That's the picture that emerged from an Education Week analysis
of waiver proposals submitted last month to the U.S. Department of Education by 11 states, whose proposals offer insight into what the next generation of state - led accountability looks like.
That's the picture that emerged from an Education Week analysis
of waiver proposals submitted last month to the U.S. Department of Education by 11 states, whose plans offer insight into what the next generation of state - led accountability looks like.
Not exact matches
The department and Board
of Regents also are working to create different pathways to graduation for high school students, including a
proposal for project - based assessments, something the
waiver would help them expand.
Klein's
proposals range from eliminating housekeeping accounts, repealing the Wilson - Pakula
waiver and creating public funding
of political campaigns.
President Obama sparked much debate in Washington with his plan to grant states
waivers from provisions
of the No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB), conditional on their willingness to embrace certain reform
proposals sketched out in the administration's March 2010
proposal, «A Blueprint for Reform: The Reauthorization
of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act.»
Passed in 2008, it invited
proposals for creating innovation schools, which could request
waivers to district policies, state statutes, and union contracts — including tenure for new teachers — if 60 percent
of the teachers voted for the Innovation Plan.
Borrow a page from Senator Alexander's 2007
proposal, or Senator Jim DeMint's A-Plus bill, and allow states to negotiate broad
waivers with the Secretary
of Education to do things very differently.
Since California's
waiver was rejected last year, and the state is not reapplying this year, CORE is going its own way, filing for a
waiver under a provision
of NCLB allowing districts to submit
proposals.
Peter Smyth, a retired educator and administrator, and also a co-founder
of Community Voice, says, «After a career in education and research into educational reform, I have come to these conclusions: while South Carolina Superintendent Zais has applied for a
waiver to No Child Left Behind, his
proposals reflect those
of Secretary Duncan and the current and previous administrations, policies which have not achieved their goals and have made raising test scores and graduation rates, rather than meaningful learning, the default goals
of American education.
State officials have aligned the remake
of their letter grade system with Indiana's request for a
waiver from requirements
of the federal No Child Left Behind law, which the state filed in November — about the same time the
proposal first came before the State Board
of Education.
The
proposal explains the first year
of data from the 2012 - 13 school year and how these meet the federal standards for a
waiver.
State superintendent Glenda Ritz and the rest
of the DOE are accepting public comment on their draft
proposal to the keep the state's No Child Left Behind
waiver.
His
proposal calls for the Secretary
of Agriculture to establish a process for granting a «
waiver from compliance» with the law to any school food program that «verifies a net loss» for a period
of six months beginning July 1, 2013.
The administration granted
waivers to to states in spite
of questions raised by the peer review panel it put in place to vet the
proposals about whether the promises made would be fulfilled.
Last month, the administration scrambled to get Virginia to scrap its low expectations for poor and minority children amid outcry from reformers and civil rights activists over the Old Dominion's move to approve AMO targets that only require districts to ensure that 57 percent
of black students (and 65 percent
of Latino peers) are proficient in math by 2016 - 2017; those targets were blessed by the administration back in June as part
of its approval
of the state's
waiver proposal.
The entire
waiver process was sloppily administered in the first place, with Duncan granting
waivers to states (and allowing them to ignore whole sections
of No Child) even thought they have not yet implemented or enacted all the
proposals within their applications, and the administration ignoring concerns raised by its own peer review panels about such matters as how states have ignored the need to gain consultation on proposed changes from American Indian tribes as required under the U.S. Constitution (as well as from black and Latino communities equally affected by the evisceration
of accountability).
The administration promised $ 1 billion in new spending on preschool; spurred states to adopt controversial K - 12 reforms such as performance - based teacher evaluations and the adoption
of the Common Core State Standards through its Race to the Top grant program and
waivers to the No Child Left Behind law; significantly expanded the federal School Improvement Grant program to turn around low - performing schools; targeted for - profit colleges and attempted to increase accountability in the higher education sector; and pushed a
proposal by the president to make community college free.
Even if a state ultimately wins a
waiver — a decision that rests with Secretary Duncan — the
proposals reveal how much more work states have to do to fully usher in this new era
of accountability.
Meanwhile the Obama administration is granting
waivers to states (and allowing them to ignore whole sections
of No Child) even thought they have not yet implemented or enacted all the
proposals within their applications.
Senate Democrats have penned a No Child Left Behind reauthorization
proposal that's expected to look a lot like the Department
of Education's current
waiver process, writes Alyson Klein for Education Week:
The release
of the
proposals got everyone talking for a time, but the Obama administration's
waivers have relieved 39 states — including Indiana — from NCLB's most onerous burdens.
The administration has also ignored red flags raised by peer review panels it has put in place to vet the submitted
proposals — including concerns that states didn't present their
proposals to American Indian tribes as required under both the
waiver process (as well as under federal and state laws), and that D.C.'s plan for implementing Common Core reading and math standards was not «realistic and
of high quality».
Pressed for time, a small group
of superintendents and officials from a coalition
of nine California school districts, representing 1.1 million students, are on their way to D.C. to ensure that its No Child Left Behind
waiver proposal is passed in time for the upcoming school year.
After California's
waiver request was rejected back in January, CORE submitted its own application to the Department
of Education, marking the first time districts filed a unified
proposal.
Duncan and other U.S. Department
of Education officials ignored concerns raised by the peer review panel charged by the administration with vetting the
waiver proposals.
Nothing in the
proposals to the Broad Foundation would shock anyone who had read the NCLB
waiver application, Ms. Morgan added.Essentially, the state believes that its turnaround strategies combine the best
of outside research and close support
of school stakeholders.
In addition, Pryor said the reduction
of funding in a
proposal aimed at low - performing districts and the removal
of specific strategies to help those districts could weaken the state's chances for a
waiver of some requirements
of the federal No Child Left Behind Act.
A coalition
of 10 California districts that together serve more than 1 million students also submitted an NCLB
waiver proposal, which raises questions about both the wisdom
of a department decision to grant flexibility at the district level and the state's ability to manage two different school accountability systems.
Vermont withdrew its
waiver request over differing opinions regarding its
proposal to use local performance measures instead
of state tests to gauge student achievement every other year.
«We applaud Acting Superintendent Ekchian's
proposal to provide «forced placement»
waivers for LA Unified's highest - need schools,» said Joan Sullivan, chief executive officer
of the Partnership for Los Angeles Schools, which manages 18 high - need schools in LA Unified.
This week, California's state board
of education will consider a
proposal by the state's department
of education to ask federal officials for direct relief from NCLB without going through the official
waiver process.
Meanwhile the very questions raised by the peer reviewers about the CORE
waiver proposal extend to just about every one
of the plans for the 40 states and the District
of Columbia approved by the administration since last year.
Under the House
proposal, schools with
waivers would be exempt from increasing the availability
of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and low - fat milk and from reducing the levels
of sodium and fat in meals.
Indiana Department
of Education officials say the state's
waiver proposal does enough to hold schools accountable for making sure the most at - risk students make progress.
The Department
of Education ignored concerns from its own peer review panel about the
waiver proposal.
Nine
of the eleven
waiver proposals, including Indiana's, would do away with these subgroups, creating instead a «super-subgroup» that requires a school to ensure the bottom 25 percent
of its students make progress.
Here's the U.S. Department
of Education letter in response to Indiana's
waiver proposal (read that in full here).
As reviewers noted with Maryland's successful
waiver, most
of the failure mills that are going to be targeted under the state's
proposal are in Baltimore and Prince George's County; forcing Maryland and other states to focus on district overhauls would make better sense.
After California's
waiver request was rejected in January, CORE submitted its own application to the Department
of Education, marking the first time districts filed a unified
proposal.
Pro Technology's Tony Romm reports that the DHS
proposal, which was published in the Federal Register on Thursday, would ask for voluntary disclosure from foreign travelers — including those arriving through the Visa
Waiver program — and «follows months
of calls on Capitol Hill for greater scrutiny
of foreign visitors» social media accounts.»
Letter to the Minister
of Labour, with submission to the Board, highlights concerns over the downside risk
waiver, complexity
of forms, and
proposal to limit oral hearings.
Response: We agree with the comment supporting the proposed rule's provision to impose no requirements for the location or sponsorship
of the IRB or privacy board that was convened to review a research
proposal for the alteration or
waiver of authorization criteria.
• Answer high call volume
of customer inquiries and manage distribution
of internal / external communications, job
proposals and estimates, and provision
of insurance certifications, capital improvement certificates and lean
waivers.
Authored
proposal to eliminate bushings from tank level indication cables and request for
waiver of irregular cofferdam around multiple cable penetrator.