The 5 - 2 ruling in Nur represents another rebuke of the Conservative government which has developed a unenviable track record
of unconstitutional legislation.
Not exact matches
This story stunned me: It is SOP for legislators to put a «severability clause» into
legislation, so that if part
of a law is found
unconstitutional, the rest
of it can remain in effect.
We are not radical democrats who believe that judicial review
of legislation is in principle
unconstitutional and illegitimate.
Finance: in this area, two articles referring to the levelling
of incomes — taking into account similarity
of fiscal effort and
legislation on local taxes — were declared
unconstitutional.
Specifically, these modern tribunes would be entitled to veto one piece
of congressional
legislation, one executive order and one Supreme Court decision; to call one national referendum, over any issue they wish (only two - thirds votes
of both the U.S. Senate and House
of Representatives may render the statute
unconstitutional); and to initiate impeachment proceedings against one Federal official from each
of the three branches
of government during their term
of office.
Trump signed
legislation imposing sanctions on Russia and limiting his own authority to lift them, but asserted that the measure included «a number
of clearly
unconstitutional provisions» and left open the possibility that he might choose not to enforce them as lawmakers intended.
Cuomo said there are a number
of strong arguments the
legislation is
unconstitutional, pointing to states» rights to tax, citizens» rights not to be double taxed, and the Equal Protection Clause.
The AG is again threatening to sue the federal government if the health care
legislation being considered in the U.S. Senate becomes law, warning
of unconstitutional provisions that remain in the latest draft.
In its haste to pass this
legislation, the Congress included a number
of clearly
unconstitutional provisions» — such as restrictions on executive branch ′ s authority that limited its flexibility in foreign policy.
Despite GOP warnings that the bill would be ruled
unconstitutional, the Democratic House majority pushed the
legislation through on a straight party line vote after nearly five hours
of debate.
«Now when this piece
of legislation was in our books, my friend and colleague, Martin Kpebu took this matter up to the Supreme Court... and the Supreme Court said that piece
of legislation is
unconstitutional.
Backers
of the
legislation, including City Council Speaker Melissa Mark - Viverito, lauded it as a way to end warrantless detention
of immigrants that they argued are
unconstitutional, and as a way to keep city families together and reform broken immigration policies.
«I believe it is
unconstitutional and we're seriously considering a lawsuit on behalf
of the people
of the state
of New York to prove what a scam and a fraud this delegation is trying to perpetrate on the people
of this state,» Cuomo said
of the proposal, which House leaders included in the Republican
legislation that would repeal and replace Obamacare.
Judicial review is the power
of the Court to examine federal
legislation, federal executive, and all state branches
of government, to decide their constitutionality, and to strike them down if found
unconstitutional.
Well over 90 %
of constitution law scholars and legal professionals, including not only the Japan Federation
of Bar Association, but also former Cabinet
Legislation Bureau Chiefs and judges, consider the bills to be
unconstitutional.
Breed Specific
Legislation (BSL) has been proven
unconstitutional in many courts and has even been addressed by the US Federal Department
of Justice as unallowable as it robs people with disabilities their right to choosing a pet that meets their specific service and therapy needs.
GRCA opposes mandatory spay / neuter
legislation because: 1) there is no evidence to suggest that it is effective in achieving its stated goal; 2) it causes well - documented health and developmental problems in some pets, especially when performed before sexual maturity; 3) it pushes responsible breeders out
of the licensing system; 4) it reduces the availability
of well - bred healthy, home bred and raised puppies; 5) it encourages the importation
of puppies and dogs from less acceptable sources, including foreign countries; and 6) because laws that force owners to perform surgery on their pets without a rational basis for doing so may be
unconstitutional.
This is not
unconstitutional, the constitution clearly gives any powers not expressly given to the federal government to the state, and so long as the state does not have
legislation forbidding localities from restricting the sale
of certain animals, then this is perfectly legal.
While Congress members like Fred Upton (Republican, Michigan) yowl about the EPA's efforts to regulate carbon emissions as «an
unconstitutional power grab» and attach the term «job - killing» to every piece
of environmental
legislation with a political pulse, national security officials have been offering dire warnings about the perils
of climate disruption and its offshoots like food shortage, water depletion and massive migration.
By taking a unified stand and claiming the individual mandate was
unconstitutional, the Republican Party, conservative think tanks, right - wing media and Republican activists helped create a climate
of controversy about the
legislation, which then pressured the mainstream media to report on the controversy, which then created a cloud
of doubt among the public, which ultimately created an environment in which the right - leaning members
of the Supreme Court could make a judgement that may have looked radical or outrageous if not for the contextual cover provide by permission structure.
An Ontario court has dismissed a set
of appeals from four families that sought to have provincial
legislation related to the approvals
of large - scale wind farms declared
unconstitutional.
«This furthers a clear pattern
of politicization
of the judiciary,» Bass» statement says, «starting with the disregard
of judgments
of the Constitutional Tribunal striking down
legislation as
unconstitutional and failing to seat judges properly appointed to it.
In our blog post
of February 18, 2014, «British Columbia Supreme Court Awards $ 2 Million in Damages for Freedom
of Association Violation,» we reported that the B.C. Supreme Court declared Bill 22,
legislation relating to teachers» collective bargaining rights,
unconstitutional.
This time around, Tessmer claimed the purpose
of the GST
legislation was
unconstitutional because
of the inconsistency between the government's dual roles as prosecutor and tax collector on the services required to defend that prosecution.
In addition to the purpose
of the
legislation, Tessmer argued its effect was also
unconstitutional.
It is true that, unlike their virtually unanimous attitude on the issue
of religious freedom, state courts have not always sustained Sunday
legislation against the charge
of unconstitutional discrimination.
The
legislation builds on a bill introduced in March and looks to amend or repeal a number
of provisions in the Criminal Code the government has determined are out
of date or likely
unconstitutional.
I suspect that both the Quebec and Federal governments are well aware
of the possibly
unconstitutional nature
of these pieces
of legislation.
The Supreme Court
of Canada agreed with the trial judge and the Court
of Appeal that the amendments that were introduced in this piece
of legislation were not
unconstitutional.
This, in turn, suggests Kinder Morgan's lawyers have a clearer grasp
of what B.C.'s constitutional chances are with its still - vague plan to enact environmental
legislation to mitigate potential damage from the expanded pipeline than do most political commentators in Alberta, who have declared the idea
unconstitutional without actually knowing what it is.
The Supreme Court
of Canada ruled that the Harper government's
legislation making retroactive changes to parole eligibility breaches the Charter
of Rights and is thus
unconstitutional.
* Passed
legislation in 1995 baring the application
of joint and several liability in the recovery
of all damages, which was struck down as
unconstitutional by Illinois State Supreme Court.
[26] Ultimately, this is the legislature's decision to make once one
of its provisions or pieces
of legislation has been found
unconstitutional.
The Court released a decision that the original IRP
legislation was
unconstitutional and no longer in effect as
of June 30, 2012.
And the sad reality is — even after the announcement
of Bill C - 39 —
unconstitutional and historical zombies still walk our
legislation and the government seems content to sit on its hands feeding on low - hanging fruit — until the next legal disaster.
In 2011, the Supreme Court
of British Columbia found the
legislation unconstitutional because it infringed s. 2 (d)
of the Charter, and the infringement was not justified under s. 1
of the Charter.
Though the heart
of s. 4 has been found
unconstitutional, it remains in the
legislation; I suspect however that Delisle will be charged under another section.
The British Columbia Teachers» Federation (BCTF) challenged the
legislation as
unconstitutional on the basis that it deprived them
of collective bargaining rights, thereby infringing their freedom to associate guaranteed under s. 2
of the Charter.
If the provincial
legislation effected a transfer
of ownership other than according to the terms
of the federal Copyright Act, then this would seem to be a potentially
unconstitutional interference with federal jurisdiction over copyrights.
This decision does not conclude that all essential services
legislation that imposes limits on strike action will be
unconstitutional; however, it will have an impact on the future
of labour relations across Canada... [more]
The majority
of the Court found the
legislation unconstitutional because it violated s. 2 (d) freedom
of association, but found it unnecessary to decide whether it violated s. 15 (1).
«It doesn't go so far as to create a licence for wage - restraint
legislation — it just doesn't; this is a unique circumstance — but I think governments are at least going to have some comfort that certain forms
of wage - restraint
legislation is not automatically
unconstitutional.»
There's at least one case saying this type
of legislation is unenforceable and to some extent
unconstitutional: http://www.canlii.org/en/mb/mbqb/doc/2014/2014mbqb155/2014mbqb155.html
We would be better off with a default rule stating that
unconstitutional parts
of a statute ARE severable unless Congress says the opposite, which would then provide a clear backdrop for
legislation.
(Indianapolis, Ind.)-- Planned Parenthood
of Indiana and Kentucky (PPINK) today filed suit against the Indiana State Department
of Health in U.S. District Court, arguing that Senate Enrolled Act 371 (SEA 371),
legislation that singles out one health center in Lafayette for unnecessary new restrictions, is discriminatory and
unconstitutional.
WASHINGTON — Planned Parenthood Federation
of America denounced today's House Judiciary Committee passage
of dangerous and
unconstitutional legislation that would ban abortion at 20 weeks nationwide — interfering in a woman's ability to make personal decisions about her pregnancy in consultation with her doctor.