There are those that do have confirmation
bias, and I have seen that
kind of thing in these reviews, but it seems to me that that one
particular part you call out in your blog is not part
of it, but rather holding reviewers accountable for their scores.
In
particular, an adversarial system could help to expose the
kinds of bias that are so often found in current pharmaceutical research, such as
bias in the choice
of hypotheses,
bias in the interpretation
of results, and
bias in experimental design.