According to the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES 1999 - 2000), 27.3 % of the students in charter schools are African Americans, compared to 16.9 %
percent in traditional public schools; 20.8 % percent are of Hispanic origin, compared to 14.9 % in traditional public schools, and 2.3 % are Native Americans, compared to 1.2 % in traditional schools.
According to research released in 2010 by professor Gary Orfield of the Civil Rights Project at the University of California, Los Angeles, 70 percent of black charter school students attend a school where the bulk of their peers are also minorities — compared to 40
percent in traditional public schools.
Charters serve proportions of students with disabilities at rates close to traditional public schools: 12.55
percent in traditional public schools compared to 10.42 percent in charter schools.
In 2014, only 11 percent of its students were proficient in English and 18 percent in math, compared to 28 and 36
percent in traditional public schools with similar demographics.
In fact, 68.5 percent of the Big Apple's charter students are proficient in math compared with 57.3
percent in traditional public schools.»
According to WNYC, Icahn's attrition rate for the 2013 — 14 school year was 8 percent for elementary school grades and 5.4 percent for middle school grades, compared to an overall rate of 13
percent in traditional public schools.
Roughly 40 percent of charter school students in grades 3 — 8 were black, compared with 31
percent in traditional public schools.
Around 50 to 60 percent of traditional charter school students are Black, compared to approximately 10 percent in online charters and 12
percent in traditional public schools.
Not exact matches
But though 80
percent of the charters
in her home state perform worse than
traditional public schools, DeVos — a billionaire whose family has also opposed workers» rights, gay marriage and has contributed heavily to a variety of other right - wing causes — has led the way
in resisting any attempts to regulate or improve Michigan charter performance.
«Some 96
percent of students
in public education attend
traditional public schools,» Magee said.
His resolution would support the Board's request to reserve 17
percent of seats for «
traditional» Buffalo
Public Schools applicants
in an effort to «remedy imbalances.»
Fifty - two
percent of city charter
school students were
in 90 - 100 % minority
schools, compared to only 34 % of
traditional public school students — a difference of eighteen percentage points, very similar to the overall difference of twenty percentage points between the two sectors of
schools (Table 22 on p. 63 of our report).
The focal measures
in this table are shown
in the last two columns, where the authors present the percentage of charter
school students (from the entire metropolitan area)
in schools with greater than 90
percent minority students alongside the similar figure for
traditional public schools.
Using the best available unit of comparison, we find that 63
percent of charter students
in these central cities attend
school in intensely segregated minority
schools, as do 53
percent of
traditional public school students (see Figure 1).
For example, the authors note that
in the Washington, D.C., CBSA, 91
percent of students
in charter
schools attend hypersegregated
schools, while only 20
percent of students
in that same area attend hypersegregated
traditional public schools.
For the 39 CBSAs examined by the authors, only 22
percent of the
traditional public schools were located
in central cities, compared to 51
percent of the charter
schools.
As the authors themselves note, across the country only 2.5
percent of
public school children roam the halls
in charter
schools each day; the remaining 97.5
percent are compelled to attend
traditional public schools.
For example, a 2010 report by UCLA's Civil Rights Project found that black charter
school students were twice as likely to attend
schools that enrolled fewer than 10
percent non-minority students as their counterparts
in traditional public schools.
For example, under the CRP method, 91.2
percent of the charter students
in the DC CBSA are
in hypersegregated minority
schools, as compared to just 20.9
percent of the students
in traditional public schools.
According to the authors» own numbers
in Table 20, more than half (56
percent) of charter
school students attend
school in a city, compared to less than one - third (30
percent) of
traditional public school students.
The D.C. metro CBSA contains 1,186
traditional public schools, 1,026 of which are
in Virginia, Maryland, and even West Virginia; only 13
percent of the
traditional public schools in the D.C. CBSA are actually situated
in the racially isolated District of Columbia.
In Florida, 57 percent of students who went from a charter school in 8th grade to a traditional public school in 9th grade received a standard high school diploma within four years, compared to 77 percent of charter 8th graders who attended a charter high schoo
In Florida, 57
percent of students who went from a charter
school in 8th grade to a traditional public school in 9th grade received a standard high school diploma within four years, compared to 77 percent of charter 8th graders who attended a charter high schoo
in 8th grade to a
traditional public school in 9th grade received a standard high school diploma within four years, compared to 77 percent of charter 8th graders who attended a charter high schoo
in 9th grade received a standard high
school diploma within four years, compared to 77
percent of charter 8th graders who attended a charter high
school.
The average performance composite among
traditional public schools increased from 67
percent in 1996 — 97 to 75
percent in 1999 — 2000 as the number of charter
schools in the state increased from 0 to more than 70.
28.3
percent of teachers
in traditional public schools miss eleven or more days of
school for illness or personal reasons.
In Chicago, the gap in college attendance is smaller but still sizable: among the study population of charter 8th graders, 49 percent of students at charter high schools attended college, compared to 38 percent of students at traditional public high school
In Chicago, the gap
in college attendance is smaller but still sizable: among the study population of charter 8th graders, 49 percent of students at charter high schools attended college, compared to 38 percent of students at traditional public high school
in college attendance is smaller but still sizable: among the study population of charter 8th graders, 49
percent of students at charter high
schools attended college, compared to 38
percent of students at
traditional public high
schools.
In Florida, among the study population of charter 8th graders, 57 percent of students attending a charter school in 9th grade went to either a two - or four - year college within five years of starting high school, whereas among students who started high school in a traditional public school the college attendance rate was only 40 percen
In Florida, among the study population of charter 8th graders, 57
percent of students attending a charter
school in 9th grade went to either a two - or four - year college within five years of starting high school, whereas among students who started high school in a traditional public school the college attendance rate was only 40 percen
in 9th grade went to either a two - or four - year college within five years of starting high
school, whereas among students who started high
school in a traditional public school the college attendance rate was only 40 percen
in a
traditional public school the college attendance rate was only 40
percent.
These students are much more likely to attend Detroit's
traditional public schools than charters: 18
percent of DPS students have IEPs compared to 10
percent in charter
schools.
For 90
percent of the 6,576 transfers
in our database, the distance between the charter
school where the student enrolled and the
traditional public school the student attended the previous year is less than ten miles.
Both Detroit's charter and
traditional public -
school sectors serve predominantly African American families (roughly 85
percent) with limited economic resources (
in charters, 84.5
percent qualify for free or reduced - price lunch versus 81.6
percent in district
schools).
Charter advocates claim the
schools receive 70
percent of what
traditional public schools in New Jersey receive, on average, while charter critics note that many outspend
traditional public schools.
Thirty - seven
percent of the students for whom we observe test - score gains at least once
in both sectors attended a
traditional public school after they were
in a charter
school, while the same is true of only 30
percent of all students
in charter
schools.
While only 14
percent of students
in traditional public schools made nonstructural transfers, the same is true of more than one - quarter of students
in fifth - year charter
schools and of an even larger share of students
in newer charter
schools.
Fifty - two
percent of city charter -
school students were
in 90 to 100
percent minority
schools, compared to 34
percent of
traditional public -
school students.
We estimate that private
school choice and intradistrict choice (allowing families to choose any
traditional public school in their district) have the largest potential to expand the sets of
schools to which families have access, with more than 80
percent of families having at least one of these «choice»
schools within five miles of home.
For example, the Civil Rights Project reports that,
in the metropolitan area surrounding the District of Columbia, 91.2
percent of charter students are
in segregated
schools, compared with just 20.9
percent of students
in traditional public schools.
Notably, while most teachers
in traditional public schools are tenured and have multiyear contracts, 96
percent of charter teachers
in their study were either at - will employees or had annual contracts; thus charters can and do separate ineffective teachers.
And on the specific claim the article makes that «half the charters perform only as well, or worse than, Detroit's
traditional public schools» this is what the Stanford study has to say: «
In reading, 47
percent of charter
schools perform significantly better than their
traditional public school market, which is more positive than the 35 % for Michigan charter
schools as a whole.
Charters nationally are producing student achievement gains that are very similar to the levels
in traditional public schools but receive about 30
percent less money per pupil.
No fewer than 26 %
percent of respondents living with
school - age children have used an alternative to
traditional public schools at some point
in those children's education.
Known as the CREDO study, it evaluated student progress on math tests
in half the nation's five thousand charter
schools and concluded that 17
percent were superior to a matched
traditional public school; 37
percent were worse than the
public school; and the remaining 46
percent had academic gains no different from that of a similar
public school.
Charter
schools are often forced to operate at a much lower funding level than
traditional public schools, facing an average disparity
in per - pupil funding of 29
percent in metropolitan areas.
A total of 34.6
percent of teachers
in North Carolina's
traditional public schools missed more than 10 days of work because of sick days or personal days, compared to 12.8
percent of teachers
in the state's charter
schools.
In school year 2009 - 2010, which was the most recent data available at the time of our review, approximately 11 percent of students enrolled in traditional public schools were students with disabilities compared to about 8 percent of students enrolled in charter school
In school year 2009 - 2010, which was the most recent data available at the time of our review, approximately 11
percent of students enrolled
in traditional public schools were students with disabilities compared to about 8 percent of students enrolled in charter school
in traditional public schools were students with disabilities compared to about 8
percent of students enrolled
in charter school
in charter
schools.
In a sign of the changing school choice landscape, 26 percent of adults living with school - age children have educated at least one of their children in an alternative setting that was not a traditional public schoo
In a sign of the changing
school choice landscape, 26
percent of adults living with
school - age children have educated at least one of their children
in an alternative setting that was not a traditional public schoo
in an alternative setting that was not a
traditional public school.
Their enrollment surged by 1,500
in 2000 - 01, to an estimated 9,450 students, or 12
percent of those still enrolled
in traditional public schools.
The same study found that 61
percent of Arizona charter parents gave their
schools an A + or an A. Comparable surveys of Arizona parents with children
in traditional public schools found only 38
percent grading their
schools A + or A.
The researchers found 28
percent of teachers
in traditional public schools, more than one
in four, were chronically absent.
In Connecticut,
public charter
schools receive $ 11,000 per student from the State, approximately 75
percent of the per - pupil funding allocated to
traditional public schools.
In New Orleans, where 7,000 teachers lost their jobs in the wake of Hurricane Katrina and traditional schools were replaced by public charter schools, the share of teachers who were black fell from 74 percent before the storm to 51 percent in 201
In New Orleans, where 7,000 teachers lost their jobs
in the wake of Hurricane Katrina and traditional schools were replaced by public charter schools, the share of teachers who were black fell from 74 percent before the storm to 51 percent in 201
in the wake of Hurricane Katrina and
traditional schools were replaced by
public charter
schools, the share of teachers who were black fell from 74
percent before the storm to 51
percent in 201
in 2012.
We find that students attending
schools in the Wisconsin Parental Choice Program score a staggering 16
percent higher than students
in traditional public schools.