Of course I will try my hardest to share my strong beliefs
about planetary protection, but I also realize that they need to come to that realization on their own.
Stray microbes from Earth could potentially harm not just Martian life, but also resources that human settlers may eventually want, such as aquifers, says John Rummel, who served as NASA's
planetary protection officer for more than a decade.
He added that NASA's Office
of Planetary Protection sterilizes spacecraft that will land on other planets to ensure our native bacteria doesn't interact with the organisms elsewhere.
But NASA's
planetary protection office, charged with keeping earthly microbes from colonizing other bodies, has said it may nix a visit.
That means it's possible that SpaceX or another company will try to send humans to Mars before the reconnaissance missions necessary to write rules
for planetary protection are even built.
«Therefore, if we'd
relax planetary protection concerns in a Viking - like mission today, we could add another low - budget mission to the space program.»
So argue two Mars scientists behind a controversial new push to relax
planetary protection rules — a set of sterilisation procedures that Mars - bound spacecraft must undergo to avoid contaminating the planet with terrestrial microbes.
They opened the already - sterilized bit box, a violation of
planetary protection protocols that caused the office to downgrade Curiosity's sterility.
Today, at a meeting in Washington, D.C., of NASA's planetary science advisory committee, the agency's
new planetary protection officer raised the possibility of opening up a few of the planet's most promising regions to more aggressive exploration.
«And this has large impact on different fields including, but not limited to, the theory of Panspermia and
planetary protection issues.»
But the Office of
Planetary Protection doesn't regulate spacecraft that plan to stay in orbit; since the Tesla was never intended to land, it wasn't cleaned before takeoff.
Whether NASA's policy might change won't be clear until a new
planetary protection chief is installed, and after the National Academies panel and special regions workshop have weighed in.
Now that we know the moon is unlikely to harbor life, moon missions are held to a less stringent standard than trips to Mars, Europa, or Enceladus, but even moon shots require some
basic planetary protection actions.
«What I didn't know at the time,» Conley says, «is the way the position is turned over: The
current planetary protection officer finds somebody who's willing to come, brings them in, and then leaves.
Spacecraft going to other worlds must follow
costly planetary protection protocols, such as sterilisation, to avoid contaminating their destination with Earth microbes, putting any native life at risk, or bringing potentially dangerous alien ones back.
Planetary Protection Racket As the first planet to form in our solar system, Jupiter helped to sculpt the rest [see «The Genesis of Planets»; SciAm, May 2008].
«We're still trying to figure out how to
implement planetary protection,» says space law professor Joanne Gabrynowicz at the University of Mississippi.
There are mixed feelings: some have suggested treating Mars as a wildlife preserve, while others argue that
existing planetary protection rules are too strict and could even hamper the hunt for life by making the most interesting destinations the hardest to explore.
At NASA, this mandate evolved into an
official planetary protection policy, a Sisyphean effort to shield the universe from the people exploring it.
The presence of water raises the possibility that Ceres might harbor life, so NASA's Office of
Planetary Protection insisted that Dawn stay at least 420 miles away to minimize the risk of contaminating a pristine world with earthly microbes.
«We have not demonstrated that we can integrate those functions to
meet planetary protection requirements,» Allen says bluntly.
«When we landed the Huygens probe on Titan, we had no idea what we'd find on the surface, so it was really the discoveries of Huygens and Cassini that led to these new
[planetary protection] requirements,» says Spilker.
Although planetary protection may conjure up thoughts of protecting Earth from marauding alien bugs, there is great effort put into protecting other worlds from our bacteria.
And with NASA's Mars 2020 rover planning to cache samples to one day return to Earth's labs,
planetary protection also means making sure that our own world is safe from contamination by possible alien life.
Several media outlets claimed NASA wanted to
hire planetary protection officers to defend Earth from an alien invasion, but the reality is far less glamorous and potentially harmful to the space agency's mission.
Microbial ecology of a crewed rover traverse in the arctic: Low microbial dispersal and implications
for planetary protection on human Mars missions.
John Rummel, an astrobiologist at East Carolina University in Greenville, North Carolina, and former
NASA Planetary Protection Officer, told the room that he doesn't think there has to be a conflict.
That makes now the best time for scientists, legal experts and the public to start thinking about when and how we might
relax planetary protection protocols if we decide another planet is lifeless, he says.
The researchers claim «the protocols and policies
of planetary protection are unnecessarily restricting Mars exploration and need to be revised.»