Overall, respondents» positions
on teacher evaluation policy appeared to be unaffected by their exposure to the policy preferences of teachers.
One survey item asked respondents to rate, on a scale of 1 (not important) to 5 (very important), the importance of various actors in informing their position
on teacher evaluation policy.
Similarly, «your constituents» was among the most frequently selected «most important» voices that state education policy makers consider when taking a position
on teacher evaluation policy (see Figure 2).
Similarly, Democrats frequently selected statewide teachers unions as one of the most important groups informing their position
on teacher evaluation policy.
It may be wise to wait until the dust settles on other issues before making moves
on teacher evaluation policy.
Examining district guidance to schools
on teacher evaluation policies in the Midwest Region (Issues & Answers Report, REL 2007 — No. 030).
Not exact matches
Cuomo is also trying to shake up education
policy, by threatening to withhold hundreds of millions of dollars in increases in school aid from schools that don't agree
on teacher evaluation plans with
teachers.
Dr. Rosa's election is an indication of how much both politicians and the public have turned against the
policies promoted by Dr. Tisch, including the
evaluation of
teachers on the basis of state test scores.
The members seeking a change in leadership argued that Iannuzzi wasn't aggressive enough in fighting the
policies of Governor Andrew Cuomo and education commissioner John King, such as a
teacher -
evaluation system that includes student scores
on state exams.
A task force by New York Governor Andrew Cuomo is reversing a number of
policies in the Common Core standards, including parts of a measure
on teacher evaluations pushed by Cuomo less than a year ago.
ALBANY — The final budget bill containing education funding and
policy, introduced
on Tuesday afternoon, included modified versions of many of Governor Andrew Cuomo's original reform proposals, including an overhauled
teacher evaluation system.
Cuomo took an aggressive position during his budget and
policy address Wednesday, threatening to withhold a significant funding increase for schools if lawmakers don't approve his controversial reform proposals, such as an amendment to the state's
teacher -
evaluation system that would increase the ratings» reliance
on standardized testing.
«While there's still more to do this session
on charters and the education investment tax credit, and more to ensure every child has access to great schools, Governor Cuomo fought hard to make meaningful reforms to tenure, arbitration
policies and
teacher evaluation criteria and his vision and hard work paid off.»
The governor in New York does not directly control education
policy, but earlier this year Cuomo inserted into the state budget the requirement that new
teacher evaluations be more dependent
on standardized tests.
A task force by Gov. Andrew Cuomo is reversing a number of
policies in the Common Core standards, including parts of a measure
on teacher evaluations pushed by Cuomo less than a year ago.
Teacher evaluations — the most controversial aspect of educational
policies pursued by Cuomo — are not
on the task force's agenda.
Beyond Satisfactory: A New
Teacher Evaluation System for New York Educators for Excellent (E4E), 2011 After five months of research and debate, E4E's Evaluation Policy Team issued this report detailing an evaluation framework for New York teachers based on what actual classroom teachers would
Evaluation System for New York Educators for Excellent (E4E), 2011 After five months of research and debate, E4E's
Evaluation Policy Team issued this report detailing an evaluation framework for New York teachers based on what actual classroom teachers would
Evaluation Policy Team issued this report detailing an
evaluation framework for New York teachers based on what actual classroom teachers would
evaluation framework for New York
teachers based
on what actual classroom
teachers would recommend.
In his campaign this year, Pelto hammered the governor
on policies including the Common Core State Standards initiative, a controversial
teacher evaluation program, and charter school management.
The commissioner has also largely avoided the drama that often accompanies education
policy in New York, instead sticking to SED's script
on controversial topics, like Common Core and
teacher evaluations.
Cuomo has told lawmakers that they must accept education
policy changes — including adding authorization for 100 new charter schools and making
teacher evaluations more dependent
on standardized tests — in order for him to agree to give the state's schools more money.
Elizabeth Ross, managing director of state
policy for the National Council
on Teacher Quality (NCTQ), refers to New Mexico as a «strong positive outlier» on the teacher - evaluation
Teacher Quality (NCTQ), refers to New Mexico as a «strong positive outlier»
on the
teacher - evaluation
teacher -
evaluation front.
The new
policy would have eventually based
teachers» salaries in part
on evaluations by the principal and a number of outside evaluators hired by the district.
Anyone participating in the education
policy debate for five years or more probably staked out their position
on the use of value - added (or student achievement growth) in
teacher evaluations long ago.
By 2011, the governing bodies of both the National Education Association and the American Federation of
Teachers had issued new
policy statements
on teacher evaluation.
Every discussion of education
policy, program design, implementation and
evaluation on instruction,
teacher policies and education, or school governance focuses
on improving educational outcomes for young people and ensuring that all learners have access to a high - quality education relevant to the 21st century.
With the importance of education fresh in her mind, Vegas went
on to pursue a master's in public
policy at Duke and then a doctorate at the Ed School, where her dissertation was an economic and research - based
evaluation of «how we could design
policies to attract, retain, and motivate better
teachers,» she says.
It can't be blamed
on policy changes like No Child Left Behind (NCLB) or Common Core or
teacher evaluations, because the upward trend predates all of these
policies.
Several new groups work to amplify the voices of top classroom
teachers as they weigh in
on controversial
policy issues, as with the
evaluations in Los Angeles.
Although an estimated 98 percent of the country's school systems have
policies requiring the
evaluation of
teachers, administrators are «woefully inadequate» at carrying the
policies out, according to Jerry W. Valentine, one of two nationally - recognized experts
on evaluation who spoke this month at a seminar here sponsored by the National Organization
on Legal Problems of Education (nolpe).
This includes state - level
teacher evaluation, report card, or school ranking
policies that rely heavily
on summative assessments; but also the federal ESEA's emphasis
on once - yearly tests that shaped state
policy with the induction of No Child Left Behind.
ESSA also gave state leaders significantly more autonomy to set
policy on other questions, such as
teacher evaluation, diminishing the federal government's influence over state
policy.
Based
on the literature reviews, observations in the schools and meetings with the departments at the Ministry of Education, the team presented several key
policy considerations to the Ministry: (1) utilize a website, the National Play Day, and the Jamaican Teaching Council as platforms from which educators can develop and share best game - based learning practices; (2) promote a culture of collaboration through the Quality Education Circles (local discussion groups for educators), and by allocating time for
teachers to develop and share game - based learning strategies; (3) provide resource support for schools in the form of workshops and training; and (4) create a monitoring and
evaluation plan to be conducted at the school level.
Moreover, summative assessment sat at the core of many of the
policy reforms that the leaders described: additional accountability levers such as
teacher evaluation systems and statewide school report cards draw
on data coming out of these summative tests to make determinations and comparisons regarding
teacher and school - level performance.
They enact
teacher evaluation and turnaround
policies whose efficacy and impact rest entirely
on the ability of officials to execute them competently and aggressively in the face of contracts, embedded routines, and recalcitrant cultures.
Cohen and Walsh point out that it is state law which drives tenure
policy and which frequently mandates much of the anachronistic step - and - lane pay schedule as well as the restrictions
on teacher evaluation.
But it is precisely the focus
on teacher evaluation — and whether it is connected to student test scores — that is at the center of the most hotly contested education
policy debates.
, American Economic Review, 2005; Anna Egalite, Brian Kisida, and Marcus Winters, «Representation in the Classroom: The Effect of Own - Race
Teachers on Student Achievement», Economics of Education Review, 2015; Stephen Holt and Seth Gershenson, «The Impact of
Teacher Demographic Representation
on Student Attendance and Suspensions», IZA discussion paper 9554, 2015; and Constance Lindsay and Cassandra Hart, «Exposure to Same - Race
Teachers and Student Disciplinary Outcomes for Black Students in North Carolina», Educational
Evaluation and
Policy Analysis, 2017.
But testing opposition appears to be more closely linked to concerns about
teacher evaluation policies: the top two reasons chosen among a national survey of parents who opted out were, «I oppose using students» performance
on standardized tests to evaluate
teachers» and «standardized tests force
teachers to teach to the test.»
I do this as someone who played a role in the events that I describe: in 2011 and 2012, I was part of the
policy team working
on the No Child Left Behind (NCLB) waiver initiative and grant programs like the
Teacher Incentive Fund (TIF), and played a role in spreading the Obama administration's teacher evaluation policies across the c
Teacher Incentive Fund (TIF), and played a role in spreading the Obama administration's
teacher evaluation policies across the c
teacher evaluation policies across the country.
In a January special session, lawmakers approved new education
policies, including the requirement that half of
teacher evaluations be based
on student achievement data.
According to the National Council
on Teacher Quality, 32 states and the District of Columbia altered their teacher - evaluation policies in recent years to incorporate multiple methods of assessing and evaluating teachers, spurred in part by the federal Race to the Top compe
Teacher Quality, 32 states and the District of Columbia altered their
teacher - evaluation policies in recent years to incorporate multiple methods of assessing and evaluating teachers, spurred in part by the federal Race to the Top compe
teacher -
evaluation policies in recent years to incorporate multiple methods of assessing and evaluating
teachers, spurred in part by the federal Race to the Top competition.
Previous
teacher evaluation policies didn't differentiate poor
teachers from average
teachers or great ones — much less award or discipline
teachers based
on their performance.
A good
teacher is now recognized as someone whose students learn and grow, with 38 states revising their
policies on educator effectiveness to include measures of student growth or achievement as one of multiple factors in
teacher evaluations.
But our
policies — especially school - level accountability and test - based
teacher evaluations — focus
on academic achievement alone.
The new report did not capture a precise measure
on what proportion of tests were required by
teacher evaluation, but it does point out that many states have put in place new assessments «to satisfy state regulations and laws for
teacher and principal
evaluation driven by and approved by U.S. Department of Education
policies.»
The seminar — promoted through a collaboration between HGSE and the Center for Public
Policy and Educational
Evaluation (Centro de Políticas Públicas e Avaliação da Educação, or CAEd) of the Federal University of Juiz de Fora in Brazil — focused
on education reform, specifically U.S. efforts to develop 21st - century skills through
teacher education, leadership development, and the definition of standards for
teachers and school leaders.
As Sandi Jacobs, managing director of state
policy for the National Council
on Teacher Quality, said, «There wasn't enough concern about how these things [the Common Core and teacher evaluation] were running down the path together until the tests became an issue.
Teacher Quality, said, «There wasn't enough concern about how these things [the Common Core and
teacher evaluation] were running down the path together until the tests became an issue.
teacher evaluation] were running down the path together until the tests became an issue.»
Several of the most significant features of recent education
policy debate in the United States are simply not found in any of these countries — for example, charter schools, pathways into teaching that allow candidates with only several weeks of training to assume full responsibility for a classroom,
teacher evaluation systems based
on student test scores, and school accountability systems based
on the premise that schools with low average test scores are failures, irrespective of the compositions of their student populations.
In addition to her full schedule of classes in the International Education
Policy Program (IEP), Chan interned at UNICEF, participated in a study group
on educational access and quality that applied their coursework to
evaluations of a
teacher accreditation program in Mexico, was
on IEP's advisory board, and led a number of outreach activities connecting her peers to the young students they hope to serve.
While these calculations illustrate the magnitudes of
teachers» impacts
on students, they do not by themselves offer a blueprint for the design of optimal
teacher evaluations, salaries, or merit - pay
policies.