(1) there is established scientific concern
over warming of the climate system based upon evidence from observations of increases in global average air and ocean temperatures, widespread melting of snow and ice, and rising global average sea level;
Not exact matches
The recent slowdown in global
warming has brought into question the reliability
of climate model projections
of future temperature change and has led to a vigorous debate
over whether this slowdown is the result
of naturally occurring, internal variability or forcing external to Earth's
climate system.
New research published in Geophysical Research Letters by University
of Melbourne scientists at the ARC Centre
of Excellence for
Climate System Science shows that a positive IPO would likely produce a sharp acceleration in global
warming over the next decade.
A few
of the main points
of the third assessment report issued in 2001 include: An increasing body
of observations gives a collective picture
of a
warming world and other changes in the
climate system; emissions
of greenhouse gases and aerosols due to human activities continue to alter the atmosphere in ways that are expected to affect the
climate; confidence in the ability
of models to project future
climate has increased; and there is new and stronger evidence that most
of the
warming observed
over the last 50 years is attributable to human activities.
Using 19
climate models, a team
of researchers led by Professor Minghua Zhang
of the School
of Marine and Atmospheric Sciences at Stony Brook University, discovered persistent dry and
warm biases
of simulated
climate over the region
of the Southern Great Plain in the central U.S. that was caused by poor modeling
of atmospheric convective
systems — the vertical transport
of heat and moisture in the atmosphere.
Warming of the
climate system is unequivocal, and since the 1950s, many
of the observed changes are unprecedented
over decades to millennia.
Of course, this contrasts sharply with other forecasts of the climate system; the purple line roughly indicates the model - based forecast of Smith et al. (2007), suggesting with a warming of roughly 0.3 deg C over the 2005 - 2015 perio
Of course, this contrasts sharply with other forecasts
of the climate system; the purple line roughly indicates the model - based forecast of Smith et al. (2007), suggesting with a warming of roughly 0.3 deg C over the 2005 - 2015 perio
of the
climate system; the purple line roughly indicates the model - based forecast
of Smith et al. (2007), suggesting with a warming of roughly 0.3 deg C over the 2005 - 2015 perio
of Smith et al. (2007), suggesting with a
warming of roughly 0.3 deg C over the 2005 - 2015 perio
of roughly 0.3 deg C
over the 2005 - 2015 period.
Such large variations
of the
climate likely won't occur every year
over the next few decades given the limited global
warming to date, but it would seem likely such conditions will occur more and more frequently as global
warming continues, disrupting both social
systems and ecosystems.
There is also a natural variability
of the
climate system (about a zero reference point) that produces El Nino and La Nina effects arising from changes in ocean circulation patterns that can make the global temperature increase or decrease,
over and above the global
warming due to CO2.
An interdisciplinary team
of researchers say they have found «missing heat» in the
climate system, casting doubt on suggestions that global
warming has slowed or stopped
over the past decade.
The conclusion that greenhouse
warming dominates
over solar
warming is supported further by a detection and attribution analysis using 13 models from the MMD at PCMDI (Stone et al., 2007a) and an analysis
of the National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR) Community
Climate System Model (CCSM1.4; Stone et al., 2007b).
But because
of the inertia
of the
climate system, any
warming will take place
over many decades.
First, Happer mentions statistical significance, but global surface temperature trends are rarely if ever statistically significant (at a 95 % confidence level)
over periods as short as a decade, even in the presence
of an underlying long - term
warming trend, because
of the natural variability and noise in the
climate system.
It is possible that Earth
warms so much that it reaches what is called a «tipping point,» where the global
climate system is seriously and permanently disrupted — like when a glass
of water has been tipped
over and the water can not realistically be put back into the glass.
We've only had 0.8 C
warming since humanity started burning fossil fuels and we're already committed
over the next 100 years to another 0.6 C
warming with what's already in the atmosphere because
of the huge time lags in the
climate system.
``...
warming of the
climate system is unequivocal... most
of the global average
warming over the past 50 years is very likely due to anthropogenic greenhouse gases increases...» — Rajendra Pachauri, Chairman
of the IPCC, Nobel Prize acceptance speech, Dec. 10, 2007
J. T. Fasullo, R. S. Nerem & B. Hamlington Scientific Reports 6, Article number: 31245 (2016) doi: 10.1038 / srep31245 Download Citation
Climate and Earth system modellingProjection and prediction Received: 13 April 2016 Accepted: 15 July 2016 Published online: 10 August 2016 Erratum: 10 November 2016 Updated online 10 November 2016 Abstract Global mean sea level rise estimated from satellite altimetry provides a strong constraint on climate variability and change and is expected to accelerate as the rates of both ocean warming and cryospheric mass loss increase ove
Climate and Earth
system modellingProjection and prediction Received: 13 April 2016 Accepted: 15 July 2016 Published online: 10 August 2016 Erratum: 10 November 2016 Updated online 10 November 2016 Abstract Global mean sea level rise estimated from satellite altimetry provides a strong constraint on
climate variability and change and is expected to accelerate as the rates of both ocean warming and cryospheric mass loss increase ove
climate variability and change and is expected to accelerate as the rates
of both ocean
warming and cryospheric mass loss increase
over time.
Assuming a good bit
of this was added after the natural
warming cycle was started we are probably looking at closer to 1200 ppm
over the next century or two before C02 levels begin to decrease again as this natural green house locks up carbon primarily in phytoplankton blooms caused by fertilization from the new large desert regions near the equator and excessive erosion from very intense storm
systems the develop in such a hot house
climate.
But the rate
of global surface
warming can fluctuate due to natural variations in the
climate system over periods
of a decade or so.»
and
of course «If the role
of internal variability in the
climate system is as large as this analysis would seem to suggest,
warming over the 21st century may well be larger than that predicted by the current generation
of models, given the propensity
of those models to underestimate
climate internal variability»
In recent decades, much research on these topics has raised the questions
of «tipping points» and «
system flips,» where feedbacks in the
system compound to rapidly cause massive reorganization
of global
climate over very short periods
of time — a truncation or reorganization
of the thermohaline circulation or
of food web structures, for instance, caused by the loss
of sea ice or
warming ocean temperatures.
In doing so we see that even though El Niños
over the past 60 years or more remove a bit
of energy each time, the longer term trend is net
warming and expansion
of this major reservoir
of energy in the
climate system.
This time period is too short to signify a change in the
warming trend, as
climate trends are measured
over periods
of decades, not years.12, 29,30,31,32 Such decade - long slowdowns or even reversals in trend have occurred before in the global instrumental record (for example, 1900 - 1910 and 1940 - 1950; see Figure 2.2), including three decade - long periods since 1970, each followed by a sharp temperature rise.33 Nonetheless, satellite and ocean observations indicate that the Earth - atmosphere
climate system has continued to gain heat energy.34
Over the past 50 years, the oceans have absorbed about 90 %
of the total heat added to the
climate system while the rest goes to melting sea and land ice, and
warming the land surface and atmosphere.
Since to me (and many scientists, although some wanted a lot more corroborative evidence, which they've also gotten) it makes absolutely no sense to presume that the earth would just go about its merry way and keep the
climate nice and relatively stable for us (though this rare actual
climate scientist pseudo skeptic seems to think it would, based upon some non scientific belief — see second half
of this piece), when the earth changes
climate easily as it is,
climate is ultimately an expression
of energy, it is stabilized (right now) by the oceans and ice sheets, and increasing the number
of long term thermal radiation / heat energy absorbing and re radiating molecules to levels not seen on earth in several million years would add an enormous influx
of energy to the lower atmosphere earth
system, which would mildly
warm the air and increasingly transfer energy to the earth
over time, which in turn would start to alter those stabilizing
systems (and which, with increasing ocean energy retention and accelerating polar ice sheet melting at both ends
of the globe, is exactly what we've been seeing) and start to reinforce the same process until a new stases would be reached well after the atmospheric levels
of ghg has stabilized.
The
climate is a messy
system and traditional attribution looking for the reasons for a
warming of several tenths
of a degree
over a century can only reach the conclusion that it is «very likely», what chance, consequently, does anyone have to confidently attribute changes
of a hundredth
of a degree
over a decade?
«TCR was originally defined as the
warming at the time
of CO2 doubling (i.e., after 70 years) in a 1 % yr — 1 increasing CO2 experiment (see Hegerl et al., 2007b), but like ECS, it can also be thought
of as a generic property
of the
climate system that determines the global temperature response ΔT to any gradual increase in RF, ΔF, taking place
over an approximately 70 - year time scale, normalized by the ratio
of the forcing change to the forcing due to doubling CO2, F2 × CO2: TCR = F2 × CO2 ΔT / ΔF»
When the
warming of the Earth's entire
climate system is considered, global
warming continues to rise at a rate equivalent to about 4 Hiroshima atomic bomb detonations per second, faster
over the past 15 years than the prior 15 years.
«When compared to the observed response
of the
climate system, the computer simulations all have forecast
warming trends much steeper
over the last several decades than measured.
If the role
of internal variability in the
climate system is as large as this analysis would seem to suggest,
warming over the 21st century may well be larger than that predicted by the current generation
of models, given the propensity
of those models to underestimate
climate internal variability.
If the role
of internal variability in the
climate system is as large as this analysis would seem to suggest,
warming over the 21st century may well be larger than that predicted by the current generation
of models, given the propensity
of those models to underestimate
climate internal variability [Kravtsov and Spannagle, 2008].»
Using the University
of Victoria Earth
System Climate Model adapted to include a permafrost response module, the researchers calculated the contribution to climate warming of thawing permafrost over a range of varying para
Climate Model adapted to include a permafrost response module, the researchers calculated the contribution to
climate warming of thawing permafrost over a range of varying para
climate warming of thawing permafrost
over a range
of varying parameters.
This year's late winter heat wave
over much
of the United States, dubbed «March Madness,» has been cited as evidence that human - induced global
warming is causing the
climate system to stray far outside its normal range
of variability.
«The assessment is supported additionally by a complementary analysis in which the parameters
of an Earth
System Model
of Intermediate Complexity (EMIC) were constrained using observations
of near - surface temperature and ocean heat content, as well as prior information on the magnitudes
of forcings, and which concluded that GHGs have caused 0.6 °C to 1.1 °C (5 to 95 % uncertainty)
warming since the mid-20th century (Huber and Knutti, 2011); an analysis by Wigley and Santer (2013), who used an energy balance model and RF and
climate sensitivity estimates from AR4, and they concluded that there was about a 93 % chance that GHGs caused a
warming greater than observed
over the 1950 — 2005 period; and earlier detection and attribution studies assessed in the AR4 (Hegerl et al., 2007b).»
Scientists at IITM's Centre for
Climate Change and Research R K Madhura, R Krishnan, Jayashree Revadekar, M Mujumdar and B N Goswami published their paper, «Changes in western disturbances
over western Himalayas in a
warming environment» which talks
of the increasing frequency
of WDs — a low pressure
system originating
over the eastern Mediterranean sea and moves eastward.
The basic physics knowledge
of the greenhouse effect have been examined since 1824 beginning with Joseph Fourier, the hypothesis that we should
warm with continued CO2 emissions has been around for more than a hundred years, the general confirmations and realization that this will develop into a global problem have been germinating for
over 50 years, and in the last three decades the knowledge that the
warming we will experience will affect our
climate and agricultural
systems is well known.
Using datasets
of actual temperatures recorded by the NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies (NASA GISS), the United Kingdom's Hadley Centre for
Climate Prediction and Research at the University
of East Anglia (Hadley - CRU), the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), satellites measuring atmospheric and deep oceanic temperatures, and a remote sensor
system in California, Christy found that «all show a lack
of warming over the past 17 years.»
The predominant summary statements from the TAR WGI strengthened the SAR's attribution statement: «An increasing body
of observations gives a collective picture
of a
warming world and other changes in the
climate system», and «There is new and stronger evidence that most
of the
warming observed
over the last 50 years is attributable to human activities.»
The 5AR's «Summary for Policymakers,» released last week, acknowledged that «the rate
of warming over the past 15 years... is smaller than the rate calculated since 1951,» before concluding that «
warming of the
climate system is unequivocal.»
The non-linearities are emergent properties
of the complex interconnectivity
of the many parts
of the earth
climate system — The presence and amplitude
of El Nino changes the rainfall in the southeastern US, which affects evapotranspiration and cloudiness
over the
warm parts
of the Atlantic, which affects the amount
of sensible and latent heat which goes into the atmosphere, which the prevailing winds carry to Great Britain, and so on through a chain
of events which eventually influence the barometric pressure differences between the Eastern and Western Pacific which drive the ENSO.
They will continue to accumulate in the atmosphere
over the next years and possibly even decades, which together with the inertia
of the
climate system will support further
warming.