The case also illustrates how vital getting documents into evidence in breach of contract cases and the paramount importance of clear prevailing
party fee provisions in written agreements.
Brinkley Morgan has successfully utilized prevailing
party fee provisions that limit recovery to a fixed amount, and we have found that such a strategy deters protracted litigation, thereby encouraging parties to resolve disputes through mediation.
Not exact matches
Such risks, uncertainties and other factors include, without limitation: (1) the effect of economic conditions in the industries and markets in which United Technologies and Rockwell Collins operate in the U.S. and globally and any changes therein, including financial market conditions, fluctuations in commodity prices, interest rates and foreign currency exchange rates, levels of end market demand in construction and in both the commercial and defense segments of the aerospace industry, levels of air travel, financial condition of commercial airlines, the impact of weather conditions and natural disasters and the financial condition of our customers and suppliers; (2) challenges in the development, production, delivery, support, performance and realization of the anticipated benefits of advanced technologies and new products and services; (3) the scope, nature, impact or timing of acquisition and divestiture or restructuring activity, including the pending acquisition of Rockwell Collins, including among other things integration of acquired businesses into United Technologies» existing businesses and realization of synergies and opportunities for growth and innovation; (4) future timing and levels of indebtedness, including indebtedness expected to be incurred by United Technologies in connection with the pending Rockwell Collins acquisition, and capital spending and research and development spending, including in connection with the pending Rockwell Collins acquisition; (5) future availability of credit and factors that may affect such availability, including credit market conditions and our capital structure; (6) the timing and scope of future repurchases of United Technologies» common stock, which may be suspended at any time due to various factors, including market conditions and the level of other investing activities and uses of cash, including in connection with the proposed acquisition of Rockwell; (7) delays and disruption in delivery of materials and services from suppliers; (8) company and customer - directed cost reduction efforts and restructuring costs and savings and other consequences thereof; (9) new business and investment opportunities; (10) our ability to realize the intended benefits of organizational changes; (11) the anticipated benefits of diversification and balance of operations across product lines, regions and industries; (12) the outcome of legal proceedings, investigations and other contingencies; (13) pension plan assumptions and future contributions; (14) the impact of the negotiation of collective bargaining agreements and labor disputes; (15) the effect of changes in political conditions in the U.S. and other countries in which United Technologies and Rockwell Collins operate, including the effect of changes in U.S. trade policies or the U.K.'s pending withdrawal from the EU, on general market conditions, global trade policies and currency exchange rates in the near term and beyond; (16) the effect of changes in tax (including U.S. tax reform enacted on December 22, 2017, which is commonly referred to as the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017), environmental, regulatory (including among other things import / export) and other laws and regulations in the U.S. and other countries in which United Technologies and Rockwell Collins operate; (17) the ability of United Technologies and Rockwell Collins to receive the required regulatory approvals (and the risk that such approvals may result in the imposition of conditions that could adversely affect the combined company or the expected benefits of the merger) and to satisfy the other conditions to the closing of the pending acquisition on a timely basis or at all; (18) the occurrence of events that may give rise to a right of one or both of United Technologies or Rockwell Collins to terminate the merger agreement, including in circumstances that might require Rockwell Collins to pay a termination
fee of $ 695 million to United Technologies or $ 50 million of expense reimbursement; (19) negative effects of the announcement or the completion of the merger on the market price of United Technologies» and / or Rockwell Collins» common stock and / or on their respective financial performance; (20) risks related to Rockwell Collins and United Technologies being restricted in their operation of their businesses while the merger agreement is in effect; (21) risks relating to the value of the United Technologies» shares to be issued in connection with the pending Rockwell acquisition, significant merger costs and / or unknown liabilities; (22) risks associated with third
party contracts containing consent and / or other
provisions that may be triggered by the Rockwell merger agreement; (23) risks associated with merger - related litigation or appraisal proceedings; and (24) the ability of United Technologies and Rockwell Collins, or the combined company, to retain and hire key personnel.
Among the less noticed features of the federal tax overhaul enacted late last year is a
provision eliminating the deductibility of sexual harassment settlement payments and related attorney's
fees if the
parties agree to keep the settlement secret.
Personal information will only be passed on to third
parties if necessary to provide the service offered (e.g. payment processing for
fee - based memberships), and if you have given us your consent or disclosure in accordance with relevant statutory
provisions that are required or permitted (e.g. if we have to comply with a request, a governmental investigative or security agency).
Personal information will only be passed on to third
parties if necessary to provide the service offered (e.g. payment processing for
fee - based memberships), or if you have given us your consent or disclosure is required in accordance with relevant statutory
provisions that are required or permitted (e.g. if we have to comply with a request, a governmental investigative or security agency).
Personal data will only be passed on to third
parties if necessary to provide the service offered (e.g. payment processing for
fee - based memberships), and if you have given us your consent or disclosure in accordance with relevant statutory
provisions that are required or permitted (e.g. if we have to comply with a request, a governmental investigative or security agency).
Special Education & Disabilities: Whether parents who succeed on claim for reimbursement for private school tuition under IDEA's stay put
provision are a prevail
party entitled to attorneys»
fees
Given that this Agreement provides for mandatory mediation and arbitration, if any
party commences litigation in violation of this
provision, such
party shall reimburse the other
parties to the litigation for the costs and expenses, including attorneys»
fees, incurred in seeking to abate such litigation and compel arbitration.
For example, in Colorado civil cases, some of the more common grounds for an award of attorneys»
fees to a defending
party are: (a) a two - sided contractual
fee shifting term, (b) dismissal of the case before filing an answer for failure to state a claim when tort claims were asserted, (c) a determination that the suit was groundless, frivolous or vexatious, (d) violation of certain rules relating to disclosure of information to the other
party, (e) a statutory
fee shifting
provision in the case of a claim based upon a statutorily created right which is present in some statutes but not others.
The Supreme Court has previously noted that the
fee - shifting
provision of the Patent Act, which permits district courts to award attorney's
fees to prevailing
parties in «exceptional cases,» is «similar» to Section 505 of the Copyright Act, which merely permits a court to award reasonable attorney's
fees at its discretion.
Mar. 24, 2016)-- joint opinion by Circuit Judges O'Scannlain and Ikuta as well as District Judge Burns (sitting by assignment); discussed in our Mar. 28, 2016 post: Prevailing
party in bankruptcy non-dischargeability action is not entitled to recover
fees under either California Civil Code section 1717 or ERISA's
fee shifting
provision.
1979 (2016): SCOTUS sets forth flexible factors to be weighed for purposes of district judges awarding
fees to a prevailing
party under the Copyright Act's
fee - shifting
provision, 17 U.S.C. § 505.
This article will discuss the latent deficiencies of the prototypical prevailing
party fee and cost
provision, the potential unintended consequence of including a well - drafted prevailing
party provision that does not limit the recover to a certain amount, and finally, conclude by providing the reader with sound legal advice.
These options include a first
party model of
provision whereby the driver's own insurer provides the replacement vehicle regardless of cost; a regulatory model intended to introduce the formal regulation of credit hire providers which would permit the capping of costs and a ban on referral
fees; an industry code of conduct which would build on the existing GTA; or a «competitive offer» model allowing the at - fault insurer to provide the vehicle at lower cost if they can do so.
Assume for a moment that your contract contains a robust
provision, free of latent deficiencies, thereby entitling the prevailing
party to all attorneys»
fees and costs incurred.
Brinkley Morgan Legal Talk Blog, July 15, 2015 «E-Discovery: A Beginner's Guide to Electronic Discovery,» Brinkley Morgan Legal Talk Blog, Feb. 20, 2015 «The Prototypical Prevailing
Party Fee and Cost
Provision: Friend or Foe?»
Bearing that in mind, prevailing
party fee and cost
provisions must include clear, unambiguous language as to exactly what the
parties intended.
Statutory
Fee - Shifting
Provisions Can Have Real Force In A Case For A Prevailing
Party, Even If The Compensatory Damages Award Is Much Less Than Requested
Fees.
The prevailing
party sought in excess of $ 4 million in attorney's
fees pursuant to a contractual
fee - shifting
provision.
Continue reading «Section 1717 and Prevailing
Parties: Fourth District, Division One, Rules that Civil Code Section 1717's Prevailing
Party Standard, Mutuality Principle, and Reasonable
Fees Standard Apply to an Attorney's
Fees Provision in a Consent Decree»»
S496 (Florida Supreme Court, June 30, 2005):
Provision in prenuptial agreement that attorney
fees would be awarded to prevailing
party in any action to enforce agreement was enforceable.
As a general matter, the prevailing
party in a lawsuit is not entitled to recovery of his attorney's
fees unless there is a written contract that contains an attorney's
fees provision.
Most mortgages and loan documents include a prevailing
party attorney's
fee provision, generally specifying only that the lender can recover its
fees.
So, too, no
fees or costs were covered by Labor Code section 2802, because that
provision only required the employer to cover third -
party claims arising out of a lawsuit against the employee arising out of the course and scope of her employment, again not encompassing expenses incurred in responding to law enforcement investigations.
Here, Prevailing
Party Sought CCP § 128.5 Sanctions, Such That
Fee Request Proper In Responding Papers — No Notice Of Motion Under Other
Provisions Required.
Family Law Case Review Case: Robert A. Masters v. Leah Masters by Mike Kohlhaas, Bingham Greenebaum Doll HELD: An indemnification
provision for violations of the
parties» arbitrated Decree permitted Wife to recover appellate attorney's
fees from Husband when Husband elected not to comply with a term of the Decree and instead pursue an appeal of it.
The TUC is calling on the government to adopt a series of measures including: abolishing employment tribunal
fees to give more people access to justice; reinstating
provisions in the Equality Act which placed a duty on employers to protect workers from third
party harassment; giving employment tribunals the power to make wider recommendations; and extending the full range of statutory employment rights to all workers.
Should either
party file an action contrary to this
provision, the other
party may recover attorney's
fees and costs up to $ 1000.00.
Opposing attorneys were granted
fees under a contractual
fees clause in an operative settlement agreement between some of the
parties (although the
provision could encompass even another non-party attorney to the settlement agreement).
Judges can shift
fees only if the winner shows that the losing
party was unreasonable; the Innovation Act's
provision has shifting as the default.
It includes a
provision that would, in certain circumstances, shift
fees away to winning
parties from the troll who brought the suit and lost.
The
provisions of Sections (Terms and
Fees) hereof shall survive termination of this Agreement for whatever cause, including, but not limited to the mutual agreement to terminate this Agreement by both
parties hereto.
Without limiting the generality or effect of other
provisions of this Agreement, as a condition of use, you agree to indemnify, hold harmless, and defend Operator and its parents, subsidiaries, affiliates, licensors, suppliers and their officers, directors, affiliates, subcontractors, agents and employees (collectively, «Indemnified
Parties» and each, individually, an «Indemnified
Party») against all costs, expenses, liabilities and damages (including reasonable attorney's fees) incurred by any Indemnified Party in connection with any third party claims arising out of: (i) your failure to comply with any applicable laws and regulations; and (ii) your breach of any of its obligations set forth in this Agree
Party») against all costs, expenses, liabilities and damages (including reasonable attorney's
fees) incurred by any Indemnified
Party in connection with any third party claims arising out of: (i) your failure to comply with any applicable laws and regulations; and (ii) your breach of any of its obligations set forth in this Agree
Party in connection with any third
party claims arising out of: (i) your failure to comply with any applicable laws and regulations; and (ii) your breach of any of its obligations set forth in this Agree
party claims arising out of: (i) your failure to comply with any applicable laws and regulations; and (ii) your breach of any of its obligations set forth in this Agreement.
If not, a tenant should make sure their lease has an attorney
provision that provides for the «prevailing
party» to recover attorney
fees and not just attorney
fees for the landlord.
Today, most residential lease agreements in Florida have
provisions that allow for the recovery of legal
fees for the prevailing
party in a landlord - tenant lawsuit.
Occasionally, a
provision providing that the breaching
party pays the nonbreaching
party's attorney's
fees can move the breaching
party to honor the contract.
This amendment was a legislative reaction to the Court of Appeals holding in J.L. Holding Company v Reis (240 N.Y. 424) interpreting the
fee splitting
provisions of Section § 442 as not prohibiting a real estate broker from paying a portion of its
fee to a buyer or seller in a transaction as such buyer or seller was not required to be licensed to provide service, help or aid in relation to the transaction to which they were a
party.
ATTORNEY»S
FEES AND COSTS: If a dispute arises by and between the parties or involving the subject matter of this Agreement and litigation is commenced to enforce the provisions herein or interpret the provisions herein, the prevailing party shall be due its reasonable attorney's fees and litigation costs, including appellate attorney's fees and costs by the non prevailing pa
FEES AND COSTS: If a dispute arises by and between the
parties or involving the subject matter of this Agreement and litigation is commenced to enforce the
provisions herein or interpret the
provisions herein, the prevailing
party shall be due its reasonable attorney's
fees and litigation costs, including appellate attorney's fees and costs by the non prevailing pa
fees and litigation costs, including appellate attorney's
fees and costs by the non prevailing pa
fees and costs by the non prevailing
party.
The court also observed that just because a broker has signed the portion of the document specifying the commission agreement with the seller, it doesn't make the broker a
party to the contract between the buyer and the seller and thus subject to an attorney
fee provision.
What will the
parties» legal rights and attorney
fee provisions be in the event of a breach of contract.