My hunch for what it's worth is that drilling holes are probably not a huge addition to the complexity of the real heat transport
of the sediment column.
Variant to the right assumes lateral variation in the deformability
of the sediment column, leading to irregular lateral compression.
Bottom waters at depths of 50 or 100 m might warm relatively quickly with a collapse in sea ice cover, but it would take centuries for that heat to diffuse through the 100 - 150 m
of sediment column to the hydrate stability zone.
When this model ``... neglects many of the mechanisms that could come into play in transporting methane quickly to the atmosphere, such as faults, channels, and blowouts
of the sediment column» then one must ask what bearing or predictive - value it has for abrupt methane release.
Not exact matches
Carried within the water
column, accumulating on the ocean bottom or becoming entrained in marine
sediments — a spill
of Alberta bitumen might prove impossible to contain.
The team analysed the chemical composition
of tiny shells built by organisms (foraminifera) that had lived in the water
column and at the sea bottom before their shells became embedded in the seafloor
sediments.
His team bored several three - meter - long
columns of sediment from parts
of the seafloor that were covered by Larsen B until its collapse.
The researchers found the chironomids burrowed into the
sediment, moving water and oxygen into the
sediment and increased the levels
of nutrients released into the
sediment porewater and water
column.
This «purification» function is carried out by the microorganisms present in their water
column and
sediments and, with it, they improve the general quality
of the water and reduce the nitrogen load by promoting denitrification.»
In 97 - million - year - old freshwater
sediments in eastern Morocco, researchers discovered new Spinosaurus fossils, including parts
of the skull, vertebral
column, pelvis, and limb bones.
The bacteria living in these
sediments were respiring the oxygen but at a slower rate than the supply
of organic material dropping out
of the water
column, allowing these ancient deep marine
sediments to remain oxygenated.
Carozza et al (2011) find that natural global warming occurred in 2 stages: First, global warming
of 3 ° to 9 ° C accompanied by a large bolus
of organic carbon released to the atmosphere through the burning
of terrestrial biomass (Kurtz et al, 2003) over approximately a 50 - year period; second, a catastrophic release
of methane hydrate from
sediment, followed by the oxidation
of a part
of this methane gas in the water
column and the escape
of the remaining CH4 to the atmosphere over a 50 - year period.
So it's not too much
of a stretch
of the imagination to think that those
sediments would still contain microorganisms that essentially don't care if a big
column of sea - water, or ice, is above them.»
During such periods, a wave surge scours the sandy bottom and suspends clouds
of sediment in the water
column.
Strong variations in the geochemical and paleo - ecological composition and genetic signature
of the
sediments in the Black Sea provide testimony that the conditions in the water
column have been far from constant over the past ∼ 7.5 kyr.
This will induce massive dissolution
of CaCO3 in the water
column as well as the
sediment,... we project detectable dissolution - driven changes only by the year 2070 in the surface ocean and after 2230 and 2500 in the deep Atlantic and Pacific respectively.
But these experiments spanned 100 hours, while the
sediment column has been warming for thousands
of years, so the experiments do not really address the question.
The real
sediment column has faults and explosions (there are lots
of things in the ocean that look like this thing in Siberia, they are called «pockmarks»).
[Response: As a modeler
of the deep
sediment column, I go to talks about observations
of the real world (geology, in other words), and am struck by how simplistic the models are.
Damming
of the river has resulted in the build - up
of highly methanogenic
sediments under a shallow water
column, facilitating the transformation
of fixed CO2 to atmospheric CH4.
Note that the
sediments can still remain unfrozen because
of the salt contamination», page 7, right
column, first paragraph.
Some
of this is lost to
sediments and some dissolved as it sinks to maintain water
column chemistry.
First through reductions in calcium carbonate polymorph super-saturation and then by dissolution
of water
column and
sediment sources.
«Pelagic
sediment or pelagite is a fine - grained
sediment that has accumulated by the settling
of particles through the water
column to the ocean floor beneath the open ocean far from land.
Carozza et al (2011) find that natural global warming occurred in 2 stages: First, global warming
of 3 ° to 9 ° C accompanied by a large bolus
of organic carbon released to the atmosphere through the burning
of terrestrial biomass (Kurtz et al, 2003) over approximately a 50 - year period; second, a catastrophic release
of methane hydrate from
sediment, followed by the oxidation
of a part
of this methane gas in the water
column and the escape
of the remaining CH4 to the atmosphere over a 50 - year period.
Large amounts
of methane are stored in seafloor
sediments as gas hydrate, and as these melt the gas is released into the water
column.
Even on the Siberian continental margin, where water temperatures are colder than the global average, and where the
sediment column retains the cold imprint from its exposure to the atmosphere during the last glacial time 20,000 years ago, any methane hydrate must be buried under at least 200 m
of water or
sediment.
Another approach is to «grow» the
sediment column through geologic time to obtain an initial condition for a climate change perturbation scenario (Archer et al., 2012), but uncertainties in various model parameters, such as the methane production rate and the fate
of bubbles in the
sediment column, prevent a well - constrained model forecast
of the methane hydrate response to climate warming.
Episodic and explosive escapes
of gaseous methane from the
sediment column have been documented by kilometer - scale «wipeout zones» in seismic images (Riedel et al., 2002), and pockmarks on the sea floor, called eruption craters (Hill et al., 2004).
Warming bottom waters in deeper parts
of the ocean, where surface
sediment is much colder than freezing and the hydrate stability zone is relatively thick, would not thaw hydrates near the
sediment surface, but downward heat diffusion into the
sediment column would thin the stability zone from below, causing basal hydrates to decompose, releasing gaseous methane.
The time scale for this mechanism
of hydrate thawing is on the order
of centuries to millennia, limited by the rate
of anthropogenic heat diffusion into the deep ocean and
sediment column.
Coupled atmosphere - ocean climate models can be used to simulate the thermal response
of the ocean water
column to climate change with a moderate degree
of uncertainty and the subsequent penetration
of heat into the
sediment column.
Organic matter in the uppermost few centimetres
of sediments is first attacked by aerobic bacteria, generating CO2, which escapes from the
sediments into the water
column.
By understanding the relationship between the size, composition and distribution
of particles found on the bottom with the motion
of the water
column above, scientists who study long cores
of ocean
sediment can tell how currents have changed or moved over time.
The idea is that the bubbles might lift the grains off
of each other, destabilizing the
sediment column.
As part
of the Dead Sea Deep Drill Core Project, Goldstein and other colleagues drilled deep below the lakebed
of the Dead Sea in 2010 and 2011 to pull up more than 1,300 feet (400 meters)
of sediment in a long
column — a record
of sediment deposits spanning 200,000 years.