«Open» — all comers, beginner questions welcome «Pro» — no beginner commentary (perhaps a «side» thread can be created for
peanut gallery discussions)
Not exact matches
I'd also (in a way) strongly second Steve Mosher's preference that we respect Gavin and Michael's plea «to open the
discussion here to all of the authors to give their thoughts...» Only the authors should post comments (at least initially, and for some time after that), and the
peanut gallery should watch.
RC is a not in my opinion a forum for serious
discussion of science, its a forum for the team to educate journalists and members of the
peanut gallery about the party line.
From my vantage point in the
Peanut Gallery the lack of focus here created the opportunity for a few to hyjack the
discussion and turn it into a critique of CE and JC.