Chad Aldeman of Bellwether Partners recently provided a reflection
on teacher evaluation reform during the Obama presidency in Education Next.
Thomas Toch — education policy expert and research fellow at Georgetown University, and founding director of the Center on the Future of American Education — just released, as part of the Center, a report titled: Grading the Graders: A Report
on Teacher Evaluation Reform in Public Education.
Feel free to read more here, as publicly available: Grading the Teachers: A Report
on Teacher Evaluation Reform in Public Education.
In a growing number of states and school districts, new, more meaningful evaluation systems have focused principals» attention on instruction, prompted valuable discussions in schools Read more about Grading the Graders: A Report
on Teacher Evaluation Reform in Education -LSB-...]
Not exact matches
The Obama agenda has focused almost exclusively
on systemic school
reform to address the achievement deficits of disadvantaged students: standards, testing,
teacher evaluations, and a continued, if different, focus
on accountability.
Broader questions remain
on school aid, however, even as education
reforms such as
teacher evaluation criteria are no longer linked to funding.
Cuomo is linking up to $ 1.1 billion in new spending for education to enacting a number of his education
reform proposals, including lifting the cap
on charter schools and a new, more stringent
teacher evaluation process.
Mr. Cuomo had declared he would boost education funding by just over $ 1 billion only if the legislature agreed to adopt his
reform plans — which included state receivership of failing schools, an increase in the charter cap, new
teacher evaluations based
on state exams, and changes to
teacher tenure.
Walcott warned that his successor will be in a «unique» situation after he leaves
on Dec. 31, jumping in mid-year to take over «a lot of new things that [are] in process right now, like our
teacher evaluation, the total ramping up of the new Common Core and making sure we continue in our special ed
reform.
Elia and the Board of Regents are revising the
teacher and principal
evaluations for the fifth time since 2010, and Pallotta said there's a lot riding
on the
reforms, including whether the test boycott movement will continue.
He also accused the governor of «demonizing»
teachers and «moving down the wrong path»
on standardized testing, though Cuomo has recently done an about - face
on that issue, most notably calling — through his latest
reform task force — for a moratorium
on linking test results and
teacher performance
evaluations.
ALBANY — The final budget bill containing education funding and policy, introduced
on Tuesday afternoon, included modified versions of many of Governor Andrew Cuomo's original
reform proposals, including an overhauled
teacher evaluation system.
Cuomo took an aggressive position during his budget and policy address Wednesday, threatening to withhold a significant funding increase for schools if lawmakers don't approve his controversial
reform proposals, such as an amendment to the state's
teacher -
evaluation system that would increase the ratings» reliance
on standardized testing.
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Contact: Chandra M. Hayslett, Communications Director
[email protected] 212-257-4350 New Yorkers Overwhelmingly Want Deal
on New
Teacher Evaluation System New Poll Shows Robust and Resilient Support; No Excuse Seen for Losing $ 300 million New York (Nov. 29, 2012)-- A new teacher evaluation system that would ensure that New York City received $ 300 million in additional State education funding enjoys overwhelming support among City voters in general and parents in particular, according to a new poll released today by StudentsFirstNY, the education reform advocacy group, and conducted by Anzalone Liszt Re
Teacher Evaluation System New Poll Shows Robust and Resilient Support; No Excuse Seen for Losing $ 300 million New York (Nov. 29, 2012)-- A new teacher evaluation system that would ensure that New York City received $ 300 million in additional State education funding enjoys overwhelming support among City voters in general and parents in particular, according to a new poll released today by StudentsFirstNY, the education reform advocacy group, and conducted by Anzalone Liszt
Evaluation System New Poll Shows Robust and Resilient Support; No Excuse Seen for Losing $ 300 million New York (Nov. 29, 2012)-- A new
teacher evaluation system that would ensure that New York City received $ 300 million in additional State education funding enjoys overwhelming support among City voters in general and parents in particular, according to a new poll released today by StudentsFirstNY, the education reform advocacy group, and conducted by Anzalone Liszt Re
teacher evaluation system that would ensure that New York City received $ 300 million in additional State education funding enjoys overwhelming support among City voters in general and parents in particular, according to a new poll released today by StudentsFirstNY, the education reform advocacy group, and conducted by Anzalone Liszt
evaluation system that would ensure that New York City received $ 300 million in additional State education funding enjoys overwhelming support among City voters in general and parents in particular, according to a new poll released today by StudentsFirstNY, the education
reform advocacy group, and conducted by Anzalone Liszt Research.
«While there's still more to do this session
on charters and the education investment tax credit, and more to ensure every child has access to great schools, Governor Cuomo fought hard to make meaningful
reforms to tenure, arbitration policies and
teacher evaluation criteria and his vision and hard work paid off.»
On Thursday, with the New York State Board of Regents hearing testimony regarding the newly approved
teacher evaluation system, leading education
reform organization StudentsFirstNY and public school parents offered recommendations and sent letters calling for a system that ensures all public school students have access to high - quality
teachers.
Cuomo
on Wednesday is also expected to outline an aggressive education
reform agenda that will include a push for more charter schools and additional funding for them, tougher
teacher evaluation standards, and money for
teacher incentives.
For a long time, one of the signature elements of Mr. Cuomo's education -
reform agenda had been tying
teacher evaluations to the test scores students received
on state exams.
Making
teacher evaluations more dependent
on test scores,
reforming tenure and adding charter schools in the city were all priorities of StudentsFirstNY and became significant pieces of the governor's agenda for the 2015 legislative session, which he announced in his State of the State speech
on Jan. 21.
At Tuesday's meeting, Pryor and his staff reported
on progress made in key
reform areas, including a new
teacher evaluation system and a new set of academic goals called the Common Core State Standards.
Beyond probationary periods, certification requirements and
evaluations, education
reform leaders are looking to take
on larger long - term sticking points between their groups and New York's city and state
teachers» union, including merit pay.
From there Cuomo went
on to call for «major
reform in two areas»:
teacher evaluation and management efficiency.»
The foundation long backed controversial education
reforms, including retooling
teacher evaluation and compensation systems based in part
on student test scores and creating smaller schools.
In his State of the State address
on Jan. 21, Governor Andrew Cuomo tied $ 1.1 billion in additional state education aid to the passage of his «
reform» proposals in the state budget: individual merit pay, more charter schools, punishing struggling schools, and making
teacher evaluation hinge
on state test scores.
For years, Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo took a hard - line approach to
reforming New York's schools, calling
on the state to mandate rigorous
evaluations for
teachers and to turn schools that fail to meet certain standards over to an outside receiver to operate.
We've heard a lot about the new
teacher evaluation plan, school aid and ethics
reforms but this week
on New York NOW we'll take a look at what a small fraction of the $ 142 billion spending plan is helping create - a logger training program.
Magee has become central to the statewide effort to battle
reforms such as standardized testing,
teacher evaluations based
on test scores and penalties for schools that do not meet certain standards.
Included among the proposed
reforms is a
teacher evaluation system based half
on student test scores, an increase in the length of time before a
teacher is eligible for tenure and allowing the state to take over failing schools and districts.
Commissioner Elia and the Board of Regents are revising the
teacher and principal
evaluations for the fifth time since 2010, and Pallotta, with NYSUT, says there's a lot riding
on the
reforms, including whether the test boycott movement will continue.
They give a higher
evaluation to private schools than to public ones in their local community, but opposition to market - oriented school -
reform proposals such as performance pay for
teachers and school vouchers seems to be
on the rise.
Five - year
evaluation study
on the effectiveness of A + arts - integrated school
reform strategies in Oklahoma schools, based
on a survey of students,
teachers, and professional - development faculty.
Most of the new data show that a great majority of
teachers score just as highly
on the new
evaluations as they did
on the previous ones, and it is unclear whether the
reforms have systematically — or broadly — led to
teachers to receiving better feedback that is translating to better teaching.
To be sure, mistakes were made: Not understanding the limitations or unintended consequences of federal leadership
on education; a disastrous, ill - timed excursion into
teacher evaluation reform; a technocratic impulse that was insufficiently sensitive to parents» concerns about issues like student privacy; and
on and
on.
Among the
reform milestones they achieved were a new requirement that 40 percent of a
teacher's
evaluation be based
on student achievement; raising the charter school cap from 200 to 460; and higher student achievement goals
on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) 4th grade and 8th grade reading tests and Regents exams.
One interpretation of the emphasis
on developing the common core curriculum is that these debates provide a convenient diversion from potentially more intractable fights over bigger
reform ideas like using improved
teacher evaluations for personnel decisions, expanded school choice, or enhanced accountability systems.
Moreover, summative assessment sat at the core of many of the policy
reforms that the leaders described: additional accountability levers such as
teacher evaluation systems and statewide school report cards draw
on data coming out of these summative tests to make determinations and comparisons regarding
teacher and school - level performance.
On issue after issue — from school vouchers, to
teacher evaluations, to collective bargaining
reform, to school finance
reform — Indiana is leading the way.
But it's also increasingly clear that the new generation of
teacher evaluations have the potential to strengthen instruction, make teaching more attractive work, and raise student achievement
on a wide scale — if states and school districts stay the course
on reform.
«School
reform» has taken
on a very particular meaning in the past decade: reformers are those who support things like charter schooling, accountability, test - based
teacher evaluation, and the Common Core.
Mostly this new ESEA is a rollback of No Child Left Behind, with a few
reform - minded elements (
on teacher evaluations, charter schools) thrown in for good measure.
When they insist that ideas like school choice, performance pay, and
teacher evaluations based
on value - added measures will themselves boost student achievement, would - be reformers stifle creativity, encourage their allies to lock elbows and march forward rather than engage in useful debate and reflection, turn every
reform proposal into an us - against - them steel - cage match, and push researchers into the awkward position of studying whether
reforms «work» rather than when, why, and how they make it easier to improve schooling.
Recent school
reform talk has focused importantly
on teacher evaluations and
on using
evaluations for personnel decisions — both positive and negative.
How widespread is
teacher opposition to rigorous
teacher evaluations, school accountability,
teacher pension
reform, merit pay, charter schools, school vouchers, and other items
on the
reform agenda?
«Clearly, there is a great need for rigorous
evaluation research, which should focus both
on the impact of school discipline
reforms and
on their potential unintended consequences,» the authors note, emphasizing that reducing suspensions is a starting point in effective school discipline
reform but that changing school culture can have «spillover» effects
on teachers and peers which raise important questions for further study.
In an analysis of the program, political scientist William Howell wrote that RttT encouraged applicants to develop «common core state standards,» design a
teacher evaluation plan based in part
on the performance of their students, ensure «successful conditions for high - performing charter schools,» and numerous other
reforms (see «Results of President Obama's Race to the Top,» research, Fall 2015).
It explains reformers» enthusiasm for test - based accountability; for «college and career - ready standards»; for
teacher evaluations based, in significant part,
on student outcomes; for «data - based instruction»; and for much of the rest of the modern - day
reform agenda.
Common Core,
teacher -
evaluation reform, new CBAs, technology, schools within schools — the list goes
on endlessly — all of these do nothing to alter the urban district's role as dominant - default school operator.
Also in this issue: A look back at what the Obama administration's signature education
reform got wrong, with lessons learned to guide states and districts in refining their
teacher evaluation systems, and a warning
on the limits of federally - led school
reform; a proposal for how to redesign education research under the Every Student Succeeds Act; and a debate
on whether there is a federal constitutional right to education.
If the extension makes it into the final spending bills for fiscal year 2011, advocates say, that could mean more states will take the
reform - minded steps emphasized in the Race to the Top program, such as revamping their
teacher -
evaluation systems and lifting caps
on charter schools, in order to get a slice of the competitive grants.
The seminar — promoted through a collaboration between HGSE and the Center for Public Policy and Educational
Evaluation (Centro de Políticas Públicas e Avaliação da Educação, or CAEd) of the Federal University of Juiz de Fora in Brazil — focused
on education
reform, specifically U.S. efforts to develop 21st - century skills through
teacher education, leadership development, and the definition of standards for
teachers and school leaders.