«A human influence
on beak size evolution is not new; we have seen the signs in Darwin's finches on the inhabited island of Santa Cruz in the Galápagos,» says Peter Grant of Princeton University, who studies ecology and evolution in Darwin's finches.
Not exact matches
If we ask why birds
on one isolated island have
beaks different from those
on others, the Darwinian answer is that they have adapted to the
size and other features of edible seeds where they live.
And because the underlying commitment is philosophical, the flimsiest facts are counted as evidence - as when the president of the National Academy of Sciences recently published an article arguing that evolution is confirmed by differences in the
size of finch
beaks, as though the sprawling evolutionary drama from biochemicals to the human brain could rest
on instances of trivial, limited variation.
He found that the food available
on the Island that the finches fed
on were different
sizes and that the
beaks were more adapted the
size of seed available.
Variants of one gene had a major effect
on rapid changes in
beak size after a drought, researchers report in the April 22 Science.
The shape and
size of the
beak are crucial for finch survival
on the islands, which periodically experience extreme droughts, El Niño - driven rains and volcanic activity.
Here we report that a Darwin's finch species (Geospiza fortis)
on an undisturbed Galápagos island diverged in
beak size from a competitor species (G. magnirostris) 22 years after the competitor's arrival, when they jointly and severely depleted the food supply.
Beak size in a finch Geospiza fortis
on one Galápagos island diverged from that of a competitor (G. magnirostris) two decades after the latter's arrival.
By careful measurements of the population of two species
on one tiny island over the course of major weather changes such as El Niño events and droughts, the Grants were able to show that evolutionary changes in
beak size and body
size can occur in as little as a couple of years.
«It is very striking that when we compare the
size and shape of the Big Bird
beaks with the
beak morphologies of the other three species inhabiting Daphne Major, the Big Birds occupy their own niche in the
beak morphology space,» said Sangeet Lamichhaney, a postdoctoral fellow at Harvard University and the first author
on the study.