I'm basing that conclusion of the weak connection on my review of those 7 charter and
private school choice studies as well as the Heckman book I referenced.
A more recent summary, by Epple, Romano, and Urquiola, selectively included only 48 % of the empirical
private school choice studies available in the research literature.
Not exact matches
I've identified 10 rigorously designed
studies of charter and
private school choice programs with later life outcomes.
My colleagues and I have shown that such differences exist in a
study that followed a group of students into and out of public and
private schools in Milwaukee (see «Special
Choices,» features, Summer 2012).
The three
studies find neutral to positive impacts of
private school choice on college enrollment and graduation, but with some variation:
We haven't had the opportunity to
study those questions in the United States when it comes to a
private school choice program operating at scale, at least until very recently, when you had statewide programs adopted in Indiana and Louisiana.
The statement includes a list of these developments: the US Supreme Court ruled scholarships constitutional; numerous
studies showed these programs benefit needy kids; families empowered with this
choice express great satisfaction; urban districts continue to struggle despite great effort; chartering hasn't created enough high - quality seats; and smart accountability systems can ensure only high - quality
private schools participate in these programs.
We limit our meta - analysis to the 19 gold standard
studies of
private school choice programs globally.
Your article on the Milwaukee
school -
choice evaluation («New Studies on Private Choice Contradict Each Other,» Sept. 4, 1996) accurately reports that our study of the Milwaukee choice program found that choice students outperformed a comparable control group of Milwaukee Public Schools students on standardized tests by a considerable amount after three and four years of experience in the choice sc
choice evaluation («New
Studies on
Private Choice Contradict Each Other,» Sept. 4, 1996) accurately reports that our study of the Milwaukee choice program found that choice students outperformed a comparable control group of Milwaukee Public Schools students on standardized tests by a considerable amount after three and four years of experience in the choice sc
Choice Contradict Each Other,» Sept. 4, 1996) accurately reports that our
study of the Milwaukee
choice program found that choice students outperformed a comparable control group of Milwaukee Public Schools students on standardized tests by a considerable amount after three and four years of experience in the choice sc
choice program found that
choice students outperformed a comparable control group of Milwaukee Public Schools students on standardized tests by a considerable amount after three and four years of experience in the choice sc
choice students outperformed a comparable control group of Milwaukee Public
Schools students on standardized tests by a considerable amount after three and four years of experience in the choice s
Schools students on standardized tests by a considerable amount after three and four years of experience in the
choice sc
choice schoolsschools.
Chingos wrote about these
studies in «What Have We Learned From Three Studies of Private School Choice?
studies in «What Have We Learned From Three
Studies of Private School Choice?
Studies of
Private School Choice?»
The Friedman Foundation for Educational
Choice recently released a
study that seeks to better understand the decision - making processes of parents who send their children to
private schools.
But there is risk of overstating results from any single
study, especially on issues as controversial and polarizing as
private school choice.
These prior
studies are based largely on non-experimental comparisons of survey responses of similar students in public and
private schools, whereas our
study is the first to examine data on the actual voting behavior of students who participated in a
choice lottery.
Smarick's
study, «The Chartered Course,» explores how
private schools and advocates of educational
choice can learn from the charter sector.
He is also the author or editor of numerous other publications including the following:
School Choice International: Exploring public
private partnerships (co-editor with Rajashri Chakrabarti)
School Money Trials: The Legal Pursuit of Educational Adequacy (co-editor with Martin R. West) Reforming Education in Florida: A
Study Prepared by the Koret Task Force on K - 12 Education (editor) The Education Gap: Vouchers and Urban
Schools (with William G. Howell) Generational Change: Closing the Test Score Gap (editor) No Child Left Behind?
Understanding the effect of
private school choice on real - world success beyond test scores requires data on outcomes like college enrollment and graduation, and thanks to three recent Urban Institute
studies, we know more about this than we did a year ago.
Three new
studies released by the Urban Institute look at how
private school choice has affected nearly 13,000 students in three different states.
The effects of
private -
school -
choice programs on the achievement of student participants have been extensively
studied using a variety of research designs.
Only one
study, conducted by Jay Greene and Marcus Winters and focusing on the D.C. voucher program, found that voucher competition had no effect on the test scores of non-participants, while no empirical
study of acceptable rigor has found that a U.S.
private -
school -
choice program decreased the achievement of public
school students.
Danish Shakeel, Kaitlin Anderson, and I conducted a meta - analysis of the 16 experimental
studies, finding that the
private -
school -
choice programs evaluated in the United States have increased student achievement by an average of.13 standard deviations in reading by the fourth year after the
study started.
This
study of Washington, DC's, Opportunity Scholarship Program (OSP) provides the first experimental evidence on the effect of a publicly funded
private school choice program on college enrollment.
[52] Likewise, a comprehensive
study of families participating in Washington, DC's
private school choice program found that «parents do not view test scores as the key metric of success in education.»
She should start with Patrick Wolf's «Civics Exam» literature review of 21
studies, which found that the «statistical record suggests that
private schooling and
school choice often enhance the realization of the civic values that are central to a well - functioning democracy.»
Study after study has supported the belief that private school choice programs benefit the students who participate (across a number of indicat
Study after
study has supported the belief that private school choice programs benefit the students who participate (across a number of indicat
study has supported the belief that
private school choice programs benefit the students who participate (across a number of indicators).
Small high
schools send larger shares of students to college, new
study says ChalkbeatNY: The multi-year
study examines a subset of 123 «small
schools of
choice» that opened between 2002 and 2008 with
private funding from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and support from former Mayor Michael Bloomberg's administration.
Patrick J. Wolf, education policy professor at the University of Arkansas, reports on a meta - analysis of 16 experimental
studies of
private -
school -
choice programs, which found achievement gains in reading.
Looking at longitudinal
studies in Milwaukee and Louisiana, she describes them in a way that will leave the impression that the results were negative for
school choice: «In both cases, programs were used primarily by black students and generally did not exacerbate segregation in public
schools; however, students using vouchers did not gain access to integrated
private schools, and segregation in
private schools actually increased.»
Fordham also downplays the likely effect of their proposed regulations by assuring that they «won't scare away [
private]
schools,» citing a previous Fordham
study which found that most
private schools would participate in a
school choice program even if that meant accepting such regulations.
He notes that, although few
studies have examined the impact of
choice on public
school students, most every finding to date suggests that vouchers, rather than adversely affecting students who are «left behind» in public
schools, actually lead to gains for public and
private school students.
Results from other
studies on
private school choice, however, do not indicate a relationship.
Prior to the IES report, there have been 15 empirical
studies examining academic outcomes for students participating in
private school choice using random assignment, the «gold standard» of defensible social science:
Dr. Matt Chingos of the Urban Institute released a new
study that shows very favorable long - term outcomes for students who enroll in the Florida Tax Credit Scholarship Program — the largest
private school choice program in the country.The results are clear: the Florida program significantly increases college matriculation, especially when students were enrolled in the FTC program for a longer period of time.
«We are incredibly pleased to see the results of this
study by Dr. Matt Chingos of the Urban Institute, as it confirms what we have known to be true for years:
private school choice programs provide families, especially disadvantaged families, greater opportunities to achieve academic success.
There have been 15 gold standard empirical
studies of
private school choice and academic outcomes: 10 are positive, 3 are neutral, and 2 are negative — only based upon on results in early years of those two
studies.
This report is based on a «meta - analysis» — a
study that examines all of the existing research and examines the overall findings — of the research literature on
private school choice programs, including vouchers and tax credit scholarships, from around the world.
According to the authors, there have been at least 9,443
studies conducted on
private school choice worldwide.
A new
study by my colleagues Brian Kisida, Pat Wolf, and Evan Rhinesmith gives some indication of how things go wrong when you impose a heavy, public -
school - like regulatory burden on
private choice programs.
IASBO recommends that there be a thorough
study of the
Choice Scholarship program to determine if it is working and to determine if students are staying in
private schools or returning to the public
schools.
No
study, even those conducted by anti-
school choice organizations, has found
private school choice programs harm the academic performance of students who remain in district
schools.
A second meta - analysis led by University of Arkansas researcher Patrick Wolf, using 19 gold standard
studies of
private school choice programs globally, found that
private school choice increases the reading and math scores of
choice users.
School choice has grown by leaps and bounds over the past two decades, with literally millions of students benefiting from the choice movement, precisely because most studies have shown that school choice programs help improve educational outcomes — for students who receive private school scholarships, those who attend public charter schools, and those who remain in traditional public sc
School choice has grown by leaps and bounds over the past two decades, with literally millions of students benefiting from the
choice movement, precisely because most
studies have shown that
school choice programs help improve educational outcomes — for students who receive private school scholarships, those who attend public charter schools, and those who remain in traditional public sc
school choice programs help improve educational outcomes — for students who receive
private school scholarships, those who attend public charter schools, and those who remain in traditional public sc
school scholarships, those who attend public charter
schools, and those who remain in traditional public
schools.
ICYMI: Groundbreaking
study shows
private school choice in Florida makes students more likely to go to college and get degrees.
In May 2016, EdChoice released a report in which it examines 100 empirical
studies of
private school choice programs, 18 of which used the «gold standard» random assignment to measure outcomes.
Results from a
study conducted by a nonpartisan research team at the University of Arkansas showed that students in
private -
choice schools were more likely to graduate from high school than their peers at Milwaukee Public S
schools were more likely to graduate from high
school than their peers at Milwaukee Public
SchoolsSchools.
Those
studies show that charter and
private choice schools cause students to graduate high
school and go to college at much higher rates.
The
study of the Milwaukee Parental
Choice voucher program concluded: «In sum, our five years of research on the MPCP [Milwaukee voucher program] suggests that students with disabilities are classified and served differently in the
private and public education sectors in Milwaukee, and that the MPCP serves students with disabilities at about two - fifths to three - quarters the rate of MPS [Milwaukee public
schools].»
This is the first
study that has measured the long - term education outcomes for students in a
private school choice program at the statewide level.
Moreover, nearly every
study on the impact of
private school choice policies on district
school performance found a positive impact, including in Louisiana and Ohio.
The Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty (WILL) has released its second annual peer - reviewed
study of
school academic performance across the Badger State, revealing charter
schools and
private schools participating in the state's
school choice programs are outperforming traditional public
schools...
But as Pat Wolf, one of the authors of that
study, noted — the score increase may well be just an artifact of
private choice schools deciding to start prepping students for that high - stakes test now that they were required to take it.