The current economic climate may result in an increase in the number
of summary judgment applications as parties seek to dispose of cases quickly.
In deciding that wrongful dismissal damages were not an appropriate matter for summary judgment, the court's reasoning expressly went beyond the question of the jurisdiction of a Master under the Court of Queen's Bench Act, but rather was based upon «the purpose and nature
of summary judgment applications, trials and summary trials» (at paragraph 31).
It must also consider whether the High Court judge was correct to conclude, for the purposes
of the summary judgment application, that the appellant's claim of indirect discrimination contrary to ECHR, arts 6 and 14 had a real prospect of success.
It also considered whether the High Court judge was correct to conclude, for the purposes
of the summary judgment application, that the appellant's claim of indirect discrimination contrary to ECHR, arts 6 and 14 had a real prospect of success.
For the purpose
of a summary judgment application, it is conceded the Respondent failed to advise the Appellant of the problem, and the Chambers Judge assumes the rig became stuck because of the sulfamic acid in the mud.
Not exact matches
An Ontario Court
of Appeal justice has warned against «
summary judgment at all costs» in her dissent
of a ruling on the
application of the doctrine
of emergency in a personal injury case.
There were three
applications before the Court
of Queen's Bench when Robertson heard the appeal this winter, all for
summary judgment.
-- Hanco ATM Systems v. Cashbox ATM Systems [2007] EWHC 1599 (Ch): Led by Andrew Hochhauser Q.C. in relation to
summary judgment application against senior employee for breach
of fiduciary duty and dishonest assistance and involving issues as to the doctrine
of «preparatory steps».
Procedural
applications, including for interim payments,
summary judgment / strike out, unless orders (see [2017] EWHC 1847 (Ch)-RRB-, security for costs, stay
of proceedings, anti-suit injunctions (see [2015] 2 B.C.L.C. 560), and
applications for the preservation
of material and for specific and enhanced (Puruvian Guano) disclosure (see [2015] EWHC 3761 (Comm)-RRB-.
With the support
of fellow BROKE members Dutton filed his mid-December
application for a
summary judgment to include dismissal
of Kinder Morgan's damage claims and an «Order for special costs payable by the Plaintiff to the Defendant.»
Applications for
summary judgment under CPR Pt 24 often involve points
of construction.
The list
of issues should be used by judges to actively promote a consideration
of whether particular issues were appropriate for
summary judgment or strike out
applications.
PNC filed an opposition with the TTAB against Ashe's
application, and Ashe and PNC filed cross-motions for
summary judgment on the basis
of priority.
Following the filing
of a motion for
summary judgment on numerous issues, including
application of the policy's pollution exclusion in Connecticut, the plaintiff insured withdrew the action.
A
summary judgment application was brought by Google in Trkulja v Google Inc & Anor (No 2)[2010] VSC 490 --(28 October 2010) after the plaintiff's fourth amendment to the pleadings, but the
summary judgment was abandoned and the proceedings focused again on the sufficiency
of the pleadings.
The issues in this
application were whether the applicants were entitled to
summary judgment on their harassment claim and whether the court should grant a permanent injunction pursuant to s. 3 (3)
of the 1997 Protection Against Harassment Act.
The judge disposed
of the
application by refusing
summary judgment and, without notice, effectively giving
summary judgment to the defendant and throwing out the specific performance claim.
A fine balance It is accepted that there is always a balance to be struck on a
summary judgment application between the risk
of injustice to the claimant and the injustice
of subjecting defendants to the time and costs
of a claim that is fanciful in approach and amount.
Sophia Purkis sets out the test for a successful
application, following the Ticketus ruling
Summary judgment applications are an established tool to seek determination
of suitable claims relatively quickly.
In response to the
application, the defendant raised the issue
of the Master's jurisdiction under s. 9 (3)
of the Court
of Queen's Bench Act, and the availability
of summary judgment in the context
of a wrongful dismissal case.
In hearing a
summary judgment application, the court asks itself whether the claim / defence / counterclaim
of the party seeking to resist a
summary judgment application:..
Meanwhile, other Ontario judges were ruling on the
application of the new
summary judgment rule with diverging views over when and how it applies.
The company made an
application for
summary judgment, seeking to dismiss the claim at the outset or, in the alternative, to strike out portions
of the claim.
Moreover, McDonald J.A. highlights the fact that, on review
of the transcript before the Chambers Judge, the Respondent did not clearly and unequivocally advise the court at the outset
of the
application that he was seeking dismissal
of the claim and not simply seeking dismissal
of the
application for
summary judgment (see the exchange between Appellant's counsel and the Chambers Judge reproduced at para. 39).
Accordingly, the court concluded that there was no issue
of fact related to the
application of the assumption
of risk defense and therefore affirmed the trial court's grant
of summary judgment.
Successfully acting for liquidators in obtaining
summary judgment in very substantial misfeasance proceedings, as well as orders on a committal
application, against multiple respondents arising out
of the collapse
of a large retail company
We also recognized that procedural changes that have taken place over the last decade — for example, the change in the cost consequences
of a failed
application for
summary judgment in Ontario following the Osborne Report — might also affect a ten - year review
of SJPs.
Acted for the administrators
of an estate in relation to a dispute concerning ownership
of a company's shares, including defending a
summary judgment application involving questions
of res judicata from previous decisions in parallel foreign proceedings.
We began to wonder — was an
application for
summary judgment emerging as an intentional strategy used by represented parties against SRLs, labeling them as vexatious and appealing to the concerns
of judicial officers about SRLs «jamming up» the courts?
In denying
summary judgment to GE and granting
summary judgment to Boston Edison, the Court found that: (1) while the construction work performed by GE met the definition
of an improvement to real property for purposes
of the statute
of repose, public policy considerations necessitated an exception to the
application of the statute in cases involving alleged asbestos - related disease; (2) the installation
of asbestos insulation was not an abnormally dangerous activity; (3) Boston Edison did not exercise sufficient control over the work at issue to be held negligent; and (4) a premises owner, such as Boston Edison, has no duty to warn where the subcontractor has knowledge
of the hazard which is equal to or greater than that
of the premises owner.
The
judgment of Mr Justice Dingemans in the case
of R (on the
application of Sunita Sisangia) v Director
of Legal Aid Casework is here and a
summary was posted by Doughty Street Chambers here.
Contempt
of court proceedings for breach
of anti-suit injunctions and
application for
summary judgment on the claim in the underlying English action.
Common types
of interlocutory
applications, such as
summary judgment,
applications to strike, substitutional service, and dismissal for long delay, are highlighted.
He is particularly experienced in cost effective ways
of bringing cases to an end including strike out and
summary judgment applications.
In a
judgment handed down today, two former executive directors
of Lloyds Bank have succeeded in their
application for
summary judgment for an award
of shares.
Applications under CPR Pt 24 (
summary judgment) often involves short points
of construction
of agreements.
The other cases mainly dealt with procedural issues (consolidation
of applications under the Substitute Decisions Act, adjournments,
summary judgment, and
applications under Rule 14.05).
For the purposes
of a strike out /
summary judgment application it was assumed that these allegations were justified (para [40]-RRB-.
Our client, faced with a
summary judgment application in a conspiracy case, asked us to conduct initial research on both the substantive law as well as the standards required by the courts, and provide a detailed analysis
of the pleadings.
The chambers judge's assessment
of the facts, the
application of the law to those facts, and the ultimate determination
of whether
summary judgment is appropriate are entitled to deference: Hryniak v Mauldin, 2014 SCC 7 (CanLII), [2014] 1 SCR 87 at paras 81 - 84; Windsor v Canadian Pacific Railway Ltd, 2014 ABCA 108 (CanLII) at para 10, 371 DLR (4th) 339.
A chambers judge's assessment
of the facts based on the record before the chambers judge, the
application of the law to those facts and the ultimate determination
of whether
summary judgment is appropriate are all reviewed for palpable and overriding error: Amack v Wishewan, 2015 ABCA 147 (CanLII) at para 27, 602 AR 62.
Our client was swamped dealing with the legal and factual aspects
of a complex
summary judgment application.
The court has held that where a defendant serves a late acknowledgment
of service, he may be entitled to an extension
of time to serve the acknowledgment together with a period
of time in which to consult with his recently appointed lawyer prior to putting in a response to a
summary judgment application by the claimant.
Read in light
of the fact that the test is equivalent to the CPR's
summary judgment test shows that there is a high threshold to be applied to the evidence before the court in determining the
application.
The
judgment contains, by way
of background, a helpful
summary of the divorce procedure in England and Wales: «An
application for divorce is made in the English court by an originating process called a petition.
After service
of a Reply alleging malice, C issued an
application for rulings on meaning and consequential orders for strike out /
summary judgment on the justification defence.
The Trademark Office in this case stated that in order to raise a genuine issue
of material fact as to its intent to use on a motion for
summary judgment, an applicant must rely on specific facts that establish the «existence
of an ability and willingness to use the mark in the United States to identify [the goods in the
application] at the time
of the filing
of the
application.»
Its
application would gut the efficacy
of summary judgment.
SUMMARY Under limited supervision, performs work involving the
application of technical expertise and independent
judgment to the preparation
of specialized departmental documents, the use
of...
SUMMARY OF QUALIFICATIONS More than twenty years functioning in positions demanding leadership, creativity, judgment, dedication, and organization including detailed working knowledge of all phases of the Software Development Life Cycle, with concentration on developing a wide range of software application
OF QUALIFICATIONS More than twenty years functioning in positions demanding leadership, creativity,
judgment, dedication, and organization including detailed working knowledge
of all phases of the Software Development Life Cycle, with concentration on developing a wide range of software application
of all phases
of the Software Development Life Cycle, with concentration on developing a wide range of software application
of the Software Development Life Cycle, with concentration on developing a wide range
of software application
of software
applications.