While the longtime critic of the Office for People with Developmental Disabilities late last year won a federal lawsuit affirming his right to criticize the agency he works for, lawyers for the state are seeking to
overturn that jury verdict.
Abbott's motion to
overturn the jury verdict was denied in March 2013.
The New Jersey Supreme Court reversed and remanded Borough of Harvey Cedars v. Harvey Karan and Phyllis Karan, thereby
overturning a jury verdict, trial court and appellate decisions that awarded the Karans $ 375,000 for the taking of a beach replenishment easement and damages to the remainder.
Hughes Hubbard successfully defended the City of New York and an NYPD detective against an appeal by a woman seeking to
overturn a jury verdict and summary judgment dismissing her civil rights claims of false arrest and malicious prosecution.
CAVEAT: These reasons are necessary, but not sufficient reasons to
overturn a jury verdict for reasons # 1, # 2 or # 3.
Not exact matches
The question is whether an appeals court was right to
overturn an $ 11 million
jury verdict awarded to Snyder's father.
Mr. Silver, the former State Assembly speaker, had his initial conviction
overturned last year, but a new
jury arrived at the same
verdict.
There are two categories of post-trial motions to decide on: motions seeking to
overturn parts of the
jury verdict (arguing that the judge should overrule the
jury or order a new trial on a given set of issues), and motions relating to relief.
In Colorado, U.S. District Senior Judge Richard P. Matsch was so infuriated by the trial conduct of counsel for Medtronic Navigation Inc. that he had already
overturned a
jury's $ 51 million
verdict in its favor, as The Denver Post reports.
Two years later, the West Virginia court
overturned a $ 50 million
jury verdict against Massey Coal Company.
Related articles: — Tallahassee Paper Supports Unanimous
Jury Verdicts for Death Sentences — Non-unanimous Judges Can
Overturn Unanimous
Jury Sentences in Florida — Alabama Judges Can Override
Juries to Impose Death Sentences
No Written Retainer Agreement, With Quantum Meruit
Jury Verdict Overturned And Reduced To $ 1.8 Million Plus Some Other Deductions.
Counsel can determine on Lex Machina's motion comparator, Ravel Law's motions database or Bloomberg's Litigation Analytics how likely judges are to either
overturn or modify a
jury verdict.
The crown argued that much of the material about Baghdadi's benefit claims may have been known by Dizaei at the time of the trial and thus did not count as new evidence, which is needed to
overturn the
jury's
verdict in the original trial.
Almost all
verdicts overturned for reasons # 4 and # 5 are «true positives» where the
jury reached an incorrect result.
But, there are lots of
jury verdicts which can't be
overturned for any of the reasons # 1, # 2, # 3, # 4 or # 5, even though the
verdicts were actually based upon a misunderstanding of the law, an inaccurate understanding of the facts of the case, or a deliberate decision not to apply the law that the
jury was instructed to follow to the facts of the case as the
jury sincerely understands them to be.
In those cases it is also necessary for the party that wants to
overturn the
verdict to «preserve» an objection to the
jury instruction in question or the judge's reason, or the condition beyond the control of the parties or the court, in order to have a judge
overturn the
verdict or to prevail on appeal.
The key thing to observe is that
jury verdicts are almost always
overturned, either based upon things that hypothetically could have caused them to reach an incorrect
verdict (for the reasons I've labeled # 1, # 2 or # 3) whether or not those mistakes actually caused the
jury to reach the wrong
verdict, or because under the circumstances it was impossible for the
jury to have reached the
verdict that it did (for the reasons I've labeled as # 4 and # 5).
The dispute commenced in 2010, resulted in a
jury verdict awarding VirnetX $ 368 million in 2012, and was
overturned on appeal in September 2014.
According to the Wall Street Journal, the federal appeals court reinstated the $ 119.6 million
jury verdict in favor of Tim Cook's company in its fight against Samsung that was
overturned by a U.S. circuit appeals in February.
«While we are pleased that the majority of original claims were dismissed in this case, we regret that the
jury did not find for us completely on those that remained, and will vigorously pursue all options to
overturn their
verdict.
«While we are pleased that the majority of the original claims were dismissed in this case, we regret that the
jury did not find for us completely on those that remained and will vigorously pursue all options to
overturn their
verdict.