It seems that in most trad publishing arrangements there is an agent involved, and 15 % less in the pockets
of trad authors is a pretty big shift in the figures you calculate.
With author Alexandra Lynwood in faithful pursuit, however, even the engaged and engaging Zacharius seems to run up on yet another interesting silence: The Silence
of the Trad Authors.
In particular, I'm very struck by the number
of trad authors in the UK who are now in almost open opposition to the publishers who are still mostly slapping high prices on an ebook at launch.
Not exact matches
I was discussing this with someone yesterday, going back and forth at possible explanations, which included that self - pubbed
authors tend to work the review mines harder than their
trad pubbed peers, or have more support from other indie
authors reviewing, or get higher ratings due to the generally lower price
of the work (greater satisfaction due to a price / performance expectation).
We are in a flood
of authors and books, and it doesn't matter if you are a
Trad -
Author or Indie
Author we all float the same and we're on our own.
We asked her a bunch
of questions about what she found in regard to
author income, books on sale, and whether indie or
trad publishing is more likely to get a person to a living wage (which she defined as the U.S. average
of $ 32,000 a year).
And I think the (near) future holds a lot
of surprises and new turns that indie
authors will be able to capitalise on (better than
trad.
The more we can do to help
authors navigate the tricky learning curve
of either self - publishing or working with agents towards a
trad publishing contract the better!
The truth has always been that most
trad published books are damp squibs (speaking from experience), but self - publishing has allowed
authors to give readers what they want to read instead
of what agents and publishers think they want to read.
This year I received responses from a total
of 227
authors, representing 2,594 indie titles
of which 1928 were frontlist indie titles and 666 were backlist (
trad - pubbed, now indie) titles, assuming no duplicates (see above).
The top news
of the week touched upon waning ebook sales for
trad pubs, the EU's recent ruling that ebooks aren't books, the new
Author Earnings Dashboard, the getting - by attitude, and the indie startup mindset.
Are poets not
authors, because books
of poetry typically have low sales, whether self - published or
trad - published?
Now
trad publishers are scrambling to sign some
of the
authors they turned away because they have proven that readers want to have more
of a selection.
The poor
trad - published Official Koslowski
Authors must be so sad having to share their Goodreads shelf space with the absolute scum
of the Earth.
If book «x» is
trad published and successful enough to sell, let's say, 20,000 books (or whatever, just a number I grabbed at), and book «y» is indy published and sells the same amount, there is no doubt that the
author of the indy book is going to be FAR better off.
I outsell 50 %
of the
authors on Amazon, both
trad and indie, but because some editor didn't validate me I'm not deserving
of the title «real
author»?
LK — A lot
of agents and publishers are making
trad pubbed
authors do this stuff.
When you think about it, it makes sense: back when
trad pub limited us to one book a year per
author, there were still plenty
of people who became fans
of Terry Prachett, Mercedes Lackey, Patricia Briggs and David Weber.
And you're also correct that
trad - pubbed
authors earn only a fraction
of the net revenue for each book sold.
Many
of my
author friends are
trad published, and I always saw that as a grass - is - greener issue.
Some
of the biggest indie
authors first got their start in
trad pub, while others never sent out a single query letter before hitting it big.
I went to an
author talk by a
trad pubbed
author and she had to buy a copy
of her own book at the bookstore because her contract doesn't allow her to buy copies
of her own book at a discount from the publisher.
However, we know they're elitists from things they've said in the past about self - published books being
of lesser quality compared to
trad pub books (how ironic that now
trad pub
authors are complaining more about their books having so many typos and problems when printed).
If you look at a number
of trad published
authors they had pen names for their different genres and now they are moving away from that.
We actually talk to
authors - you see a few blog posts and articles and believe we are at war but the reality is many
of us know
trad published
authors - some are happy, some are becoming unhappy, some are in the middle
of lawsuits, some are no longer writing because they couldn't afford to sue and gave up.
You are not one
of the big 5 and many
of us commenting on Joes blog have
trad author friends.
Most
authors who go with them from
Trad Pub speak very highly
of them.
Manufacturer
of raw goods (
authors)- > Supplier
of finished goods (
trads)- > Amazon - > Final customer (reader) Then there is Amazon.
I am friends with several
authors who came out
of trads because
of rigidity and low returns.
Considering how poorly trained the volunteers were — most
of whom are readers and have zero idea
of author politics or the indie /
trad battle
of bruised egos — I'm not surprised if a) one or two volunteers got the designation wrong and / or b) the overheard conversations had zero to do with the book signing and were instead «why does your name badge say that / what do you write / do you have a book out?»
Have to disagree with some
of the points on
trad publishing though - For the pros you neglected to mention that the publishers distribute your book to all bookstores and e-books sites (hitting two marketing areas) A huge Pro considering most
authors are battling to get their book seen and traditional publishing can do that.
I know
of very few
trad pub
authors who made six figures on their first novels.
For most
trad pub
authors, you are on your own to do most
of the same promotion you'd do as an indie.
Then I read the new
trad pubbed books
of long - time favorite
authors.
For every Brandon, there are thousands
of trad pub
authors that came and went.
[NOTE:
of course, there are
authors who do some combination
of the above, some books indie, some
trad - pub, etc..
It's also worth noting that the
author of the AE report, Hugh Howey, admitted in comments on Chuck Wendig's blog (fourth down) that actually he earned more from
trad pub last year that he did from Amazon.
Author of #historical fiction, ex costume designer, history, art and nature fan (currently both
trad and indie published).
Nice little round - up
of blogs
authors of all stripes, indie and
trad alike, should be following.
However, when I wrote The Experiencers (my first novel) and consulted on the subject
of trad versus indie publishing with a hybrid
author who has been writing books since the 1970s, he made a good case for me to go indie.
And since the onus
of marketing is vastly on me and my coauthor (something else many self - publishing
authors don't realize — they'll have to do the majority
of book promotion themselves regardless
of how they publish), there hasn't been a real advantage to going the
trad route.
And one
of the biggest negative effects we've now created as indie
authors is denigrating the value
of ebooks — specifically indie ebooks, as you'll find the
trad pubs don't do much, if any, free promo — in the eyes
of the audience that buys them.
The other thing is that I think over the next decade or so, we're going to see a lot
of independent
authors do as well or better on their own, compared to how they would've done with
trad publishers.
I'll answer by repeating Shawn's point, that a surprising proportion
of readers wouldn't know a
trad - pub from a self - pub
author.
Once again, Kozlowski's argument is to infantilize the reader and whine that they need to be «protected» from the scourge
of indie
authors, as if the average reader can't tell a poorly written, sloppy book from the crisp and beautiful books produced by
trad publishers.
More than that, the
trad authors are afraid
of being pushed out, which they should be.
It's one thing to say that indie publishing is a successful alternative to
trad publishing and worth pursuing, and that there are notable success stories — especially among trained, highly motivated
authors — most
of them with established name from
trad pub backgrounds.
Because this is just what
trad - pubbed
authors probably thought about Amazon's launch
of KDP.
It would also be great if
Author Earnings could study this, and compare the money made by a trad pub author in libraries vs an indie author's, and also the raw numbers of books trad published in libraries vs indie publ
Author Earnings could study this, and compare the money made by a
trad pub
author in libraries vs an indie author's, and also the raw numbers of books trad published in libraries vs indie publ
author in libraries vs an indie
author's, and also the raw numbers of books trad published in libraries vs indie publ
author's, and also the raw numbers
of books
trad published in libraries vs indie published.
Asserting that self - publishers take away seven times more than
trad published
authors may appeal to his audience, but ignores the fact that Amazon pays just 35 % much
of the time.