The case was closely watched across the country as teachers unions and educational reform groups have battled
over teacher tenure.
The teacher regulations have so far received a more tepid response, a little surprising given the rancor
over teacher tenure over the past year.
Well, a group of California students took the state to court
over teacher tenure.
I am saddened that my efforts researching and negotiating the work of public education seem meaningless in the face of current policy debates — and that last year's nationwide struggle
over teacher tenure or this week's «debates» over teacher evaluation in New York arrive forcefully, demanding immediate reaction rather than initiative from educators.
The other thing that's an obvious connection here is thinking about the recent debate
over teacher tenure policy which has been in the courts.
Not exact matches
, its speech codes, its
teacher evaluations conducted sub secreto pontificio, its heated debate
over the minutest matters, its hair - splitting fights
over teaching loads and research assistants (
tenure as benefice!)
Background: Of the roughly 138,000 public school
teachers outside of New York City, 316
tenured teachers faced disciplinary charges
over two years, 2012 - 13 and 2013 - 14, according to the state Education Department.
Mr. Cuomo had declared he would boost education funding by just
over $ 1 billion only if the legislature agreed to adopt his reform plans — which included state receivership of failing schools, an increase in the charter cap, new
teacher evaluations based on state exams, and changes to
teacher tenure.
This year's state exams, which third through eighth graders will begin taking this week, immediately follow a bitter battle between Cuomo and
teachers» unions
over evaluations as well as
tenure, merit pay and turnaround strategies for chronically underperforming schools.
After last week's Vergara v. California ruling, New York's
teachers unions and education reform groups are preparing to battle
over expected legal action seeking to change the state's
tenure laws.
Since he made those comments during an interview with the Daily News editorial board, Cuomo has reiterated his intentions to battle unions
over education reforms, most recently with a letter he sent to state education officials outlining what appeared to be his second - term schools agenda, including questions about firing
teachers, extending the probationary period before
tenure and boosting the charter school sector.
Cuomo and the
teacher unions have been at war
over the governor's proposed education - reform package that would revamp the
teacher tenure and evaluation programs, make it easier to fire bad and lecherous instructors, and expand charter schools.
Included among the proposed reforms is a
teacher evaluation system based half on student test scores, an increase in the length of time before a
teacher is eligible for
tenure and allowing the state to take
over failing schools and districts.
For many purposes, such as
tenure or retention decisions, it is not the «year to year» correlation that matters, but the «year - to - career» — that is, the degree to which a single year's value - added measure would provide information about a
teacher's likely impact on students
over their future careers.
Asked about their support for «giving
tenure to
teachers,» just 33 % express a positive view and 49 % are opposed — but this reflects a jump in support for
tenure of 5 percentage points
over the past year.
Elite
tenure, for the top 10 — 25 %, would confer status to the deserving, open doors to paid instructional career opportunities, and give power
over future decisions to top
teachers who would be motivated to maintain a high standard.
The average
tenure of
teachers at Partnership Schools is more than ten years,
over four times that of some the larger charter management organizations in the city.
The discussions about the future of
teacher evaluation and
teacher tenure are going to pick up speed all
over the country and the origins are going to turn out to be in Race to the Top....
Back home in East Los Angeles, the
teachers associations would spend
over $ 1 million during his six - year
tenure in Sacramento to ensure that Villaraigosa would be reelected.
In April, the California Court of Appeal overturned the trial court's ruling in Vergara v. California [i], in which a group of families had challenged the constitutionality of state laws governing
teacher tenure [ii](California state law automatically grants
tenure to
teachers after sixteen months, provides extra due process protections to
teachers over and above those available to other state workers, and requires schools to use seniority rather than competency in layoff decisions.)
Even more striking, the number of states requiring districts to consider
teacher evaluations in
tenure decisions grew from 0 to 23
over that same period.
As reported elsewhere, the survey asked about school spending, charters, vouchers,
teacher unions, bilingual education, digital learning, state take -
overs of troubled district schools,
teacher unions, merit pay,
teacher tenure, and many other matters.
The researchers elaborate, explaining, «Evaluation reforms appear to result in a steady decline in new labor supply
over time whereas
tenure reforms result in a sharp and immediate contraction in the supply of new
teachers that then slowly rebounds.»
A veteran
teacher with
tenure receives preferential treatment
over newer
teachers in school assignments and with respect to layoffs and dismissal procedures.
(California state law automatically grants
tenure to
teachers after sixteen months, provides extra due process protections to
teachers over and above those available to other state workers, and requires schools to use seniority rather than competency in layoff decisions.)
Her
tenure was marked by consecutive years of enrollment growth, an increase in graduation rates, improvements in student satisfaction and
teacher retention, increases in AP participation and pass rates, and the greatest growth of any urban district on the National Assessment of Education Progress (NAEP)
over multiple years.
While state governments have had a heavy hand in
teacher preparation, licensure, and certification policy for over a century (American Association of Colleges of Teacher Education, 1990; Hawley, 1990), states have traditionally delegated teacher tenure and evaluation policy to localities, often in conjunction with local collective bargaining units (Ballou, 2000; Cohen - Vogel & Osborne - Lampkin, 2007; Hannaway & Rotherham, 2006; Hungerford & Blom, 2014; Strunk,
teacher preparation, licensure, and certification policy for
over a century (American Association of Colleges of
Teacher Education, 1990; Hawley, 1990), states have traditionally delegated teacher tenure and evaluation policy to localities, often in conjunction with local collective bargaining units (Ballou, 2000; Cohen - Vogel & Osborne - Lampkin, 2007; Hannaway & Rotherham, 2006; Hungerford & Blom, 2014; Strunk,
Teacher Education, 1990; Hawley, 1990), states have traditionally delegated
teacher tenure and evaluation policy to localities, often in conjunction with local collective bargaining units (Ballou, 2000; Cohen - Vogel & Osborne - Lampkin, 2007; Hannaway & Rotherham, 2006; Hungerford & Blom, 2014; Strunk,
teacher tenure and evaluation policy to localities, often in conjunction with local collective bargaining units (Ballou, 2000; Cohen - Vogel & Osborne - Lampkin, 2007; Hannaway & Rotherham, 2006; Hungerford & Blom, 2014; Strunk, 2012).
Even in cases where a principal «s
tenure extends
over a period of several years,
teachers may remain alienated when principal turnover is the result of a district leadership rotation policy.208 Teachers may become cynical and resistant to change because of the «revolving door syndrome» — the uncertainty and instability turnover causes, and the perception of the new leader as a «servant to the
teachers may remain alienated when principal turnover is the result of a district leadership rotation policy.208
Teachers may become cynical and resistant to change because of the «revolving door syndrome» — the uncertainty and instability turnover causes, and the perception of the new leader as a «servant to the
Teachers may become cynical and resistant to change because of the «revolving door syndrome» — the uncertainty and instability turnover causes, and the perception of the new leader as a «servant to the system.
According to the last set of federal and state campaign finance reports, Governor Malloy, the champion of the corporate education reform industry and the only Democratic governor in the nation to propose doing away with
teacher tenure and repealing collective bargaining for
teachers working in the poorest schools has received well
over a quarter of a million dollars from leaders and political action committees associated with the national education reform and privatization effort.
While denial of
tenure increased from two percent in 2008 to just three percent in 2012,
teachers whose probationary period was extended rose from less than 5 percent to
over 40 percent of
teachers.
The reforms Rhee implemented — stringent
teacher evaluations, a heavy emphasis on test scores, dismissals of ineffective
teachers — have continued largely apace since Henderson took
over, without the sturm und drang that accompanied Rhee's
tenure.
But meanwhile, in most of
tenure cases so far under the new law, the arguments have been
over typically either individual incidents of alleged misconduct or longer patterns of
teachers failing to improve their practices.
Hiring one
teacher over another, granting
tenure or not, selecting instructional leaders — these are important decisions that affect both educators and students.
A review of 212 settlement agreements and 773
tenure misconduct hearing opinions
over a span of six years details how ineffective and harmful
teachers are able to game the system to keep their jobs.
For our part, we're tired of seeing
teachers cast as scapegoats, of all the carping
over unions and
tenure.
The 2009 publication The Widget Effect (Weisberg, Sexton, Mulhern, & Keeling, 2009), a study of
teacher evaluation practices in 12 diverse districts in four states, found that
over 99 % of
tenured teachers in districts using a satisfactory or unsatisfactory rating system earned a positive rating.
While Republicans are aiming to weaken
teachers unions through such policies as private - school vouchers and legal battles
over dues collection, the unions are colliding with Democrats who are challenging bedrock labor rights, such as seniority and
teacher tenure.
Much of the public debate
over tenure has focused on whether it is possible to fire
tenured teachers who are no longer making the grade.
She faces court cases challenging
teacher tenure and job protections, the defection of historically loyal Democrats, growing apprehension
over the Common Core, diminishing ranks, public relations campaigns painting her union as greedy and a complicated chessboard of state and local members with a variety of interests.
Similar legislation emphasizing
teacher performance
over job security is pending in Louisiana and Minnesota, and bills overhauling
tenure protections and / or evaluation systems have already passed in Maryland, Connecticut, Washington, Tennessee and Michigan.
After three and half years, much of it mired in controversy
over technology missteps like the rollout of a $ 1.3 billion iPad program and a court case that struck down
teacher tenure laws in California, the schools chief and the board have agreed to part ways.
An award - winning study of Illinois school districts
over an 18 - year period found an average of two
tenured teachers out of 95,000 were dismissed for underperformance each year.
Governor Dan Malloy used that quote to reiterate why the state should terminate
tenure, shift to a
teacher evaluation system that relies more heavily on standardized test scores and create something called the «Commissioner's Network» in which the state would take
over 25 schools, fire the
teachers, ban collective bargaining and turn the schools
over to a third - party.
Over the last four years, the school board has denied
tenure to an average of 35
teachers annually.
In an interview last week, the 32 - year - old Marrocco talked about her path to excellence, a climb marked by a few stepping stones that are often overlooked in debates
over teacher evaluation,
tenure, and test scores.
During Beate's
tenure as Superintendent of Curriculum and Instructional Services, the department she led served
over 200 schools and 9,000
teachers through their work with Area Superintendents, area Learning Networks and their work with new
teachers, and
teachers seeking individual support.
Being touted as the suit that could «reignite the battle
over union protections for Minnesota
teachers» by local publications such as the Star Tribune, this suit is being modeled after recent landmark cases in New York and California that seek to chip away outdated
tenure provisions that many reformers contend degrade the professionalism of educators and hurt students.
Looming
over her: Court cases testing
teacher tenure, declining membership and the defection of historically loyal Democrats and the Common Core cacophony.
It was thus with No Child Left Behind, Massachusetts» landmark 1993 Education Reform law, and the reforms of Mayor Michael Bloomberg, during whose
tenure «
teacher salaries rose
over 40 percent».
We achieved this sign - on rate even though all participating LEAs will have to implement a bold set of policy and practice changes, including using student growth as one of multiple measures in evaluating and compensating
teachers and leaders; denying
tenure to
teachers who are deemed ineffective as gauged partly by student growth; relinquishing control
over their persistently lowest - achieving schools; increasing the number of students who are taught by effective
teachers; and, in many cases, opening their doors to more charter schools.