In her work with Children Now, she fought for legislation
on teacher dismissals that she clearly didn't fully understand, and, in an interview with the editorial board, gave an inaccurate description of how it would work.
DeBose and Vergara are among nine students challenging state laws
on teacher dismissal, seniority and tenure that they say violate their right to an effective education.
Not exact matches
While Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone holds the line
on the teaching of orthodox moral doctrines of the Catholic Church out in San Francisco, here in New Jersey a theology
teacher in Immaculata High School in Somerville is threatened with
dismissal from her position for... agreeing with orthodox moral doctrines of the Catholic Church.
«One day when Josiah scored poorly
on a test, the
teacher made him hold up his test sheet in front of the entire class, with a big «F»
on it, until
dismissal,» Jackson said.
The
dismissal came after some 19
teachers, including the two head
teachers were invited for questioning by the GES
on Thursday, to respond to allegations that they were requesting parents and guardians to...
Teachers on the cusp of
dismissal under the IMPACT evaluation system in the nation's capital improved their performance by statistically significant margins, as did those
on the cusp of winning a large financial bonus, according to the study, published as a working paper last week by the Cambridge, Mass. - based National Bureau of Economic Research.
By comparing
teacher attrition and performance
on each side of the performance cutoffs, we can get a better sense of how the threat of
dismissal or prospect of a raise affects
teachers» behavior.
These design features create sharp incentive contrasts for
teachers with scores
on either side of the «effective» threshold, because scoring above it removes the threat of
dismissal.
'» It is nonetheless quite disconcerting that he — and those who rely
on his work — say that she was engaged in «large - scale firing» and «mass
dismissals» when in fact she released in 2010 just 241
teachers for low performance.
Now a new study by University of Michigan economist Brian Jacob finds that when given the authority, principals make
dismissal decisions that put a premium
on teacher effectiveness and student achievement.
He is reported as saying that he acted only because «he believes they [his findings] should serve as a check
on a policy of mass
dismissals of
teachers as a way to improve districts.
Chicago Study Shows Principals Focus
on Retaining Highly Effective
Teachers in
Dismissal Decisions — if Policies Permit
All of the plaintiffs claim that
teachers are subject to
dismissals and employment actions based
on seriously flawed evaluation methods.
In ruling
on the due - process question, the appeals court overturned a district court's decision to dismiss the case, which involved a San Antonio science
teacher's claim that he was «constructively discharged «3from his position without a hearing prior to his
dismissal.
In February 2010, the superintendent of schools in Central Falls, Rhode Island, announced the
dismissal of all
teachers at her district's high school
on the grounds that the school was persistently underperforming.
Minimally effective
teachers who chose to stay at DCPS improved their performance by roughly 11 - points
on the IMPACT scale, suggesting that threat of
dismissal lead to successful instructional improvement efforts.
We excluded instances of conflicts between schools and
teachers (such as
teacher dismissal cases) and between schools and nonstudent outsiders (such as drug - and weapon - free - zone cases that did not involve students), as well as student rights cases focused exclusively
on free speech issues (that is, those not combined with the school's use of suspension, expulsion, corporal punishment, and transfer).
The school
dismissal time was moved from 2:30 p.m. to 4:15 p.m. four days a week, and school started at 7:15 a.m. School was dismissed at 2:30
on one day for
teachers to participate in professional development.
For example, schools might focus
on those few places where the public can see students and
teachers during the school day, such as
on field trips or at
dismissal.
When the bell rang for early
dismissal on a recent afternoon at Cold Springs Middle School in Nevada, students sprinted toward the buses while
teachers filed into the library, where posters filled with the names of every child in the 980 - student school covered the walls.
For example, when a principal is «monitoring» student
dismissal at 3 p.m., that responsibility should be viewed as both management and leadership, Dr. Alvy said, because the principal is making sure students are safe as they are leaving school and taking the opportunity to talk with students,
teachers, and bus drivers about the day and important educational issues — such as, «Monica, I heard you did great
on your math test yesterday; well done!»
Even ranking states
on the number of education lawsuits filed by families to challenge the array of near - lifetime job protections and
teacher dismissal policies that harm children would have been good to determine.
On Wednesday, the Star Tribune's Beena Raghavendran reported that the Minnesota Court of Appeals heard oral arguments for a lawsuit in which a group of parents are challenging the constitutionality of Minnesota's
teacher tenure,
dismissal, and «last in, first out» laws.
Research Now conducted a survey of 618 California
teachers, principals and superintendents to find out their opinions
on teacher effectiveness, tenure,
dismissal and «last - in, first - out» layoffs.
The use of LIFO rules instead of ones based
on teacher effectiveness have been shown to increase the number of
teachers who must be dismissed and to dramatically alter the quality of
dismissals when compared to policies based
on effectiveness.
The full implementation of Judge Treu's striking down five laws that set rules for
teacher dismissal, seniority rights and tenure will likely not take effect for years — or not at all if the state wins
on appeal.
According to the Court, the laws in question — laws that govern
teacher tenure,
dismissal, and layoffs — impose substantial harm
on California's students by forcing administrators to push passionate, inspiring
teachers out of the school system and keep grossly ineffective
teachers in front of students year after year.
Perhaps the oddest recommendation is that if a
teacher or principal is brought up
on 3020a
dismissal charges, based
on an ineffective rating
on Common Core assessments, the
teacher or principal can blame the local Board of Education for not «providing adequate professional development.»
Its purpose was to promote the usage of students» test scores to grade and pay
teachers annual bonuses (i.e., «supplements») as per their performance, and «provide a procedure for observing and evaluating
teachers» to help make other «significant differentiation [s] in pay, retention, promotion,
dismissals, and other staffing decisions, including transfers, placements, and preferences in the event of reductions in force, [as] primarily [based]
on evaluation results.»
The LAUSD Board will hold a special closed session
on Tuesday, December 4 to confer with its legal counsel about the Doe v. Deasy case and to discuss labor negotiations: Board Members Monica Garcia and Tamar Galatzan will also introduce a resolution calling
on state legislators to change «the lengthy, expensive [
teacher]
dismissal process required...
If a career status
teacher is up for
dismissal or demotion, she has a right to a hearing by a neutral third party who would sift through the evidence to determine whether or not the employment action was based
on sound evidence.
Because Judge Rolf Treu has placed a stay
on his Vergara ruling pending the outcome of the
teachers unions» appeal, the tenure, seniority and
dismissal statutes are still alive and well in California.
When asked what the primary purpose of evaluating
teachers should be, 60 percent said to help
teachers improve, compared with 26 percent who said it should be used to document ineffectiveness that could lead to
dismissal, and 13 percent said evaluations should be used to establish
teachers» salaries based
on their skills.
A presentation was given
on how Montgomery County Public Schools (in Maryland, nearly 149,000 students in 2012 - 13) had a peer review system that actually recommended the
dismissal of
teachers.
The reforms Rhee implemented — stringent
teacher evaluations, a heavy emphasis
on test scores,
dismissals of ineffective
teachers — have continued largely apace since Henderson took over, without the sturm und drang that accompanied Rhee's tenure.
And, increasingly, we're getting solid evidence of what reforms may help:
teacher evaluations based
on student performance, higher pay and prestige for good
teachers,
dismissals for weak
teachers.
«While the educational implications here are ambiguous, what is clear is that the mass
dismissals have had a lasting impact
on the
teachers themselves, their families, and the community,» according to the latest report from the Education Research Alliance (ERA) at Tulane University.
Indeed, there are a few things we still don't know about the candidates» education positions, including where they stand
on the controversial No Child Left Behind «waiver» that LAUSD is trying to get from Washington, whether they support SB 441, the
teacher dismissal bill going through the state legislature, and — perhaps most important — which candidate they support for the District 6 School Board runoff.
Coutinho said key amendments would be filed
on Monday, including possibly those dealing with seniority rights and with the
dismissal process of ineffective
teachers.
Strong technical skills, particularly in integrating technology in the classroom to drive academic achievement Demonstrated volunteer or community service At least one (or more) of the following: o National Board Certificationo TAP Experience (sign
on bonus for TAP certification) o Core Knowledge Experienceo Experience with Blended Learningo At least two years of successful teaching in an urban environment ESSENTIAL POSITION FUNCTIONS: An Elementary School
teacher is required to perform the following duties: Plan and implement a blended learning environment, providing direct and indirect instruction in the areas of Social Studies, Science, Language Arts, Health, and Mathematics based
on state standards Participation in all TAP requirements, focusing
on data - driven instruction Create inviting, innovative and engaging learning environment that develops student critical thinking and problem solving skills Prepare students for strong academic achievement and passing of all required assessments Communicate regularly with parents Continually assess student progress toward mastery of standards and keep students and parents well informed of student progress by collecting and tracking data, providing daily feedback, weekly assessments, and occasional parent /
teacher conferences Work with the Special Education
teachers and administration to serve special needs students in the classroom Attend all grade level and staff meetings and attend designated school functions outside of school hours Establish and enforce rules for behavior and procedures for maintaining order among the students for whom you are responsible Accept and incorporate feedback and coaching from administrative staff Perform necessary duties including but not limited to morning, lunch,
dismissal, and after - school duties Preforms other duties, as deemed appropriate, by the principal Dress professionally and uphold all school policies
One of the historical failings of
teacher evaluation systems in the United States has been their reliance
on the school principal alone as the person expected to observe
teachers, mentor beginners, coach those who need help, document concerns and support processes for those who struggle, and make the final call
on whether to recommend
dismissal based
on the assembled record.
The tests must also be able to evaluate the validity and reliability of future questions because if the state is going to mandate the
dismissal of
teachers and principals based
on student test results, or ruin their reputation by posting their scores in the newspaper, then it must also require that the tests be designed to stand up in court (whether or not they ultimate do stand up is still an open question).
What that means is that if a
teacher is up for
dismissal or demotion, she or he has a right to a hearing by a neutral third party who would sift through the evidence to make a determination of whether or not the action was based
on sound evidence.
Analysts at the Fordham Foundation created a rubric for gauging the difficulty of firing ineffective
teachers based
on these three metrics: Does tenure protect veteran
teachers from performance - based
dismissal?
Previous posts: Union Tells
Teachers How to Protest Evaluations; Deasy Requests Changes to
Teacher Dismissal Bill; Union & District Clarify Positions
on Teacher Evaluation
One of the failings of
teacher evaluation systems in the United States has been their reliance
on the school principal alone as the person expected to observe
teachers, mentor those who struggle, document concerns and processes, and make the final call
on whether to recommend
dismissal.
AB 934 even adds to the bureaucratic red tape by forcing a patchwork of
dismissal policies throughout the state, the success of which will depend
on the status of the relationship between districts and their
teachers unions.
What Mulgrew never says in public is that
teachers rated developing have now been brought up
on incompetence charges and have been subject to
dismissal hearings.
The story, «The War
on Teacher Tenure,» is mostly about the Vergara decision — in which a judge found that the tenure, seniority and
dismissal statutes in the California education code are unconstitutional.
NYC Educator tears apart the Unity argument by simply saying that the old S or U system always placed the burden of proof in
teacher dismissal hearings
on management to show we were incompetent or had committed misconduct but that under the current law, after two ineffective ratings we are presumed to be incompetent.