The Arizona State Charter School Board has developed an innovative system that compares
the performance of alternative schools only to that of other alternative schools.
Too many policymakers and authorizers find themselves unable to truly assess
the performance of alternative schools and distinguish, as the report notes, «AECs [that] likely save the lives of many students» from those schools that are «terrible warehouses that temporarily hold kids before putting them on the street.»
Not exact matches
This effort is intended to offer an
alternative to the prevailing notion in so many
schools of success as high academic
performance, often at the cost
of children's mental and physical health, character and integrity.
I'm heartened by the fact that Berkeley, and other
schools like Wisconsin's Appleton Central
Alternative School (ACAS), have adopted programs harnessing the power
of delicious and satisfying food to improve not just health but
performance.
Hawkins was polling 9 % statewide even before a widely - praised debate
performance, and has earned endorsements from a spectrum
of people and organizations, including Ralph Nader, Seattle socialist city council member Kshama Sawant, education analyst Diane Ravitch, and former Mobil Oil VP - turned - renewable energy activist Lou Allstadt; as well as Albany weekly paper Metroland, 6 teachers» unions, 6 Democratic Party clubs, Socialist
Alternative, and a number
of groups leading the fight against
school privatization, such as United Opt Out and the New York Badass Teacher Association.
Even if ticket replacement insurance is taken, there will be no cash
alternative for those that do not wish, or are unable, to attend a future
performance leaving the teacher and
school potentially out
of pocket.
As the progression
of school design gets further and further away from the scope
of BB93, more
alternative performance standards are applied to
school buildings.
In other words, the public
school alternatives are not so great and the
performance of the participating private
schools is considerably worse.
The lottery process allowed the researchers to compare the
performance of students who won the lottery with those who lost the lottery and either attended a neighborhood G&T program, a charter
school, or an
alternative magnet
school.
Harris instead offers two potential
alternatives: 1) the improved public / charter
school performance in New Orleans made the
performance of the private sector look relatively worse; and 2) the curriculum at most private
schools may not have been aligned to the state test, so the poor
performance merely reflects that lack
of alignment rather than poor
performance.
The foundation has already committed some $ 135 million to overhauling fundamental aspects
of urban
school districts: identifying new sources
of talent for positions
of authority; developing
alternative training methods for managers, principals, and teachers union leaders; creating new tools for analyzing
performance data; and working with
school boards to help those sometimes obstructionist bodies become more focused on student learning than on petty power plays.
For example, in 2012, Long Beach City College (LBCC) in California was one
of the first to develop and pilot an
alternative placement algorithm based on high
school coursework and grades, which increased the proportion
of students placing directly into college - level coursework by 21 percentage points in math and 56 percentage points in English, without significantly lowering the average
performance of students in these courses.
Georgia has a strong track record
of reform, including an overhaul
of the state's
performance standards; redevelopment
of state exams; uniform standards for high
school graduation; and a law that has led to the approval
of 27
alternative providers
of teacher certification.
It has also participated in the development
of the Common Core Standards initiative; created
alternative - certification routes that allow organizations other than education
schools to give teachers credentials; improved its teacher pipeline through strong partnerships with the New Teacher Project and Teacher for America; and experimented with
performance - based compensation in 41
school districts.
The Urban Academy and more than 30 other
alternative high
schools that are part
of the New York
Performance Standards Consortium have adopted these rigorous performance assessments as an alternative to the Regents Exams, which high school students throughout New York State are required to pass in English, math, history, and science in order to earn
Performance Standards Consortium have adopted these rigorous
performance assessments as an alternative to the Regents Exams, which high school students throughout New York State are required to pass in English, math, history, and science in order to earn
performance assessments as an
alternative to the Regents Exams, which high
school students throughout New York State are required to pass in English, math, history, and science in order to earn a diploma.
Encourage boards
of struggling
schools to consider restart as part
of school improvement planning by emphasizing the board's public obligation, discussing restart as a viable and welcomed
alternative to incremental change or closure, and setting clear
performance criteria.
While opponents said that vouchers had no track record
of improving student
performance, supporters countered that no
alternative could be worse than Washington's public
schools, which in any case were in line to receive more federal aid.
Rather than lifting the
performance of marginal students,
alternative schools serve too often as way stations for future dropouts.
To address this concern, the SBE approved a methodology for calculating LEA - and
school - level
performance that assumes the subsequent adoption
of a system that more effectively addresses the needs
of alternative schools.
However, using
alternative assessments makes it difficult to compare the
performance of ESA students to students in other
schools, both public and private.
We chose to label the years that four key accountability policies went into effect, in order to look for a possible relationship between
alternative school enrollment the implementation
of policies that would penalize
schools for poor
performance.
The primary purposes
of both AYP requirements under the ESEA statute and
alternative state
performance measures in waiver states are to determine whether
schools are making sufficient progress and to select low - performing
schools for interventions or especially high - performing
schools for rewards.
State
performance measures for
schools, whether they use the AYP measure
of the ESEA statute or
alternative measures developed by waiver states, must be predicated on regular movement by
schools toward an ultimate goal.
In their statement,
school district officials noted the district's overall graduation rate, which includes the
performance of the charter
alternative schools, has risen in recent years.
Explicitly endorsing or encouraging states to use one
of the two above - mentioned approaches as an
alternative to proficiency rates as the primary measure
of school performance.
These
alternative state measures
of school performance often take the form
of multifaceted
performance indexes that vary widely in scope, complexity, and transparency.
Left - wing policy supports neighborhood - based public
schools, opposes any methods to measure or differentiate the
performance of teachers or
schools, and argues instead for
alternatives to
school reform like increased anti-poverty spending or urging middle - class parents to enroll their children in high - poverty
schools.
Accordingly, some indicators that are appropriate measures
of performance for comprehensive high
schools can not accurately measure the quality
of educational programs at
alternative schools.
After piloting the collection
of measures
of those skills in a small number
of schools during the 2013 - 14
school year, including conducting multiple experiments to compare the
performance of alternative survey items, CORE conducted a broader field test involving more than 450,000 students in grades 3 - 12 the following spring.
Also tucked in the recommendations are such bold ideas as serious acceptance
of alternative pathways and «residency» - style preparation; insistence on real standards for entering prep programs and getting certified; the demand that prep programs respond to K — 12 education's actual supply - demand numbers rather than enrolling as many people as possible (thus probably killing the proverbial ed -
school «cash cow» within universities); and tracking the
performance of those emerging from various prep programs and institutions — and actually closing those that don't produce successful professionals.
We did not find any obvious relationship between
alternative patterns
of distributed leadership and state test
performance of students in each
school from 2002/03 to 2005/06.
I spoke on the subjects
of accountability,
performance contracting, teacher centers, continuous progress education, and what we were then calling
alternative schools, but would now be considered magnet
schools.
Other research has pointed to the possibility that top - down and bottom - up approaches need not be viewed as
alternatives, but can be combined.235 Recent research on the district role in
school - improvement activity has focused increasingly on the identification
of specific district - level policies, actions, and conditions that are related to improvement in teachers «and students «
performance.
Federal law in postsecondary education must also be a robust source
of support for local innovation, research, and implementation
of strategies designed to improve teacher and principal effectiveness and include: Evidence - based preparation and professional development; Evidence - based evaluation systems that include, in part, student
performance;
Alternative certification programs that meet workforce needs; State and
school district flexibility regarding credentials for small and / or rural
schools, special education programs, English learners and specialized programs such as science, technology, engineering, arts, and mathematics; and Locally - determined compensation and teacher and principal assignment policies.
Schools Week has previously reported on the issue of pupils «disappearing» from school registers or being sent to alternative provision by schools over fears of poor league table perfo
Schools Week has previously reported on the issue
of pupils «disappearing» from
school registers or being sent to
alternative provision by
schools over fears of poor league table perfo
schools over fears
of poor league table
performance.
Execute contracts that include clear, measurable
performance standards to judge the effectiveness
of alternative schools, if applicable - requiring and appropriately weighting rigorous mission - specific
performance measures and metrics that credibly demonstrate each
school's success in fulfilling its mission and serving its special population.
In 1997 the New York State
Performance Consortium was founded to give a handful
of district
schools an
alternative method in which to evaluate its students free from most Regents exams though students are still required to pass the English Regents in order to graduate.
The Race to the Top initiative, initially financed through the 2009 federal economic - stimulus legislation, gave Democrats the political cover to push for priorities such as expansion
of charter
schools,
alternative teacher training, and teacher
performance evaluations tied in part to students» academic gains — issues that previously had been associated most closely with Republicans.
Against a backdrop
of the opportunities provided by the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) and the challenges for education posed by the new federal administration, the Annenberg Institute for
School Report has released an issue
of Voices in Urban Education (VUE) and an online supplement that proposes
performance assessment as a personalized and rigorous alternative Read more about Performance Assessment: Fostering the Learning of Teachers and Students (updat
performance assessment as a personalized and rigorous
alternative Read more about
Performance Assessment: Fostering the Learning of Teachers and Students (updat
Performance Assessment: Fostering the Learning
of Teachers and Students (update)-LSB-...]
Certified teachers remain one
of the best options for boosting student
performance, as
school districts and the public consider
alternative choices to traditional
schooling.
An exemplary professional
school counseling program that serves nontraditional or
alternative students targets academic
performance, is grounded in research based practices, and addresses the current and future needs
of students.
The adults who work there often have a long record
of poor
performance, having bounced around from
school to
school until, finally, the teachers union and the district human resources department make a deal to assign them to an
alternative setting, which serves as a kind
of professional exile from the rest
of the system.
We are being told that our evaluation system will require our full comprehension and maintenance
of: measures
of teacher practice observation option selection forms, evaluator forms, consistent update
of class lists / rosters, observation options A, B, C, D, the Matrix, and MOSL options (project based learning assessments, student learning inventories,
performance based assessments, and progress monitoring assessments), not to mention how this plays out for what people teach (elementary / middle / high
school,
alternative assessment, English as a New Language, content areas, etc).
In fact, he said that thinking
of virtual charter
schools as complete
alternatives to traditional
schooling might even be contributing to students» poor academic
performance.
The
Alternative respects the research demonstrating that the local
school must be the focus
of analysis and intervention to improve student
performance.
A class
of parents queued into the
performance of their local
schools would be far more likely to overcome the problem
of governance fragmentation than the
alternative solution proposed by Ford.
Finally, all the studies I've read say
alternative licensure does nothing to improve overall student
performance, (that appearance only being created by the grouping
of more interested and involved parents into «charter»
schools which promise better results.
Lear's focus over the years has been on redesigning high
schools, including an early and long interest in alternative schools and work as a senior researcher at the Coalition of Essential Schools, where he was an early advocate for performance asses
schools, including an early and long interest in
alternative schools and work as a senior researcher at the Coalition of Essential Schools, where he was an early advocate for performance asses
schools and work as a senior researcher at the Coalition
of Essential
Schools, where he was an early advocate for performance asses
Schools, where he was an early advocate for
performance assessments.
Accountability measures for «
alternative» charter
schools need to be carefully worked out as part
of their authorization contracts, with additional evaluation measures clearly laid out to go along with traditional
performance indicators, according to a new report from the National Association
of Charter
School Authorizers.
Those policies include plans to force
schools in poor performing or unviable councils to convert into academies, new
performance tables for academy trusts and a reform
of alternative provision.