Not exact matches
But company lawyer Jesse Binnall said the Fourth Circuit
Court of Appeals, which upheld the lower
ruling, did so on
procedural grounds, so that the Justice Department's win would not influence much elsewhere.
That wasn't even Olson's case, but with assists from a federal district
court judge who came out as being in a same - sex relationship only after
ruling and retiring, and elected officials who chose to forgo their traditional duty to vigorously defend state law, Olson and Boies did succeed in disenfranchising millions
of Californians on a
procedural technicality.
The Supreme
Court's June
ruling on whether «under God» should be part
of the Pledge
of Allegiance passed with relatively little notice, since the case was rejected on
procedural grounds.
But in his
ruling, Justice Tsoho held that Falana's argument had not shifted the
court's earlier position in its
ruling delivered on April 28, to the effect that the constitutional rights
of the interested parties to be heard by the appeal
court outweighed the
procedural requirements the SAN was relying on.
«It is respectfully submitted therefore My Lord, that on the basis
of the grounds argued above,
of Lack
of, or Excess
of Jurisdiction,
Procedural Irregularity and breach
of the
rules of natural justice it is submitted that the decision
of the National Disciplinary Committee dated 2nd December, 2015 and endorsed by the National Executive Committee on 10th December 2015 be brought up to this
court for purposes
of having same quashed.»
Any time a judiciary adopts
procedural rules which have the effect
of violating substantial due process rights, the said
rules should ideally be disputed by the injured parties in
courts, administrative hearings, and before legislators.
France's Council
of State, which advises the government on legal issues and is the nation's highest administrative
court of appeal, today upheld a September European Court of Justice ruling that found that France's 2008 prohibition against Monsanto's MON810 variety was out of line on procedural gro
court of appeal, today upheld a September European
Court of Justice ruling that found that France's 2008 prohibition against Monsanto's MON810 variety was out of line on procedural gro
Court of Justice
ruling that found that France's 2008 prohibition against Monsanto's MON810 variety was out
of line on
procedural grounds.
The
Court then found that
procedural rules that would allow the continuation
of the decision - making process in a situation where LZ was challenging the decision that did not allow it to fully participate in that decision - making process
The
Court then proceeded to investigate whether the CFR precluded the application
of the Slovak
procedural rules in question.
In a significant win for access to justice in environmental matters, the
Court's Grand Chamber found that Article 47
of the Charter
of Fundamental Rights (the right to an effective remedy), read together with the Aarhus Convention, precluded the application
of national
procedural rules allowing for swift decision - making at the expense
of rights granted to environmental NGOs.
Thorpe LJ provides some helpful
procedural advice which may be incorporated into new family
courts rules; but, in the longer term, does this case represent a continued widening
of the door for outright capital provision for unmarried carer parents — in line with Re P (a child: financial provision)[2003] EWCA Civ 837, [2003] All ER (D) 312 (Jun)-- as against the interests in possession during a child's dependency favoured by earlier cases, eg T v S [1994] 1 FCR 743, [1994] 2 FLR 883; A v A [1995] 2 FCR 353, [1995] 2 FLR 356; J v C (a child: financial provision)[1998] 3 FCR 79, [1999] 1 FLR 152?
In a remarkably short judgment the
Court starts its considerations from the direct effect and full effectiveness
of Article 101 (1) to find that national
procedural rules relating to claims based on EU law must be subject to the principles
of equivalence and effectiveness.
Although the forthcoming general election has meant that the Prisons and
Courts Bill, which seeks to implement some
of these key reforms (including the formation
of a new online
procedural rule committee), has been dropped, work on structuring and piloting aspects
of the OC continues.
On 22 February 2008 the Ministry
of Justice (MOJ) with Her Majesty's
Court Service produced Family Proceedings
Rules: A new
Procedural Code for Family Proceedings, a response to consultation CP (R) 19/06.
The
Court found that when a Member State's
procedural rules apply to actions concerning the exercise
of rights which an environmental organisation derives from article 6 (3)
of the Habitats Directive; «that Member State is implementing obligations stemming from those provisions and must therefore be regarded as implementing EU law» (para 52).
-- that regulation does not preclude the application
of a provision
of national
procedural law
of a Member State which, with a view to avoiding situations
of denial
of justice, enables proceedings to be brought against, and in the absence
of, a person whose domicile is unknown, if the
court seised
of the matter is satisfied, before giving a
ruling in those proceedings, that all investigations required by the principles
of diligence and good faith have been undertaken with a view to tracing the defendant.
As Director
of Arbitration and ADR, North America, for the ICC International
Court of Arbitration, she advised North American companies, law firms and parties on all phases
of ICC arbitration, including negotiating and drafting arbitration clauses, substantive and
procedural rules for filing requests for arbitration before the ICC
Court, and enforcement
of arbitration awards
Accordingly,
courts have rejected arguments that the composition
of the tribunal or the procedure did not comply with the law
of the place
of the arbitration where the parties had agreed on other
procedural rules.
The
court ruled that the Act's
procedural steps could not be enforced through federal injunctions and directed the Federal Circuit to determine the availability
of state law injunctions on remand.
From the perspective
of the exercise
of the public role
of the
court in explaining the law and diffusing conflict among citizens, the
ruling can be criticized in three significant ways: The public was left guessing the precise relief the plaintiffs were seeking and the applicable
procedural law, so as to leave the legal analysis a mystery.
One United States
court observed that the Convention does not «permit reviewing
courts to police every
procedural ruling made by the arbitrator and to set aside the award if any violation
of the -LSB-...] procedures is found.
Earlier this month, a state appellate
court issued a written opinion in a personal injury case that illustrates the importance
of following all
procedural and
court rules in South Florida medical malpractice cases.
In a speech to senior legal figures to mark the opening
of the new law term, Mr Justice Clarke said there was little doubt «that at least some aspects
of our civil
procedural model are beyond their sell - by dates», noting that many
of the
rules of court date to 1870.
926 A German
court has also considered that the participation
of a party in an arbitration without raising any objection may be construed as an implicit agreement with the
procedural rules applied by the tribunal.927
The latest
procedural dispute between Apple and Google (Motorola) is over which U.S. appeals
court — the Federal Circuit or the Seventh Circuit — should hear the parties» cross-appeal of a FRAND contract ruling handed down in November 2012 by the United States District Court for the Western District of Wisco
court — the Federal Circuit or the Seventh Circuit — should hear the parties» cross-appeal
of a FRAND contract
ruling handed down in November 2012 by the United States District
Court for the Western District of Wisco
Court for the Western District
of Wisconsin.
A
court that
rules on an application for recognition and enforcement in reference to the
procedural law
of the country where the arbitration took place, without first ascertaining the existence
of a party agreement, will thus violate the Convention.868
Even where the composition
of the tribunal or the procedure was valid under the
procedural rules of the country where the arbitration took place,
courts have denied recognition and enforcement under article V (1)(d) where those elements deviated from the parties» agreement.
Indiana appellate
courts receive thousands
of appeals each year, and they employ a strict set
of procedural rules to ensure that only the most diligent parties with meritorious claims
of error are heard.
The Vermont Supreme
Court has promulgated a set
of amendments to
procedural rules, which take effect the first
of the year, to simplify the process
of computing deadlines and to change the time requirements
of many
rules.
However, the Statements
of Principle recognize that the
Court should not be slaves to
procedural rules at the expense
of justice.
I have long assumed that the habit
of including requests for
procedural relief in South Carolina family
court pleadings was due to the prior version of Family Court Rule 25, which encouraged the informal exchange of information but did not mandate formal discovery in family court proceedings unless stipulated to by the parties or ordered by the c
court pleadings was due to the prior version
of Family
Court Rule 25, which encouraged the informal exchange of information but did not mandate formal discovery in family court proceedings unless stipulated to by the parties or ordered by the c
Court Rule 25, which encouraged the informal exchange
of information but did not mandate formal discovery in family
court proceedings unless stipulated to by the parties or ordered by the c
court proceedings unless stipulated to by the parties or ordered by the
courtcourt.
The
Court of Appeal suggests that in the pursuit
of greater
procedural fairness for SRLs, there should be flexibility in the application
of Family Law
Rules and the
Rules of Civil Procedure.
I cherish the fundamental values that are the foundations in our
court process: the need to respect the
procedural rules in order to allow for the most expeditious means to reach a resolution on the merits, the importance
of consistency and equality in applying the
rules equally to every party.
Presumably, this includes the power to establish
procedural rules for the
Court's proceedings, including such matters as the timing
of Supreme
Court terms (which is indeed regulated by Congressional statute, as Orin notes).
I suspect that the real heavy lifting in enhancing access to justice is a matter
of procedural reform — specialized decision - making bodies with extremely simplified
procedural rules for specific civil law issues (something that actually already exists in certain areas such as Landlord / Tenant, but could be further improved upon), wider permissions for over-the-counter motions, fewer unnecessary
court appearances, fewer procedurally - mandated appearances (e.g., going from a Case Conference to a Settlement Conference to a Trial Management Conference, and possibly further, before you can get to a family law trial), and so on.
A consequence is that the approach
of «mutual trust» between
courts helps to «avoid an erroneous focus on the domestic process
of the member state
of origin» when the focus should be on «compliance with inter-continentally applicable
procedural rules».
In a 5 - 4
ruling, the Supreme
Court of Canada has found that the Crown need not prove the lawfulness of a demand to provide a breath sample from a person suspected of driving while impaired in order to use procedural «shortcuts» to prove the case in c
Court of Canada has found that the Crown need not prove the lawfulness
of a demand to provide a breath sample from a person suspected
of driving while impaired in order to use
procedural «shortcuts» to prove the case in
courtcourt.
A
procedural rule known as the statute
of limitations may prevent a personal injury lawsuit from being heard by a
court, regardless
of how strong the case is.
At the behest
of the U.S. Chamber
of Commerce — a longtime opponent
of third party litigation funding — the arm
of the federal judiciary that oversees
procedural rules recently decided to consider whether
courts should mandate disclosure from civil litigants using third party funding to finance their legal claims....
This
ruling should be seen as a victory for victims
of negligence by a government organization or employee, since the plaintiff has been vindicated from what was an unfair use
of strict
procedural rules wholly to deny an injured plaintiff from having their day in
court.
It is anticipated that the new law will provide a properly structured
procedural framework for domestic and international arbitrations seated in the UAE, with clear
rules on when an award may be challenged, as well as easing the route to enforcement
of awards by giving arbitration awards the status
of court judgment which can be ratified in the UAE
Courts (thereby avoiding lengthy enforcement proceedings).
On the one hand, the
court of appeal
rules on challenges against
procedural acts and decisions
of prosecuting authorities (Article 20 CrimPC).
Our standard
of review in appeals from the family
court requires a de novo review
of the family
court's decision, and appellate
courts are consistent in holding that
procedural rules are subservient to the
court's duty to zealously guard the rights
of minors.
The majority also insists that the
procedural rule confirmed in Vonner somehow eliminates the need for a contextual inquiry when determining the sufficiency
of a defendant's objection, despite the fact that Vonner explicitly requires us to conduct such a contextual review when evaluating the sufficiency
of the district
court's sentencing pronouncement.
The
court's
procedural rules, as well as judicial resistance to the idea
of rewarding aggressive litigation with monetary bonanzas, have historically limited the amounts recoverable under these doctrines.
Under the applicable
procedural rules in Switzerland, investigators or the
court may neither ask for documents that relate to the professional legal representation
of a party or
of a third person in civil proceedings nor for correspondence between an accused person and the defence lawyer in criminal proceedings.
It had to be
procedural in the way
rule 49, which favours plaintiffs in the allocation
of costs after trial, is a «thumb on the scale» intended to encourage defendants to settle out
of court.
(See Akazaki, «Peering over the plaintiffs» and defendants» parapets: Redesigning Ontario
Rule 49 to Encourage Meaningful Offers of Settlement,» The Advocates» Quarterly: 30:285) A rule that guides the court's process must be characterized as procedural, compared to one that contemplates evidence - based awards of compensa
Rule 49 to Encourage Meaningful Offers
of Settlement,» The Advocates» Quarterly: 30:285) A
rule that guides the court's process must be characterized as procedural, compared to one that contemplates evidence - based awards of compensa
rule that guides the
court's process must be characterized as
procedural, compared to one that contemplates evidence - based awards
of compensation
Smith argued that the mere fact that
courts of different sovereignty would decide the motions made the issues to be determined different, because the second
court must have the opportunity to construe differently its
procedural rule.
The answer said the
court, is that where a judge finds there is a gap in existing
procedural rules or practice direction which needs to be filled to make a decision possible, s / he can make it part
of the
court's judgement to fill that gap.