The new policy would have eventually based teachers» salaries in part on evaluations by the principal and a number
of outside evaluators hired by the district.
The next step in the process is
for outside evaluators to examine the applications, who will then notify the authorizing board on July 11.
The TDST was developed and field tested
by outside evaluators on the staff of the International Society of Technology Educators during the first year of the project.
U.F.T. president Michael Mulgrew complained that there are few details about the plan, including what kind of
training outside evaluators will receive.
A divided state Board of Regents on Sept. 16 proposed three changes to the state evaluation system aimed at making the process fairer: an appeals process to address aberrations in growth scores, ensuring that privacy protections to bar the release to the public of individual teachers» growth scores will remain in force and the creation of a hardship waiver for school districts who find it difficult to
hire outside evaluators.
The United Federation of Teachers, which represents most of the teachers in New York City public schools, has come out strongly against the
proposed outside evaluator piece.
The United Federation of Teachers, the teachers union in New York City, has come out strongly against the proposed
outside evaluator piece.
Gov. Andrew Cuomo's teacher evaluation overhaul that would rely
on outside evaluators is just «another way to privatize education,» Chancellor Carmen Fariña said Tuesday.
Cuomo officials note that the governor secured some reform wins in 2015, including deals that made it more difficult for teachers to be rated «highly effective,» a requirement that
outside evaluators assess teachers along with their principals, and a stricter timeline for failing schools to improve.
Many police departments get what amounts to a stamp of approval
from outside evaluators that review, advise and ultimately accredit them as adhering to best practices.
Fariña was specifically criticizing a proposal that would
require outside evaluators to weigh in on teacher performance, although they would not necessarily have to come from the private sector.
My challenge is to deal
with outside evaluators that always recommend Wilson as if it is the answer to all reading problems.
UFT President Michael Mulgrew complained that there are few details about the plan, including what kind of
training outside evaluators will receive.
As reported last week by Investigative Post, accreditation
by outside evaluators is a long - ignored requirement of the City Charter.
But whether the use
of outside evaluators — or any particular approach to evaluating teachers — improves teaching in the long run remains an open question.
Of course, if you have reason to believe this is not the case, obtaining
an outside evaluator may be your only recourse.
The chancellor said
outside evaluators would lack a complete enough picture of a teacher to make a fair judgment.
«I absolutely believe that holding teachers accountable only on test scores and
outside evaluators is not a good idea,» Fariña said.
The measures of teacher practice component of a teacher's evaluation, going forward, must be a combination of a principal's observation and
an outside evaluator's.
Teacher observations for evaluations should be conducted by three people: the principal, another teacher in the building, and
an outside evaluator, she said.
Candidates earn their jobs either in an open competition or by going through a review by
an outside evaluator.
Outside evaluators, too, may be chosen from the ranks of scientists working within traditional disciplines.
In the year 2000, the NatureMapping program utilized
an outside evaluator to appraise its program, assessing multiple grade levels and schools and studying the effects of the program on its student participants, their schools, and their communities.
«We have fairs where we invite other classes to come in and be
the outside evaluators for the younger kids.
As a content expert,
an outside evaluator can provide feedback on the items outside of your content area such as online tools to use, best practices in online teaching, how to build communities in your classroom, presenting new material, providing guidance, etc..
Of that total share, the principals» observations would count for just 15 percent, compared to 35 percent for
the outside evaluators» observations.
«If
an outside evaluator comes in and says, «This is the problem,» and the principal says, «No, this is the problem,» who does the teacher pay attention to?»
«If we're able to train
outside evaluators that can point out strengths and weaknesses and help teachers move forward, I'd be willing to talk about that,» he said.
Principals were frustrated that they would no longer have the right to decide which teachers remain and which are fired from their schools — test scores and
the outside evaluators» opinion would matter significantly more.
But in New York, it is unclear whether or not additional training will be offered to teachers by
outside evaluators.
Thomas admits that the district didn't do enough to inform teachers about the role of
the outside evaluators, a concern echoed in criticisms of the New York plan.
There is an alternative to
outside evaluators that tends to get more teacher support.
But in the version of the state budget that passed on March 31, no mention is made of how principals» and
outside evaluators» observations will be weighted, though both are mandatory.
Supovitz, MacGowan, and Slattery (1997) compared the ratings given by Rochester classroom teachers and
outside evaluators.
Principals were frustrated that they would no longer have the right to decide which teachers remain and which are fired from their schools — test scores and
an outside evaluator's opinion would matter significantly more.
Of that total share, the principal's observations would count for just 15 percent, compared to 35 percent for
the outside evaluator's observations.
DOA spokesman Cullen Werwie said the bidding process included an evaluation team selected by DPI, and was made up of four DPI officials and an «
outside evaluator.»
While city officials do not yet have a projected cost,
these outside evaluators are expected to be the largest expense of the new evaluation system.
She is being removed her from my «program» to Wilson because
an outside evaluator said that is what she needs.
This is especially true when parents will not permit
the outside evaluator to collect observational information from teachers or school psychologists.
Having a diagnosis can make a big difference so parents need to go to
an outside evaluator.
However, the last part of what the teacher wrote says that, «
an outside evaluator» said that the student needs Wilson.
Sad thing is that
the outside evaluators recommendations are almost always followed and they Do not have a reading background and barely know the student.
Over a period of several weeks, teams, with or without the help of
an outside evaluator / consultant, review evidence to determine current level of implementation and plan for the future.