"Prosecutorial discretion" means the power of prosecutors to make decisions about how they handle criminal cases, like whether to charge someone, negotiate a plea deal, or drop charges. It allows them to use their judgment based on factors like the seriousness of the offense, available evidence, and the best use of limited resources.
Full definition
It applies prospectively to the exercise
of prosecutorial discretion in future cases and does not provide defendants or subjects of enforcement action with a basis for reconsideration of any pending civil action or criminal prosecution.
These include legislation, prosecutorial charging guidelines, court challenges, jury nullification, the exercise of
prosecutorial discretion in the absence of offence - specific charging guidelines, and the exercise of judicial discretion in sentencing.
I spoke with Rob Breakenridge about Quebec's «right to die» legislation and a timely Supreme Court of Canada case
on prosecutorial discretion.
I am very pleased to hear of these developments, though I can not resist noting that I urged them nearly a decade ago in at a symposium
about prosecutorial discretion at Temple School of Law.
Question: What records must charter schools provide to help current and former students meet the requirements of President Obama's June 15, 2012 executive order regarding the execution of
prosecutorial discretion with respect to individuals who came to the United States as children?
Attorneys with the Capital Area Immigrant Rights (Cair) Coalition, who met with more than 70 other launched detainees with lowered sentences, say he has one of the greatest cases for
prosecutorial discretion as detailed in a 2014 memo by the head of the Department of Homeland Security.
The Report concluded that the wide latitude
for prosecutorial discretion, and the absence of judicial accountability, presented opportunities for abuse.
A prosecutor can decide as a matter of
prosecutorial discretion not to press charges in stale cases even if the prosecutor has the legal authority to do so.
But what relief exists in cases
where Prosecutorial Discretion might be used to protect people who are powerful, influential, and / or friends of the Court?
As for
how prosecutorial discretion should be exercised regarding Spitzer, it is interesting to think about how he might have answered the question in similar circumstances just a few years ago.
Again, I'm not
arguing prosecutorial discretion, again, I agree with you... but how you can implicitly endorse fucking someone up (and using TLO to do it) is beyond me.
(BTW, prosecutors are the only ones who
think prosecutorial discretion protects the innocents, so a citizen doesn't have much more protection - at least before charges are filed - than someone who is e-shamed.
And that's not really an invitation to argue about
prosecutorial discretion because, again, I disagree with the DA, but how about just don't tell us to fuck up people?
«In an August 2013 memo, the Department of Justice signaled that law enforcement agencies should
use prosecutorial discretion in cases involving legalized marijuana,» Schumer and Gillibrand wrote in the letter to outgoing US Attorney General Eric Holder.
The
term prosecutorial discretion is commonly used to describe the wide latitude that prosecutors have in determining when, whom, how, and even whether to prosecute apparent violations of the law.
However, standing to challenge alleged violations of the Take Care Clause may be limited, and no court appears to have invalidated a policy of non-enforcement founded
upon prosecutorial discretion on the grounds that the policy violated the Take Care Clause.
The president pointed to executive orders issued by Democratic and Republican predecessors and said presidents exercise «
prosecutorial discretion all the time.»
Students who have been
granted prosecutorial discretion through Deferred Action, Stay of Removal or various forms of temporary humanitarian relief but are unable to fully legalize their status.
Importance: Recently the Supreme Court of Canada in R. v. Anderson, 2014 SCC 41 at para. 44
described prosecutorial discretion as «an expansive term that covers all decisions regarding the nature and extent of the prosecution and the Attorney General's participation in it».
The authority of a prosecutor to prosecute a crime over the objections of the victim, or to decline to prosecute a crime despite a victim's insistence that it be prosecuted (even when the victim can prove that the crime was committed by someone) is
called prosecutorial discretion and is very nearly absolute in U.S. criminal law jurisprudence.
Kids in hot cars is a specialized niche in case law, so I don't think one can learn much about the nature of
prosecutorial discretion from focusing just on those cases (Lexis gives me over 1000 cases involving «negligent homicide» and only 185 of them are about children; 85 of those are about cars; 6 are about anything hot).
This means that whatever factors
affect prosecutorial discretion (such as the prosecutor knowing who they have to work with on other days) can become significant in the determination.
The plan relies on the President's
prosecutorial discretion authority, recognizing that immigration enforcement is necessarily selective and that Congress funds capacity for about 400,000 deportations each year.
We will discuss enforcement practices, risk assessment for clients, and arguments and strategies for advocates to
obtain prosecutorial discretion for your clients.
Absent such an obligation, the prosecutor's decision is a matter of
prosecutorial discretion which is reviewable by the courts only for abuse of process.
The latest information on addressing removal issues
including prosecutorial discretion, issues that can appealed or waived and using U nonimmigrant status as a relief from removal or a means to terminate proceedings
The defendants resisted disclosure of certain documents on the authority of R. v. Anderson (SCC 2014), which was said to have established a broad rule imposing a «threshold evidentiary burden» on a party
challenging prosecutorial discretion.