally, provided that it is causally linked to the original discrimination.
While Stanley Burnton J did — but «not without considerable hesitation» — accept as lawful the additional reasons, in the course
of his
judgment he extracted the following useful propositions from R v Westminster City Council, ex p Ermakov [1996] 2 All ER 302 and other authorities: - Where there is a statutory duty to give reasons as part
of the notification
of the decision, so that (per Mr Justice Laws in R v Northamptonshire County Council, ex p D [1998] ED CR 14) «the adequacy
of the reasons is itself made a condition
of the legality
of the decision», only in exceptional circumstances, if at all, will the court accept
subsequent evidence
of the reasons.
Mr. Pratap learned senior counsel submitted that even if earlier Court has erroneously assumed jurisdiction by applying Part - I, in another proceeding based on different cause
of action, same Court can decline to exercise jurisdiction based on
subsequent judgments of Supreme Court and this Court.
Even if this Court has erroneously assumed jurisdiction under a statute, it does not mean the Court can not decline jurisdiction in another set
of proceedings between the same parties if there are several
subsequent judgments of this Court and Division Bench
of this Court clarifying the legal position in regard to the jurisdiction
of Court under the statute.