Neither the policies nor legal
principles giving rise to the claims for framing the rights are the same.
A claim that cost consequences arose due to a breach — a party must show that such costs arose from the breach, not from an event which could not in
principle give rise to a claim / counterclaim.
Not exact matches
And in Perry v Day Mr Justice Rimer held (at [62]-RRB- that, in the light of Giles v Rhind, it was arguable that there is an exception
to the
principle where the company fails
to sue within the period available for it
to do so because of ignorance of the facts
giving rise to the
claim.
The subrogation
claim, although potentially applicable
to non-signatories, did not
give rise to fee entitlement because nothing allowed cross-complainant
to step in the shoes of any party
to the construction loan agreement — so, if cross-complainant could not recover for fees, Bank could not either under either contractual interpretation or Civil Code section 1717 reciprocity
principles.
In relation
to the fourth issue, however, his Lordship ruled that the UK was in sufficiently serious breach of the terms of the Second Directive so as
to give rise, in
principle,
to a
claim for damages.