What it is: The Center for American Progress, a liberal public policy think - tank, this week released a report titled «The State
of Teacher Evaluation Reform,» which looks at new teacher - evaluation systems in New Jersey and five other states as they continue to evolve under new state and national mandates.
If we are surprised by the often muted effects
of teacher evaluation reform, that is perhaps because we are insufficiently sensitive to the forces that contribute to seemingly inflated teacher evaluations.
We are at the very beginning stages
of teacher evaluation reform.
New York Governor Andrew Cuomo re-ignited the controversy by including a second round
of teacher evaluation reforms in his budget this year.
Some proponents
of teacher evaluation reforms have conjectured that if districts would eliminate the bottom 5 to 10 percent of teachers each year, as measured by value - added student test scores, U.S. student achievement would increase by a substantial amount — enough to catch up to high - achieving countries like Finland.3 However, there is no real - world evidence to support this idea and quite a bit to dispute it.
Not exact matches
Download one chapter at a time due to the very large file size Chapter One Waldorf Education and Education
Reform Chapter Two The Waldorf Understanding
of the Purpose
of Education Chapter Three Research Objectives and Procedures Chapter Four How Waldorf
Teachers Set Learning Goals Chapter Five Teaching and Making Assessments in a Waldorf Classroom Chapter Six Formal Assessments in Waldorf Education Chapter Seven Learning - centered Assessments: Waldorf Methods in Concept Chapter Eight The Preparation, Profession, and Practice
of a Waldorf Class
Teacher Chapter Nine
Teacher Evaluation in Waldorf Elementary Schools Chapter Ten Waldorf Education and the Future
of Assessment for Learning
The Obama agenda has focused almost exclusively on systemic school
reform to address the achievement deficits
of disadvantaged students: standards, testing,
teacher evaluations, and a continued, if different, focus on accountability.
Cuomo has had an at - times truculent relationship with
teachers unions, especially when it comes to support for charter schools and other concerns
of the education
reform movement, such as stronger
teacher evaluations.
Cuomo quickly backed away from his plans and left the promise
of teacher evaluation and tenure
reform unfulfilled, much to the unions» delight.
During a speech at the Rockefeller Institute
of Government in Albany, King offered education
reforms such as the Common Core standards and
teacher evaluations as vehicles
of greater equality in schools.
Assemblyman Jim Tedisco (R,C,I - Glenville), today will offer an amendment to
reform the rules
of the New York State Assembly to stop major legislation like pension
reform,
teacher evaluations, the SAFE Act and state budgets from being passed in the middle
of the night away from public viewing.
Assemblyman to bring to the Floor
of the Assembly a Rules
Reform Amendment to stop major legislation like Pension
Reform,
Teacher Evaluations, SAFE Act & state budgets from being passed in the middle
of the night
Cuomo is linking up to $ 1.1 billion in new spending for education to enacting a number
of his education
reform proposals, including lifting the cap on charter schools and a new, more stringent
teacher evaluation process.
«The key education
reforms are dealing with the epidemic
of failing schools, improvement to the
teacher evaluation system, tenure
reform,
teacher performance bonuses and scholarships to attract new
teachers.
Mr. Cuomo had declared he would boost education funding by just over $ 1 billion only if the legislature agreed to adopt his
reform plans — which included state receivership
of failing schools, an increase in the charter cap, new
teacher evaluations based on state exams, and changes to
teacher tenure.
But Mr. Malatras has been particularly visible in pushing Mr. Cuomo's education
reform agenda, authoring a long and public letter to the state's Board
of Regents and liaising with various interests in Albany as all sides gear up for a post-budget fight over the specifics
of teacher evaluations.
Walcott warned that his successor will be in a «unique» situation after he leaves on Dec. 31, jumping in mid-year to take over «a lot
of new things that [are] in process right now, like our
teacher evaluation, the total ramping up
of the new Common Core and making sure we continue in our special ed
reform.
Elia and the Board
of Regents are revising the
teacher and principal
evaluations for the fifth time since 2010, and Pallotta said there's a lot riding on the
reforms, including whether the test boycott movement will continue.
In an act
of open defiance toward Albany and Cuomo's education
reform agenda, the Kenmore - Town
of Tonawanda School Board voted unanimously to «seriously consider» boycotting
teacher evaluations and standardized testing in the district.
He also accused the governor
of «demonizing»
teachers and «moving down the wrong path» on standardized testing, though Cuomo has recently done an about - face on that issue, most notably calling — through his latest
reform task force — for a moratorium on linking test results and
teacher performance
evaluations.
Democratic lawmakers in that chamber already have a number
of issues they have to get done: rent control, monitoring the regulations for the new
teacher evaluation law and an extension
of mayoral control for New York City schools and criminal justice
reform, just to name a few.
«A
teacher evaluation system is his signature education accomplishment and I can't imagine that he would move toward dismantling a
reform he fought so hard for,» said Campbell Brown, founder
of the Parents Transparency Project.
ALBANY — The final budget bill containing education funding and policy, introduced on Tuesday afternoon, included modified versions
of many
of Governor Andrew Cuomo's original
reform proposals, including an overhauled
teacher evaluation system.
In a joint letter, education
reform groups thanked Governor Cuomo, Senate Leaders Skelos and Klein, and Assembly Speaker Silver for the substantial improvements you made to New York State's
teacher evaluation law as part
of this year's budget.
On Thursday, with the New York State Board
of Regents hearing testimony regarding the newly approved
teacher evaluation system, leading education
reform organization StudentsFirstNY and public school parents offered recommendations and sent letters calling for a system that ensures all public school students have access to high - quality
teachers.
While ethics
reform may be dominating much
of the conversation in Albany, education advocates are hoping the public and lawmakers don't forget there's much work to be done regarding
teacher evaluations.
For a long time, one
of the signature elements
of Mr. Cuomo's education -
reform agenda had been tying
teacher evaluations to the test scores students received on state exams.
Making
teacher evaluations more dependent on test scores,
reforming tenure and adding charter schools in the city were all priorities
of StudentsFirstNY and became significant pieces
of the governor's agenda for the 2015 legislative session, which he announced in his State
of the State speech on Jan. 21.
At Tuesday's meeting, Pryor and his staff reported on progress made in key
reform areas, including a new
teacher evaluation system and a new set
of academic goals called the Common Core State Standards.
Nationally, Natale's words struck a chord as
teachers everywhere are dealing with
reforms similar to those implemented in Connecticut this year — a new
teacher evaluation system, new academic standards known as the Common Core State Standards, and the trial
of a new computerized testing system.
In his State
of the State address on Jan. 21, Governor Andrew Cuomo tied $ 1.1 billion in additional state education aid to the passage
of his «
reform» proposals in the state budget: individual merit pay, more charter schools, punishing struggling schools, and making
teacher evaluation hinge on state test scores.
Plattsburgh City School District Superintendent Jay LeBrun attributes the overall decrease to the link between student scores and
teacher evaluations — a major sticking point last year as educators battled with the state Department
of Education and the governor over
reforms that would have wedded the two.
We've heard a lot about the new
teacher evaluation plan, school aid and ethics
reforms but this week on New York NOW we'll take a look at what a small fraction
of the $ 142 billion spending plan is helping create - a logger training program.
Besides his ethics promise Cuomo insists he will only increase state education spending by $ 327 million if the Legislature does not accept his sweeping education
reforms, which include a new
teacher evaluation system and an increase
of the charter school cap.
Included among the proposed
reforms is a
teacher evaluation system based half on student test scores, an increase in the length
of time before a
teacher is eligible for tenure and allowing the state to take over failing schools and districts.
Commissioner Elia and the Board
of Regents are revising the
teacher and principal
evaluations for the fifth time since 2010, and Pallotta, with NYSUT, says there's a lot riding on the
reforms, including whether the test boycott movement will continue.
But perhaps most substantially, there is a growing awareness in the world
of education
reform that the big battles over getting new
teacher - evaluation laws passed or school accountability systems implemented are not the end of the story («The Teacher Evaluation Revamp, In Hindsight,» features, Spring
teacher -
evaluation laws passed or school accountability systems implemented are not the end of the story («The Teacher Evaluation Revamp, In Hindsight,» features, Spr
evaluation laws passed or school accountability systems implemented are not the end
of the story («The
Teacher Evaluation Revamp, In Hindsight,» features, Spring
Teacher Evaluation Revamp, In Hindsight,» features, Spr
Evaluation Revamp, In Hindsight,» features, Spring 2017).
Five - year
evaluation study on the effectiveness
of A + arts - integrated school
reform strategies in Oklahoma schools, based on a survey
of students,
teachers, and professional - development faculty.
Noting that
teacher evaluation was a crucial lever
of Obama - style
reform, he observes, «Progress was uneven, hampered by both design flaws and capacity challenges.
A court victory in the
teacher -
evaluation case would clear the decks for even more thoroughgoing
reforms of teacher preparation and support
of the kind that Ruszkowski has indicated he is interested in pursuing.
Most
of the new data show that a great majority
of teachers score just as highly on the new
evaluations as they did on the previous ones, and it is unclear whether the
reforms have systematically — or broadly — led to
teachers to receiving better feedback that is translating to better teaching.
That recognition has driven a tidal wave
of controversial policy
reforms over the past decade, rooted in new
evaluation systems that link
teachers» ratings and, in some cases, their pay and advancement to evidence
of classroom practice and student learning.
Nationwide, school administrators identify only a tiny fraction
of their
teachers as ineffective, despite major
evaluation -
reform efforts by state and federal governments.
What if the reason that
teacher evaluation reform was so disappointing — with 98 percent
of teachers still rated effective — was because we misdiagnosed the problem?
To be sure, mistakes were made: Not understanding the limitations or unintended consequences
of federal leadership on education; a disastrous, ill - timed excursion into
teacher evaluation reform; a technocratic impulse that was insufficiently sensitive to parents» concerns about issues like student privacy; and on and on.
Among the
reform milestones they achieved were a new requirement that 40 percent
of a
teacher's
evaluation be based on student achievement; raising the charter school cap from 200 to 460; and higher student achievement goals on the National Assessment
of Educational Progress (NAEP) 4th grade and 8th grade reading tests and Regents exams.
One interpretation
of the emphasis on developing the common core curriculum is that these debates provide a convenient diversion from potentially more intractable fights over bigger
reform ideas like using improved
teacher evaluations for personnel decisions, expanded school choice, or enhanced accountability systems.
The worst thing we could do at this time with
teacher and principal
evaluations related to student achievement, even though I think it is the Holy Grail
of school
reform, is to impose any version from Washington.
A high - school English
teacher in her ninth year, Keigan and other fellows have been involved in shaping the details
of SB 191, the Colorado
reform bill that made major changes to
teacher - related policies, including
evaluations and tenure.
Moreover, summative assessment sat at the core
of many
of the policy
reforms that the leaders described: additional accountability levers such as
teacher evaluation systems and statewide school report cards draw on data coming out
of these summative tests to make determinations and comparisons regarding
teacher and school - level performance.